Export finance is the business of lending to a foreign buyer so that it can pay a domestic exporter, with most of the credit risk transferred to a state. The state acts through its export credit agency (ECA): Bpifrance Assurance Export in France, Euler Hermes for the German federal government, SACE in Italy, UK Export Finance, EKN in Sweden, US EXIM, K-SURE and KEXIM in Korea, NEXI and JBIC in Japan. The bank brings the money, the structuring and the administration; the ECA brings an insurance policy or a guarantee covering 95% to 100% of the loan against non-payment for political or commercial reasons.
The desk sits in Corporate Banking, next to trade finance (see B11) and project finance (see B06, B07). It has two sets of clients. The exporters are the bank’s corporate clients: turbine makers, engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) contractors, shipyards, rail and telecom equipment suppliers. They want to win a contract, and a financing offer attached to the bid is often what wins it. The borrowers are the exporters’ customers: ministries of finance, state utilities, private project companies, airlines and shipowners, often in countries where no bank would lend for fifteen years on its own name.
How the desk earns money. A covered loan pays a margin over EURIBOR or SOFR that, as an order of magnitude, sits between 50 and 150 bp depending on tenor, currency and the quality of the cover, an arrangement fee of roughly 50 to 150 bp flat, a commitment fee on undrawn amounts during construction, and an annual agency fee. The margin looks thin for an eighteen-year loan to a single-B country, and it is: the bank is in fact lending to its own government for 95% of the amount. The business works because the covered part carries a risk weight of zero or close to it, so that a small margin on a large amount is set against a small amount of capital. We will see in section 5.9 that Meridian’s EUR 236m loan to Tanesi Power earns about EUR 2.0m a year and returns 31% on regulatory capital, and in section 6 why that figure flatters the business: the scarce resources are long-term funding and people, not RWA.
WHO DOES WHAT — The export finance originator follows the exporters and their tender pipeline and issues the financing offer. The ECA structurer knows the rulebook (the OECD Arrangement) and each agency’s policy wording, negotiates the cover and sizes the loan. The coverage banker owns the exporter relationship; a country or public-sector banker may own the borrower. The credit analyst and the country risk team write the application: there are three limits to approve, on the borrower, on the country and on the ECA’s sovereign. The environmental and social risk management (ESRM) team runs the Equator Principles process alongside the ECA’s own specialists. Legal and external counsel draft the facility agreement and check that every clause is consistent with the policy. After signing, the loan agency (often called the ECA agent) checks the exporter’s documents before each drawing, reports to the ECA, and would file the claim. Treasury provides the long-term funding and tells the desk what it costs.
A realistic week in November 2026. Monday: call with an EPC contractor bidding for a grid-scale battery in Central Asia, which needs an indicative term sheet by Friday and asks whether twenty-two years is available. Tuesday: site-visit debrief on the Tanesi Power resettlement plan with the ECA’s environmental specialist and the independent consultant. Wednesday: credit committee for a covered loan to a ministry of finance, where the discussion is about the 5% left uncovered and the country limit. Thursday: the loan agency rejects a drawing request because the exporter’s invoice includes a local subcontract that was not declared to the ECA; an undeclared item could void the cover on that drawing. Friday: quarterly review with Treasury of the long-term funding the desk has consumed, and of how much of the portfolio can go into the covered-bond pool.
A transaction takes nine to eighteen months from the first term sheet to the first drawing. A junior on the desk does the content calculations, premium estimates, repayment schedules, interest-rate comparisons and drawdown controls: the calculations of this module.
IN ONE SENTENCE — An ECA-covered buyer credit is a bank loan to a foreign buyer, disbursed directly to the exporter, on which a state promises to pay the bank if the buyer does not.
INTUITION — A parent co-signs the lease of a student’s flat. The landlord (the bank) deals with the student (the foreign buyer) every month, but sets the rent as if the parent were the tenant. The parent charges the student a fee for the signature (the premium), reads the lease before signing (the policy conditions), and will only pay if the landlord has followed the lease to the letter.
Four structures share the market.
In a supplier credit, the exporter itself grants deferred payment terms to its buyer, usually documented by promissory notes or bills of exchange. The exporter takes out a supplier-credit policy with the ECA and then sells the notes to a bank without recourse (forfaiting). It suits small contracts and short tenors.
In a buyer credit, the bank signs a loan agreement with the buyer, or with the buyer’s bank or ministry of finance. The loan never passes through the borrower’s hands: each drawing is paid to the exporter against documents proving that goods were shipped or milestones reached. The exporter is paid in cash and bears no credit risk; the bank holds the policy. This is the standard format above roughly EUR 10m, and the one of our case.
Pure cover means the ECA only insures or guarantees and a commercial bank lends. Direct lending means the ECA, or a public bank next to it, lends itself: US EXIM, Export Development Canada, KEXIM, JBIC and the direct lending facility of UK Export Finance do so. The NZECA progress report of November 2025 puts the product mix of its member agencies at about three quarters insurance and guarantees and one quarter direct lending. In continental Europe pure cover dominates, sometimes combined with a public refinancing scheme (section 6.3).
Insurance or guarantee: an insurance policy (the Bpifrance and Euler Hermes tradition) pays a percentage of the loss, typically 95%, after a claims waiting period, provided the bank has complied with the policy. A guarantee (UK Export Finance, US EXIM) is closer to an unconditional, on-demand commitment for 100%. The difference matters for capital: prudential rules want credit protection to be direct, explicit, irrevocable and unconditional, and each policy form has had to be read against that test (section 6.1).
What is covered: political risks (transfer and convertibility restrictions, expropriation, war, moratorium) and commercial risks (insolvency or protracted default of the borrower). What is not: the bank’s own documentation mistakes, drawings made outside the terms notified to the ECA, and disputes between exporter and buyer, which is why the loan agreement contains an “isabel clause” making the borrower’s obligation to repay independent of the commercial contract.
Left to themselves, governments would compete for export contracts with ever longer and cheaper credit. Since 1978 the Arrangement on Officially Supported Export Credits has set a floor under that competition. It is a gentlemen’s agreement among eleven Participants (Australia, Canada, the European Union, Japan, Korea, New Zealand, Norway, Switzerland, Türkiye, the United Kingdom and the United States), hosted by the OECD but not an OECD act; in the European Union it is made binding by Regulation (EU) No 1233/2011 and the delegated acts that update it. The prevailing text is dated January 2026. China, India and other large exporters are not Participants, which is the oldest weakness of the system.
The Arrangement applies to official support with a repayment term of two years or more. Its main disciplines are these:
| Discipline | Rule in the prevailing text | Why it exists |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment | At least 15% of the export contract value, paid at or before the starting point of credit | The buyer keeps skin in the game |
| Maximum official support | 85% of the export contract value, plus local costs up to 40% of that value in high-income OECD countries and 50% elsewhere | Limits the subsidy |
| Maximum repayment term | 15 years in general; 12 years for conventional power plants; up to 22 years under the climate and nuclear sector understandings | Tenor is the main competitive weapon |
| Repayment profile | Equal principal instalments at least annually, first one within a year of the starting point; flexibilities when justified | No bullet loans, no back-loading |
| Minimum price | A minimum premium rate (MPR) for credit risk; a minimum fixed rate (CIRR) when the state supports the interest rate | Risk must be paid for |
The modernisation agreed in March 2023 and in force since 15 July 2023 rewrote several of these numbers: the general maximum term went from 8.5 or 10 years to 15, the country distinction for tenors was removed, repayment profiles became more flexible, premiums for long tenors and weak obligors were reduced, and the Climate Change Sector Understanding (section 3) was widened. Separate sector understandings govern ships, aircraft, nuclear plants and rail.
The starting point of credit deserves a sentence because every clock runs from it. For a turnkey plant it is the date on which the buyer takes over the plant, in practice the commissioning date fixed in the contract. Drawings happen before it, during construction; repayments happen after it.
IN ONE SENTENCE — A standard export credit repays principal in equal instalments every six months, so interest falls steadily and the borrower’s debt service is heaviest in the first year.
FORMULA
is the loan amount at the starting point of credit; the number of semi-annual instalments; the principal instalment; the interest paid at instalment ; the annual interest rate; the weighted average life in years measured from the starting point, which for equal semi-annual instalments is the average of the first date (0.5 year) and the last ( years).
Take EUR 100m repaid over ten years at 4%. Each instalment repays EUR 5m. The first year costs EUR 13.9m (EUR 10m of principal and EUR 3.9m of interest), the weighted average life is 5.25 years and total interest is EUR 21.0m. An annuity profile, with constant total payments as in a mortgage, would cost EUR 12.23m every year: lighter at the start, heavier at the end, with a longer average life of 5.58 years and EUR 22.31m of interest. The Arrangement treats equal principal as the norm. Since 2023 a tailored profile is allowed when the project’s cash flows justify it, within limits: no more than 30% of principal in any six months, a first repayment within 24 months of the starting point, and a weighted average life no longer than the greater of 65% of the repayment term and six years (35%, 36 months and 70% for most climate projects).
INTERACTIVE LAB — Repayment profile of an export credit: equal principal against annuity
Compare the debt service, weighted average life and total interest of the standard equal-principal profile with an annuity profile.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Loan at starting point of credit | 10 to 500 EUR m | 100 EUR m |
| Repayment term | 2 to 22 years | 10 years |
| Interest rate | 0 to 10 % | 4 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Semi-annual principal instalment (equal principal) | 5.000 EUR m |
| First-year debt service, equal principal | 13.900 EUR m |
| First-year debt service, annuity | 12.231 EUR m |
| Weighted average life, equal principal | 5.25 years |
| Weighted average life, annuity | 5.58 years |
| Total interest, equal principal | 21.00 EUR m |
| Total interest, annuity | 22.31 EUR m |
| Maximum WAL under the general flexibility (65% of term or 6 years) | 6.50 years |
Try it. Lengthen the term from 10 to 18 years: first-year debt service falls by about a third, while total interest nearly doubles.
IN ONE SENTENCE — The premium is the price of the ECA’s cover, paid by the borrower, usually in one amount at the start, and it cannot be lower than a minimum that depends on the country, the obligor, the duration of the risk and the quality of the cover.
The OECD classifies countries into eight risk categories, from 0 (negligible) to 7, with a quantitative model reviewed by country-risk experts several times a year. Obligors are then placed in buyer-risk categories relative to their sovereign: SOV/CC0 for the sovereign and entities that commit its full faith and credit, then CC1 (very good) to CC5 (weak). For categories 1 to 7 the Arrangement gives a formula for the minimum premium rate, expressed as a percentage of principal as if paid in full at the first drawing. For category 0 and high-income countries there is no formula: the premium must not undercut market pricing, using benchmarks such as bond or CDS spreads.
FORMULA
and are the country-risk coefficients of category ; is the horizon of risk in years, equal to half the disbursement period plus the repayment period; and are the percentages of cover for commercial and political risk; is a discount of up to 0.2 for local-currency financing; is the buyer-risk coefficient, zero for a sovereign obligor; is a credit-enhancement factor of at most 0.35 for security such as escrow accounts; is the quality-of-product factor (1 for standard insurance, slightly above for guarantees); is a surcharge when cover exceeds 95%; is 0.9 for the rare obligor rated better than its sovereign; is the term adjustment introduced in 2023, a discount capped at 15% for speculative-grade obligors when the horizon of risk exceeds ten years.
| Category | 1 | 3 | 5 | 7 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (per year of HOR) | 0.090 | 0.350 | 0.740 | 1.100 |
| (constant) | 0.350 | 0.350 | 0.750 | 1.800 |
(The other categories: 2 has 0.200 and 0.350; 4 has 0.550 and 0.350; 6 has 0.900 and 1.200.)
Term by term. The first bracket is country risk: a fixed entry cost plus a cost per year . The second is the extra risk of a buyer weaker than its sovereign. The factors after the bracket adjust for what the bank actually receives: more than 95% cover, or an on-demand guarantee, costs more. An example: a ministry of finance in a category 3 country, one year of disbursement, ten years of repayment, 95% standard cover. The horizon of risk is 10.5 years and the MPR is of principal, paid upfront. The same loan in category 5 costs 8.44% and in category 7 13.23%, after the term adjustment.
INTERACTIVE LAB — OECD minimum premium rate for country categories 1 to 7
Compute the minimum premium rate from the country category, the buyer category, the horizon of risk and the percentage of cover, and see how it grows with the repayment term.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| OECD country risk category | 1 / 2 / 3 / 4 / 5 / 6 / 7 | 3 |
| Buyer risk category | SOV/CC0 / CC1 / CC2 | SOV/CC0 |
| Disbursement period | 0 to 5 years | 1 years |
| Repayment term | 2 to 22 years | 10 years |
| Percentage of cover (political and commercial) | 85 to 100 % | 95 % |
| Quality of product | below standard / standard / above standard | standard |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Horizon of risk | 10.50 years |
| Term adjustment (categories 5 to 7 only in this model) | 0.00 % |
| Minimum premium rate, upfront | 4.0250 % of principal |
| MPR divided by horizon of risk | 38.3 bp per year |
Try it. Raise the cover from 95% to 100% in category 5: the premium rises by about 9% of itself, because cover above 95% is charged both pro rata and through a surcharge.
PITFALL — The MPR is a floor, not a tariff. Each ECA has its own pricing system and may charge more, for instance for a weak private buyer or a long pre-credit period. It is also quoted flat and upfront: 4.025% is not 4.025% a year. Spread over the life of the loan it is closer to 75 bp a year, the same order as the bank’s margin.
The borrower chooses between a floating rate (EURIBOR or SOFR plus the bank’s margin), which it may swap, and, where the exporter’s country offers it, a fixed rate under an official interest-support scheme. That fixed rate cannot be lower than the Commercial Interest Reference Rate (CIRR) of the currency.
Since the reform that took effect in July 2023, the CIRR is a base rate plus a margin. The base rate is the yield of government bonds whose maturity equals the drawdown period plus half the repayment period plus half the interval between instalments, rounded to the nearest year and kept between 3 and 10 years. The margin formula is half of the average five-year swap spread plus 80 bp, bounded between 80 and 120 bp; in practice a transitional footnote has kept it at 100 bp, and the January 2026 text removed the end date of that footnote. CIRRs are published monthly, on the 15th. A borrower may lock the rate up to twelve months before signing, for a surcharge of 20 bp for up to six months, rising to 44 bp for twelve.
WHY IT MATTERS ON THE DESK — The CIRR is a free option on rates for the borrower during the tender. When rates rise between bid and signing, a CIRR fixed at bid date can be worth several percent of the contract; when they fall, the borrower drops it and takes the market rate. The structurer must know every month which side of the market the CIRR is on. In section 5.5 it is on the wrong side.
The bank’s risks are not where a newcomer looks for them. The borrower’s default is, for 95%, the state’s problem. What can hurt the bank is losing the cover.
Documentary risk. The policy covers a loan made on the notified terms for goods of the declared origin. A drawing paid against non-conforming documents, a waiver granted without the ECA’s consent, or a late notification of a missed payment can each void or reduce the indemnity. The loan agency’s checklist is the first risk control of the desk.
Residual risk. The uncovered 5% is a long-dated exposure to a weak borrower, and it is what consumes capital (section 6).
Sovereign risk on the ECA. The covered part is an exposure to the ECA’s state. It counts in the bank’s sovereign limits and, for some states and currencies, carries a non-zero risk weight.
Funding and rate risk. Eighteen-year money is expensive and prepayment is possible; break costs must be documented.
The documents: the commercial contract between exporter and buyer; the facility agreement between bank and borrower, usually on a Loan Market Association base adapted for export finance; the ECA policy or guarantee, with its general and special conditions; where relevant a ministry of finance guarantee and the legal opinions on it; an exporter’s undertaking, by which the exporter confirms to the bank the origin of the goods and accepts recourse if its own misrepresentation costs the bank its cover; and the qualifying certificates presented at each drawing.
Export finance does not have a “green product” in the way bond markets do. What it has is a public rulebook whose terms now differ according to what is being exported. The sustainable layer comes in four parts: better terms for climate-friendly projects, prohibitions, mandatory environmental and social due diligence, and voluntary labels and alliances.
IN ONE SENTENCE — The Climate Change Sector Understanding (CCSU) is the annex of the Arrangement that allows longer repayment terms and more flexible profiles for listed classes of climate-friendly projects.
Created in 2012 for renewable energy and water projects, the CCSU was widened in the 2023 modernisation. Its Appendix I lists project classes with eligibility criteria and a maximum repayment term for each:
| Project class (examples) | Maximum repayment term |
|---|---|
| A-1 Renewable energy, including solar photovoltaic | 22 years |
| D Carbon capture, storage and transport; E-1 Energy management, transmission, distribution and grid-scale storage; E-2 Battery production and recycling | 22 years |
| F Clean hydrogen and ammonia | 22 years (tier 1) or 18 years (tier 2) |
| G Low-emissions manufacturing; I Clean energy minerals and ores | 22 years |
| H Zero- and low-emissions transport | 18 to 22 years by type |
| B-1 Fossil fuel plants with carbon capture | 18 years |
| B-2 Waste to energy; C Combined heat and power, district heating, smart grids | 15 years |
Climate adaptation projects and water projects are also eligible for 22 years. Compare with the 12 years available to a conventional power plant: for a solar plant the CCSU nearly doubles the available tenor. The flexibilities on the repayment profile are also wider than in the general rules (first principal repayment up to 36 months after the starting point, weighted average life up to 70% of the term). The 2023 package did not create a “green premium discount”: the reductions for long horizons of risk and weak obligors apply to all projects, but they are worth most on the long tenors that only CCSU projects can reach.
PITFALL — Tenor is not a gift. A longer horizon of risk raises the premium, lengthens the bank’s funding and extends the period during which the plant must perform. Section 5.4 puts numbers on the trade-off: six more years cut the first-year debt service by 21% and add EUR 5.8m of premium.
Article 6 of the Arrangement, in force since 1 November 2021, prohibits official export credits and tied aid for new unabated coal-fired power plants and for equipment supplied to existing ones, with exceptions for carbon capture and for pollution abatement that does not extend the plant’s life. That is the only fossil-fuel prohibition in the rulebook.
Attempts to go further have failed so far. Talks on Article 6 opened in 2023; a European Union proposal to restrict support for oil and gas to limited circumstances was discussed through November and December 2024 and did not reach consensus. In November 2025 the EU, Australia, Norway, Switzerland and the United Kingdom signed a voluntary joint statement committing to publish their energy-sector export credits by type of energy, which the Council of the EU itself describes as a first step and not a restriction. The Council conclusions of 12 June 2026 restate that EU ECAs have committed to end official support for fossil-fuel energy projects and ask the EU to lead a second phase of modernisation, whose agenda is about tied aid, non-concessional finance and transparency.
Restrictions therefore come from national policies, which differ. Signatories of the Glasgow statement of November 2021 (the Clean Energy Transition Partnership) undertook to end new direct public support for the international unabated fossil-fuel energy sector by the end of 2022, with exceptions that each country defined. The German climate strategy for export credit guarantees, in force since 1 November 2023, sorts transactions in key sectors into green, white and red categories against a 1.5°C pathway and excludes the red ones. A structurer must check the policy of the specific ECA at the date of application, not a summary.
IN ONE SENTENCE — The Common Approaches are the OECD recommendation that obliges ECAs to screen, classify and review the environmental and social impacts of the projects they support before committing.
The Recommendation on Common Approaches for Officially Supported Export Credits and Environmental and Social Due Diligence dates from 2003 in its first form, was substantially revised in 2012 and 2016 (when human rights were made explicit), and was amended again in 2024, when the benchmarks were updated and the IFC Performance Standards were proposed as the default reference. It applies to export credits with a repayment term of two years or more. Its mechanics:
The bank runs a parallel process. Meridian is a signatory of the Equator Principles (fourth version, EP4, applicable since October 2020), which cover project finance and also project-related corporate loans, a definition that expressly includes export finance in the form of buyer credit when the loan is mostly for one project that the borrower controls, the total loan and the bank’s own commitment are each at least USD 50 million, and the tenor is at least two years. The categories (A, B, C) and the benchmark (IFC Performance Standards in non-designated countries) are the same as the ECA’s, so the two processes share one independent consultant and one action plan. A third text matters when the borrower is a low-income sovereign: the OECD Recommendation on Sustainable Lending Practices, under which ECAs take account of the debt-sustainability limits agreed between the country and the IMF and World Bank.
Within the Arrangement’s limits, each state decides its own cover percentage, content rules and appetite. Several have used those levers for green projects:
NOTE — None of these incentives lowers the minimum premium rate: the Arrangement does not allow it. What they change is eligibility (content), the share of risk left with the bank (cover) and convenience (local costs, currency). In our case the content rule is what makes the deal possible at all.
A classic export credit is tied: it finances a named export contract. Since about 2020 several ECAs have developed untied guarantees, which cover a loan to a foreign company or a strategic project without an underlying export contract, in exchange for a broader national interest. SACE’s Push Strategy guarantees loans to large foreign buyers that agree to meet Italian suppliers through organised matchmaking. Germany’s untied loan guarantees (UFK) support projects that secure raw-material supply for German industry under long-term offtake contracts, and have been used for transition minerals.
Untied cover is officially outside the Arrangement’s terms, since it is not export credit, and should be priced on market terms. That is exactly why it is debated: transparency over “official support outside the Arrangement” is on the agenda of the second modernisation phase. For the bank the mechanics are close to a covered corporate loan (see B02), with a sovereign guarantor; the green angle, where there is one, comes from the use of proceeds or from the raw material secured.
A covered buyer credit for a solar plant can be labelled a green loan under the Green Loan Principles (LMA, APLMA and LSTA; last updated in March 2025; we rely on public summaries): use of proceeds is identified by construction, project evaluation is done twice over, proceeds are paid directly to the exporter, and reporting can draw on the monitoring already required. The label costs little and changes no cash flow. Its use is to let the borrower and the bank count the loan in their green frameworks, and to make the loan eligible as collateral for the bank’s green bonds (see C01).
Two alliances frame the agencies’ own commitments: Export Finance for Future (E3F), a coalition of European states launched in April 2021, and the Net-Zero Export Credit Agencies Alliance (NZECA), launched at COP28 in December 2023 with UNEP FI (figures in section 8).
On the bank’s side, what bites is not specific to export finance: the sector policies and exclusion lists of the bank (see A05), the EU Taxonomy and the Green Asset Ratio, Pillar 3 ESG disclosures and financed emissions (section 6.5), and the supply-chain concerns of solar and batteries, including the EU Forced Labour Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2024/3015), which will prohibit products made with forced labour on the EU market and for export from the EU from 14 December 2027.
INTERACTIVE LAB — An ECA-covered buyer credit from tender to final repayment
Follow the transaction through the bank, the exporter, the ECA and the borrower, with the document produced at each step.
| # | Who | Does what | Deliverable |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Exporter’s sales and export finance team, with Meridian’s export finance originator | Attach a financing offer to the bid; Meridian sizes an indicative buyer credit and checks the ECA’s country policy | Indicative term sheet and letter of support |
| 2 | ECA underwriter | Gives a preliminary view on the country, the obligor, content and eligibility for climate terms | Letter of interest with premium indication |
| 3 | Borrower and its ministry of finance | Award the contract, mandate the bank and confirm the debt is within the public borrowing plan | Mandate letter; signed commercial contract |
| 4 | Exporter and Meridian’s ECA structurer | File the application for cover with the content declaration and the environmental and social questionnaire | Application for cover |
| 5 | ECA environmental and social specialists; Meridian ESRM; independent consultant | Screen and classify the project, review the ESIA against the IFC Performance Standards, visit the site, agree the action plan | Classification; due diligence report; ESAP |
| 6 | ECA | Publishes project information and the ESIA of a Category A project at least 30 days before final commitment | Ex ante disclosure notice |
| 7 | Meridian credit analyst, country risk and credit committee | Approve limits on the borrower, the country and the ECA’s sovereign; approve the uncovered share and the tenor | Credit approval with conditions |
| 8 | ECA credit committee or interministerial committee | Takes the final commitment and sets the premium | Offer of cover, then policy with special conditions |
| 9 | Legal and external counsel | Align the facility agreement, the ministry of finance guarantee and the policy; obtain legal opinions | Facility agreement; guarantee; opinions |
| 10 | Borrower, Meridian, exporter | Sign; satisfy conditions precedent; pay the down payment and the premium | CP satisfaction letter; premium receipt |
| 11 | Meridian loan agency (ECA agent) | Checks each qualifying certificate and invoice, pays the exporter directly, reports drawings to the ECA | Drawdown notices; disbursement reports |
| 12 | Exporter and borrower | Commission the plant: the starting point of credit; the repayment schedule is fixed | Taking-over certificate; final repayment schedule |
| 13 | Loan agency, ESRM, ECA | Collect instalments every six months; monitor the action plan and covenants; report annually | Monitoring reports; ECA reporting |
| 14 | Loan agency and ECA claims department | If an instalment is missed: notify within the policy deadline, wait the claims period, file the claim, pursue recovery together | Notice of default; claim file; indemnity |
Steps 1 to 3: before the contract. The bank is involved early because financing is a bid criterion. The indicative term sheet states the financed share, tenor, repayment profile, interest options, margin, fees and an estimated premium. It is given “subject to credit approval and ECA cover”, but the exporter will hold the bank to its spirit. The first control is the eligibility check: is the country open at this ECA (many have ceilings per country), is the product excluded by Article 6 or by national policy, and does the contract meet the content rules. On the borrower’s side a sovereign or state-guaranteed loan needs a place in the public borrowing plan and, in countries under an IMF programme, must respect the limits on non-concessional debt.
Steps 4 to 6: the application and the environmental and social review. The application is filed by the exporter (for the content and the contract) and by the bank (for the loan). The environmental and social questionnaire triggers screening. For a Category A project, the critical path of the whole deal runs through here: the ESIA must exist, meet international standards and be disclosed for 30 days before the ECA can commit. A missing resettlement plan can cost six months. The bank’s ESRM team documents its own Equator Principles categorisation and relies on the same independent consultant, whose scope is agreed jointly.
Steps 7 and 8: two credit decisions. Meridian’s credit application covers three counterparties. On the borrower: the 5% residual risk, for eighteen years. On the country: the full amount, because transfer risk and documentary risk exist until the ECA pays. On the ECA’s sovereign: 95% of the amount. The committee also approves the policy wording, since capital relief depends on it (section 6.1). The ECA’s decision follows its own governance; for large amounts the ministry of finance of the exporter’s country decides. The offer of cover fixes the premium, the cover percentage and the special conditions, including environmental and social covenants.
Steps 9 and 10: documentation and signing. The facility agreement must mirror the policy: same amounts, same drawing conditions, same repayment schedule, and an obligation on the bank to obtain the ECA’s consent before any amendment or waiver. Conditions precedent include the down payment (proof that 15% of the contract value has been paid to the exporter), the legal opinions, the effectiveness of the guarantee, and the payment of the premium, which in our case is financed by the first drawing.
Steps 11 and 12: drawings and the starting point. Each drawing is requested by the exporter with a qualifying certificate countersigned by the borrower. The agency checks amounts, dates, origin declarations and cumulative local costs against the limits notified to the ECA, then pays the exporter directly (or reimburses the borrower for payments already made). A commitment fee runs on the undrawn amount. At commissioning the taking-over certificate fixes the starting point of credit; the first instalment falls six months later.
Steps 13 and 14: the long tail. For eighteen years the agency collects, reports and seeks the ECA’s consent for any change. ESRM follows the action plan through the consultant’s monitoring reports, six-monthly during construction and annual in operation. If the borrower misses a payment, the policy sets a notification deadline (often 30 days) and a claims waiting period (commonly three to six months) after which the ECA pays the covered share of each missed instalment, usually as it falls due and not by acceleration. Recoveries, for a sovereign often through a Paris Club rescheduling, are shared 95/5.
Question. What is being financed, for whom, and what does the borrower ask of the bank?
Tanesi Power is the state-owned electricity utility of an East African country that we do not name, since the case is fictional. The country is rated single-B and, by case assumption, classified in OECD country risk category 5. Its grid relies on hydropower, increasingly erratic, and on diesel and heavy-fuel-oil plants that run in the evening peak. Tanesi tendered a 150 MWp solar photovoltaic plant with a 300 MWh battery energy storage system, so that part of the midday output can be delivered in the evening. The contract was awarded in March 2026 to Solventis Energy, a euro-area EPC contractor and long-standing client of Meridian, whose bid included a financing offer arranged by the bank.
| Item | Case data |
|---|---|
| Export contract (design, modules, inverters, batteries, energy management system, substation, commissioning) | EUR 200m |
| Local costs (civil works, access road, local labour, 25 km line) | EUR 40m |
| Solventis’s national content / foreign content | EUR 76m / EUR 124m |
| Construction and disbursement period | 24 months; commissioning November 2028 |
| Expected net energy delivered | 280 GWh a year |
| Borrower / guarantor | Tanesi Power / Ministry of Finance |
| Cover | ECA of Solventis’s home state (euro-area sovereign rated AA), 95% of political and commercial risk, insurance policy |
The Ministry of Finance guarantee places the obligor in the SOV/CC0 buyer category. Tanesi asks for the longest tenor available, a fixed rate, and a financing of the ECA premium, because its investment budget is limited to EUR 50m. Meridian is sole mandated lead arranger, lender and ECA agent. The facility agreement is signed on 16 November 2026.
Why an export credit and not something else? Tanesi’s alternatives were three. A concessional loan from a development bank would have been cheaper, but the country’s allocation was committed to transmission and rural access for the next three years. An independent power producer could have built the plant and sold the power under a long-term contract, but the government wanted to own the storage, which it sees as a system asset, and earlier private projects had required sovereign guarantees anyway. A Eurobond was out of reach at this tenor. The buyer credit is the instrument that remains when a state wants to own an imported asset and pay for it over its life. For Solventis the logic is simpler: two of its three competitors in the tender came with a financing offer backed by their own state.
The credit question for Meridian is correspondingly narrow. Tanesi’s own accounts are weak (tariffs below cost, receivables from public bodies), so the analysis rests on the Ministry of Finance guarantee and therefore on the sovereign: public debt, the share owed to official creditors, the IMF programme and its limit on non-concessional borrowing, into which this loan was explicitly fitted. The plant’s economics matter to the country’s decision; they do not service the debt in a legal sense.
Question. How much can the ECA support and Meridian lend?
Three tests apply. First, the down payment: 15% of the export contract value, EUR 30m, must be paid by Tanesi from its own resources. Official support is limited to the remaining 85%, EUR 170m. Second, local costs: the host country is not a high-income OECD country, so local costs may be supported up to 50% of the export contract value, EUR 100m. The EUR 40m of local works fit easily and are financed in full. Third, content: Solventis designs the plant and manufactures the power conversion and energy management systems at home, but the modules and battery cells come from Asia. Foreign content is EUR 124m, or 62% of the contract.
CASE — The base loan is EUR 170m + EUR 40m = EUR 210m, or 87.5% of the EUR 240m of contract value and local costs. The ECA’s general rule accepts up to 50% of foreign content; its climate policy raises the ceiling to 70% for projects in its green category (case assumption, modelled on the German rule of November 2023). At 62% the contract fails the general rule by EUR 24m of foreign supply and passes the green one with EUR 16m of headroom.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Sizing an ECA-covered buyer credit
Derive the maximum supported amount from the export contract value, the down payment, the local-cost limit and the foreign-content ceiling.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Export contract value | 20 to 1000 EUR m | 200 EUR m |
| Down payment | 15 to 40 % of contract | 15 % of contract |
| Local costs to be financed | 0 to 300 EUR m | 40 EUR m |
| Host country group for local costs | Category II (50%) / Category I high-income OECD (40%) | Category II (50%) |
| Foreign content in the export contract | 0 to 1000 EUR m | 124 EUR m |
| ECA ceiling on foreign content | 50 / 70 | 70 |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Down payment paid by the buyer | 30.00 EUR m |
| Supported share of the export contract | 170.00 EUR m |
| Local-cost limit | 100.00 EUR m |
| Local costs supported | 40.00 EUR m |
| Base loan before premium | 210.00 EUR m |
| Base loan as share of contract plus local costs | 87.5 % |
| Foreign content | 62.0 % of contract |
| Headroom under the ceiling (negative: ineligible) | 16.0 EUR m |
Try it. Switch the ceiling to 50%: without the green category the contract is ineligible, or cover is cut back, and Solventis must re-source EUR 24m of supply.
How the content figure is built matters, because the exporter signs for it. Solventis’s declaration lists every lot of the contract with its origin: engineering, project management, the power conversion system, the energy management software, medium-voltage equipment and commissioning are national, EUR 76m in all; photovoltaic modules (EUR 52m), battery cells and racks (EUR 58m), trackers and cabling (EUR 14m) are foreign. Local works are not content at all: they are local costs, counted under their own limit. The structurer checks the declaration against the price schedule of the contract, and the exporter’s undertaking gives the bank recourse if it proves wrong.
Reading. The most valuable green incentive in this deal is neither a price nor a tenor. A European solar-plus-storage contract contains mostly Asian hardware; under the ordinary content rule it could not be covered in full. This is where the industrial reality of the energy transition meets export policy, and it is contested: taxpayers of the exporter’s country insure a contract of which 62% is produced elsewhere.
Question. What does the cover cost, and how is it paid?
The CCSU allows up to 22 years for class A-1 (solar) and class E-1 (grid-scale storage). Tanesi wanted 22; the ECA and the bank settled on 18 years, in line with the battery’s augmentation plan and the ECA’s appetite for the country. The repayment profile is standard: 36 equal semi-annual instalments, the first in May 2029.
CASE — Horizon of risk: years. Country component in category 5: . Cover is 95% with a standard product, so the cover factors equal 1; the buyer coefficient is zero for a sovereign-guaranteed obligor. Term adjustment: , capped at 15%. The minimum premium rate is of principal. On EUR 210m the premium is EUR 26.436m. Tanesi has it financed, so the loan is EUR 236.436m.
Two remarks on method. The ECA applies the rate to the base amount and covers the financed premium without charging premium on premium (case assumption; practice differs between agencies, and some gross up). And the ECA charges exactly the minimum, which is common for sovereign obligors but not guaranteed.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Tanesi Power: premium and loan amount
Apply the minimum premium rate to the Tanesi base loan and see how the premium moves with the repayment term, the country category and the percentage of cover.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Base loan | 50 to 500 EUR m | 210 EUR m |
| OECD country risk category | 3 / 4 / 5 / 6 / 7 | 5 |
| Disbursement period | 0 to 4 years | 2 years |
| Repayment term | 8 to 22 years | 18 years |
| Percentage of cover | 90 to 100 % | 95 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Horizon of risk | 19.0 years |
| Rate before term adjustment | 14.8100 % |
| Term adjustment | 15.0 % |
| Minimum premium rate | 12.5885 % of principal |
| Premium | 26.436 EUR m |
| Loan including financed premium | 236.436 EUR m |
| Premium saved by the 2023 term adjustment | 4.665 EUR m |
Try it. Set the cover to 98%, the German green-category level: the bank’s residual risk falls by 60% and the borrower pays EUR 1.4m more premium.
Could the premium have been lower? Three levers exist in the formula and none was available. Security: an offshore escrow account fed by export receipts can earn a credit-enhancement discount, but it applies to buyer risk and a utility selling in local currency has no such receipts. Local-currency financing earns a discount of up to 20% of the country component, but no bank would lend the local currency for eighteen years. A shorter tenor is the only real lever, and section 5.4 prices it. In the other direction, one notch matters a great deal: in category 6 the same loan would carry an MPR of 15.555% and a premium of EUR 32.666m.
Reading. EUR 26.4m is 11% of the contract and local costs. It is the largest single financing cost of the project, larger than the bank’s margin over the whole life (section 5.7). The 2023 term adjustment saves Tanesi EUR 4.665m: that is the only “discount” in the deal and it rewards a long horizon of risk in a weak country, whatever the project. A category 5 country pays this price for solar as it would for a road.
Question. How much does Tanesi gain from repaying over 18 years, compared with the 12 years available to a conventional power plant?
We compare the two loans at the same all-in fixed rate of 3.60% (derived in 5.5). Over 12 years the horizon of risk is 13 years, the term adjustment 5.4%, the MPR 9.81% and the loan EUR 230.601m.
| 12 years (non-CCSU) | 18 years (CCSU) | |
|---|---|---|
| Premium | EUR 20.601m | EUR 26.436m |
| Loan | EUR 230.601m | EUR 236.436m |
| First-year debt service | EUR 27.345m | EUR 21.529m |
| Per MWh delivered (280 GWh) | EUR 97.66 | EUR 76.89 |
| Total interest over the life | EUR 51.885m | EUR 78.733m |
CASE — The first-year debt service is the sum of two principal instalments (EUR 236.436m / 18 = EUR 13.135m) and interest on the declining balance (EUR 8.393m), in total EUR 21.529m. Against the 12-year loan it is 21.3% lower, or EUR 20.77 less per MWh. The price: EUR 5.835m more premium and EUR 26.848m more interest.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Tenor against premium: what the Climate Change Sector Understanding is worth
Compare debt service, premium and interest of the Tanesi loan for two repayment terms, in euros and per MWh delivered.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Repayment term under the CCSU | 13 to 22 years | 18 years |
| Reference term (12 years: conventional power plant) | 8 to 15 years | 12 years |
| All-in fixed interest rate | 1 to 8 % | 3.6 % |
| Net energy delivered | 100 to 500 GWh a year | 280 GWh a year |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Loan, CCSU term | 236.436 EUR m |
| Loan, reference term | 230.601 EUR m |
| First-year debt service, CCSU term | 21.529 EUR m |
| First-year debt service, reference term | 27.345 EUR m |
| Reduction in first-year debt service | 21.3 % |
| First-year debt service per MWh, CCSU term | 76.89 EUR |
| First-year debt service per MWh, reference term | 97.66 EUR |
| Additional premium | 5.835 EUR m |
| Total interest, CCSU term | 78.733 EUR m |
| Total interest, reference term | 51.885 EUR m |
Try it. Push the CCSU term to 22 years: the first-year debt service falls by a further EUR 1.9m, for EUR 5.3m more premium than at 18 years.
The structurer also examined the flexibilities of the CCSU. A solar plant has no ramp-up to speak of, but a first repayment 36 months after commissioning, or a sculpted profile with a weighted average life of up to 70% of the term (12.6 years, against 9.25 years for equal instalments), would have lowered the early debt service further. The ECA declined: flexibilities must be “duly justified” by a mismatch between the project’s cash flows and the standard profile, and a sovereign-guaranteed loan repaid from the budget shows none. They are designed for limited-recourse projects whose revenues build up over time (see B07). A back-loaded profile would also have lengthened the bank’s funding and the equivalent horizon of risk, and with it the premium.
Reading. A utility that sells power at a regulated tariff cares about the cash it must find each year. Moving from EUR 98 to EUR 77 per MWh of debt service in the first year brings the plant below the cost of the diesel generation it displaces in the evening, which is the argument that got the project approved. The longer tenor is not free: it costs EUR 32.7m more in premium and interest over the life. This is a reasonable trade for a 30-year asset, and it is the main thing the “green” rulebook delivers: time, not a lower price.
Question. Should Tanesi fix its rate at the CIRR?
The bond maturity for the base rate is years, rounded to 11 and capped at 10. With a ten-year euro government yield of 2.85% (case assumption) and a margin of 100 bp, the CIRR is 3.85%. Tanesi fixed nothing at bid stage; holding the rate for the six months to signing would have added 20 bp, giving 4.05%. The market alternative: Meridian lends at six-month EURIBOR plus 110 bp, and with the swap curve flat at 2.50% the borrower can fix at 3.60%.
CASE — The market fixed rate is 45 bp below the held CIRR. On the opening balance of EUR 236.436m that is EUR 1.064m of interest in the first year. Tanesi takes the floating-rate loan and Meridian’s rates desk provides the swap, which the Ministry of Finance guarantee also covers.
INTERACTIVE LAB — CIRR against a market fixed rate
Build the CIRR from the government yield, the margin and the holding surcharge, and compare it with EURIBOR swapped plus the bank’s margin.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Drawdown period | 0 to 4 years | 2 years |
| Repayment term | 2 to 22 years | 18 years |
| Government bond yield at the base maturity | 0 to 6 % | 2.85 % |
| CIRR margin | 80 to 120 bp | 100 bp |
| Holding period before signing | 0 / 6 / 12 | 6 |
| Swap rate for the loan’s profile | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Bank margin | 40 to 250 bp | 110 bp |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Bond maturity used for the base rate | 10 years |
| CIRR before holding surcharge | 3.85 % |
| CIRR with holding surcharge | 4.05 % |
| Market fixed rate (swap plus margin) | 3.60 % |
| CIRR minus market | 45.0 bp |
| First-year interest difference on EUR 236.436m | 1.064 EUR m |
Try it. Raise the swap rate to 3.50%, as if rates had risen by 100 bp between bid and signing: the CIRR locked at bid is now 55 bp cheaper than the market.
Reading. With a margin of 100 bp over government yields, the CIRR beats the market only when bank margins are high or when rates have risen since the rate was locked. Here neither holds. The honest advice to the borrower is to take the market rate, and the honest remark for the student is that the CIRR’s value lies in its optionality during the bid.
Question. What happens between signing and the starting point of credit, and what does it cost?
The loan is drawn in four half-yearly tranches that follow the milestones of the commercial contract: 20%, 30%, 30% and 20% of the EUR 210m base amount. The first drawing also finances the premium, which the ECA requires before the policy takes effect. During construction Tanesi pays interest every six months on the amount drawn, from its own funds, because the Arrangement does not allow interest to be capitalised after the starting point and the ECA did not agree to finance interest before it. It also pays a commitment fee of 40% of the margin, 44 bp a year, on the undrawn amount.
| Date | Drawing | Drawn after | Undrawn after |
|---|---|---|---|
| November 2026 | EUR 68.436m (42.000 + premium 26.436) | EUR 68.436m | EUR 168.000m |
| May 2027 | EUR 63.000m | EUR 131.436m | EUR 105.000m |
| November 2027 | EUR 63.000m | EUR 194.436m | EUR 42.000m |
| May 2028 | EUR 42.000m | EUR 236.436m | nil |
CASE — Commitment fee: 44 bp a year for six months on EUR 168m, EUR 105m and EUR 42m, in total EUR 0.693m. Interest during construction at 3.60%: EUR 11.353m over the four half-years. With the arrangement fee of EUR 1.891m, Tanesi pays EUR 13.937m of financing costs in cash before the plant produces anything, out of the EUR 18.564m of owner’s costs in its budget.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Construction period: drawings, commitment fee and interest
Follow the four drawings of the Tanesi loan and compute the commitment fee and the interest paid before the starting point of credit.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| First drawing, share of base loan | 10 to 40 % | 20 % |
| Last drawing, share of base loan | 10 to 40 % | 20 % |
| Interest rate | 1 to 8 % | 3.6 % |
| Margin | 40 to 250 bp | 110 bp |
| Commitment fee as share of margin | 20 to 50 % | 40 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| First drawing including premium | 68.436 EUR m |
| Commitment fee rate | 44.0 bp |
| Commitment fee over construction | 0.693 EUR m |
| Interest during construction | 11.353 EUR m |
| Financing costs paid in cash before commissioning, with arrangement fee | 13.938 EUR m |
Try it. Back-load the drawings (10% first, 30% last): interest during construction falls to EUR 10.2m and the commitment fee rises to EUR 0.83m, since the bank holds the money ready for longer.
Reading. Two controls sit in this stage. Each drawing is a moment when cover can be lost: the agency pays only against a qualifying certificate that matches the contract’s milestone, the origin declaration and the cumulative local-cost limit. And the starting point is a date in the contract with a long-stop: if commissioning slips beyond it, repayment starts anyway, and Tanesi would service a loan for a plant that is not yet producing. Solventis’s liquidated damages for delay are sized with that in mind, and its performance guarantee is issued by Meridian’s trade finance desk (see B11).
Question. What does the financing really cost Tanesi, premium and fees included?
Tanesi signs for EUR 236.436m but only EUR 210m pays for the plant; EUR 26.436m goes to the ECA. Meridian’s arrangement fee is 0.80% flat on the loan, EUR 1.891m, paid in cash at signing. The all-in cost is the internal rate of return of the borrower’s cash flows: EUR 210m received less the fee, then 36 instalments of principal and interest at 3.60%. To keep the calculation readable we treat the loan as fully drawn at the starting point and ignore commitment fees.
CASE — The all-in cost is 5.37% a year. Without the arrangement fee it would be 5.24%, and without the premium 3.60%. The premium therefore costs the equivalent of 164 bp a year, the bank’s margin 110 bp and the arrangement fee 13 bp. The ECA earns more on this loan than the bank.
INTERACTIVE LAB — All-in cost of the buyer credit for Tanesi Power
Compute the borrower’s internal rate of return on the cash actually received, and split the spread between the ECA premium, the bank’s margin and the arrangement fee.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Repayment term | 8 to 22 years | 18 years |
| Swap rate | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Bank margin | 40 to 250 bp | 110 bp |
| Arrangement fee, flat on the loan | 0 to 2 % | 0.8 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Loan including financed premium | 236.436 EUR m |
| Arrangement fee | 1.891 EUR m |
| All-in cost | 5.37 % a year |
| All-in cost without arrangement fee | 5.24 % a year |
| Premium expressed as a running spread | 164 bp |
| Arrangement fee expressed as a running spread | 13 bp |
Try it. Shorten the term to 12 years: the premium is smaller in euros but is repaid faster, so its running cost barely falls.
Reading. Put in proportion. Tanesi could not borrow for eighteen years in euros in the bond market at all; a ten-year sovereign Eurobond for a single-B issuer would cost several hundred basis points more than 5.37%. The cover is expensive and still far cheaper than the alternative. And nothing in this price is “green”: the same loan for a gas turbine would carry the same premium per year of risk. The climate terms changed the tenor and the eligibility, not the price of risk.
Question. How is the project classified, and what follows?
The site covers 320 hectares of grazing land; 22 households must be physically relocated and about 140 lose access to pasture; the 25 km line crosses a seasonal wetland. Screening is immediate, since the ECA’s share far exceeds SDR 10 million. A solar plant has modest impacts in operation, yet the ECA and Meridian both classify the project in Category A, because of physical resettlement and the wetland crossing. Classification follows impacts, not the virtue of the technology.
What follows, in documents:
The calendar: the revised ESIA was disclosed on the ECA’s website on 3 August 2026, so the 30-day period ended on 2 September. The ECA took its final commitment on 20 October and signing followed on 16 November. Resettlement must be completed before the first drawing for site works, which is a condition precedent to that drawing, not to signing.
After signing, the file stays open. The independent consultant reports every six months during construction: progress of resettlement and livelihood restoration, grievances received and closed, accidents on site, results of the supplier audit. In operation the reports become annual and add panel-washing water use and the handling of replaced battery modules. Each report goes to Meridian’s ESRM team and to the ECA, which reports Category A projects to the OECD. A serious breach of the action plan gives the lender a right it will hesitate to use, since accelerating a covered loan needs the ECA’s consent; in practice the lever is the next drawing, which the agency can withhold while an action is overdue.
PITFALL — “It is a solar plant, so it is Category C” is the classic mistake of a junior, and of some exporters. Renewable projects use a lot of land. Most of the difficult environmental and social files of an export finance desk today are wind, solar, hydro and transmission projects, because that is what the desk now finances.
Question. What does Meridian earn, and on how much capital?
Meridian’s exposure splits in two. The covered 95%, EUR 224.614m, is an exposure to the ECA’s state, in euros, weighted 0% (section 6.1). The uncovered 5%, EUR 11.822m, is an exposure to Tanesi guaranteed by its sovereign: PD 4.00% (grade B), F-IRB LGD of 45% for a senior sovereign exposure, maturity 2.5 years by Meridian’s convention.
Assumptions for the first year of repayment, on the opening balance. Funding: Treasury charges 60 bp of liquidity premium for a loan of about ten years of average life, but only 35 bp on the covered part, which can be refinanced in the public-sector covered-bond pool (section 6.3); the blended cost is 36.25 bp. Fees: the arrangement fee spread over ten years, and an agency fee of EUR 50,000 a year. Cost-income: 40% on the margin, 60% on fees.
| Line | Calculation | EUR m |
|---|---|---|
| Net margin over FTP | 236.436 × (1.10% − 0.3625%) | 1.744 |
| Fees | 1.891 / 10 + 0.050 | 0.239 |
| Operating costs | 40% × 1.744 + 60% × 0.239 | 0.841 |
| Expected loss | 0.03% × 45% × 224.614 + 4% × 45% × 11.822 | 0.243 |
| Pre-tax result | 1.983 − 0.841 − 0.243 | 0.899 |
| RWA | 0% × 224.614 + 139.58% × 11.822 | 16.501 |
| Allocated capital | 13% × 16.501 | 2.145 |
| RAROC | 0.899 × 75% / 2.145 | 31.4% |
CASE — RAROC is 31.4%, against a hurdle of 12%. Without cover the same loan would carry EUR 330.0m of RWA and EUR 42.9m of capital, its expected loss of EUR 4.256m would exceed its revenues, and its RAROC would be −6.0%. The cover releases EUR 40.8m of capital, 95% of the total.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Meridian’s RAROC on the Tanesi loan, with and without ECA cover
Compute revenues, costs, expected loss, RWA and RAROC of the covered loan under substitution, and test the effect of the cover percentage and of an internal risk-weight floor on the covered part.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Margin over EURIBOR | 40 to 250 bp | 110 bp |
| FTP liquidity premium, covered part | 0 to 100 bp | 35 bp |
| FTP liquidity premium, uncovered part | 0 to 100 bp | 60 bp |
| Percentage of cover | 85 to 99 % | 95 % |
| PD of the borrower (uncovered part) | 0.2 to 10 % | 4 % |
| Internal risk weight on the covered part | 0 to 50 % | 0 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Loan | 236.436 EUR m |
| Covered exposure | 224.614 EUR m |
| Uncovered exposure | 11.822 EUR m |
| Net margin over FTP | 1.744 EUR m |
| Fees (arrangement fee over 10 years, agency fee) | 0.239 EUR m |
| Operating costs | 0.841 EUR m |
| Expected loss | 0.243 EUR m |
| Pre-tax result | 0.899 EUR m |
| F-IRB risk weight of the uncovered part | 139.58 % |
| RWA | 16.501 EUR m |
| Allocated capital | 2.145 EUR m |
| RAROC | 31.4 % |
| Pre-tax result on the funded amount | 38.0 bp |
| RWA without cover | 330.0 EUR m |
| Capital without cover | 42.90 EUR m |
| Expected loss without cover | 4.256 EUR m |
| RAROC without cover (FTP of the uncovered part) | -6.0 % |
| Capital released by the cover | 40.76 EUR m |
Try it. Set an internal risk weight of 10% on the covered part, as some banks do to reflect documentary and sovereign risk: RAROC falls from 31% to 13%, just above the hurdle.
Read the table by line. Revenues of EUR 1.983m: 88% net margin, 12% fees. Costs of EUR 0.841m: the 40% cost-income ratio is a group average and understates the cost of an eighteen-year agency role, another reason to treat the ratio with care. Expected loss of EUR 0.243m: seven eighths of it comes from the 5% uncovered. Capital of EUR 2.145m: all of it on the uncovered part.
The committee approved three limits with the loan: EUR 11.8m of eighteen-year risk on the host sovereign, EUR 236.4m on the country for transfer and documentary risk, and EUR 224.6m on the ECA’s state. It also noted the exit route: the covered tranche is a euro-denominated claim on a AA sovereign with a spread, and portfolio management may sell part of it to an insurer once the plant is commissioned, keeping the agency role and the uncovered share (see B16).
Reading. Three lessons. The product does not exist without the cover: no margin compatible with the borrower’s budget would pay for EUR 42.9m of capital and EUR 4.3m of expected loss a year. The regulatory RAROC is very sensitive to conventions: a 10% internal floor on the covered part, or 98% cover, moves it from 13% to 91%; a number that unstable should not be used alone, and Meridian’s committee also looks at the return on the funded amount, here 38 bp before tax. And nothing in this table depends on what the plant produces: a covered loan for a gas plant would show the same capital.
Question. What happens to Meridian if Tanesi and its guarantor stop paying?
Suppose the thirteenth instalment, due in May 2035, is not paid; the country has entered a debt restructuring. Twelve instalments have been repaid, so EUR 157.624m is outstanding. The missed instalment is EUR 6.568m of principal and EUR 2.837m of interest (at 3.60%; the swap is a separate matter), EUR 9.405m in total.
CASE — Meridian notifies the ECA within the policy deadline. After the claims waiting period of six months, the ECA pays 95% of the missed instalment, EUR 8.935m; Meridian bears EUR 0.470m. The same happens every six months as instalments fall due. Meridian’s residual exposure is 5% of the outstanding principal, EUR 7.881m; with a recovery of 55% its ultimate principal loss would be EUR 3.547m, spread over years of Paris Club negotiation.
INTERACTIVE LAB — A missed instalment: what the ECA pays and what the bank keeps
Compute the indemnity on a missed instalment of the Tanesi loan, the bank’s share and its residual exposure.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Number of the first missed instalment (1 to 36) | 1 to 36 | 13 |
| Percentage of cover | 90 to 100 % | 95 % |
| Loan interest rate | 1 to 8 % | 3.6 % |
| Ultimate recovery rate | 0 to 100 % | 55 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Principal outstanding before the missed instalment | 157.624 EUR m |
| Missed principal | 6.568 EUR m |
| Missed interest | 2.837 EUR m |
| Missed instalment | 9.405 EUR m |
| Indemnity paid by the ECA after the waiting period | 8.935 EUR m |
| Bank’s share of the missed instalment | 0.470 EUR m |
| Bank’s uncovered share of outstanding principal | 7.881 EUR m |
| Bank’s ultimate principal loss | 3.547 EUR m |
| Covered share of outstanding principal | 149.7 EUR m |
Try it. Set the first missed instalment to 1: a default at the very start leaves the bank with EUR 11.8m of residual exposure and eighteen years of claims administration.
Two further consequences. The interest-rate swap is a separate contract: if Tanesi stops paying, Meridian’s rates desk closes it out, and the close-out amount is a claim on Tanesi and its guarantor that the ECA policy covers only if the hedge was declared and accepted for cover, which here it was not. The desk therefore carries counterparty risk on the swap in full and prices it through a credit valuation adjustment (see D02). And the indemnity follows the original schedule: Meridian receives EUR 8.9m every six months, not EUR 149.7m at once, so the funding stays in place and Treasury’s cost continues while the margin is paid by the ECA only up to the covered interest.
Reading. The loss is small; the work is not. For years the agency files a claim every six months, the ECA checks each one against the policy, and any past documentary weakness surfaces at that moment. The ECA is subrogated to the bank’s rights for 95% and leads the recovery with the other official creditors. Under IFRS 9 the loan is in Stage 3 while its expected credit loss stays small (section 6.4).
Question. What can Meridian say about the climate effect of the loan?
The method is that of PCAF for loans with a known use of proceeds (section 6.5): the project’s emissions are attributed to the lender in proportion to its outstanding amount over the project’s total equity and debt.
CASE — Total project cost is EUR 285m (contract EUR 200m, local costs EUR 40m, premium EUR 26.436m, owner’s costs EUR 18.564m). In the first year of operation Meridian’s attribution factor is 236.436 / 285 = 82.96%. The plant’s own emissions are small, 1.2 kt CO2e a year by assumption, of which 1.0 kt is attributed to Meridian. With an emission factor of 0.60 t per MWh for the displaced thermal generation (case assumption), avoided emissions are 168.0 kt a year, of which 139.4 kt is attributed to Meridian: 589 t per EUR million lent. By year 10 the attribution factor has fallen to 41.5%.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Financed and avoided emissions of the Tanesi loan (PCAF attribution)
Attribute the project’s operating and avoided emissions to the lender and see how the attribution declines as the loan amortises.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Net energy delivered | 100 to 500 GWh a year | 280 GWh a year |
| Emission factor of displaced generation | 0.1 to 1 tCO2 per MWh | 0.6 tCO2 per MWh |
| Total project cost (equity and debt) | 240 to 400 EUR m | 285 EUR m |
| Plant’s own annual emissions | 0 to 10 ktCO2e | 1.2 ktCO2e |
| Year of operation | 1 to 18 | 1 |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Loan outstanding at start of year | 236.436 EUR m |
| Attribution factor | 82.96 % |
| Avoided emissions of the project | 168.0 ktCO2 |
| Avoided emissions attributed to Meridian | 139.4 ktCO2 |
| Financed emissions attributed to Meridian | 1.00 ktCO2e |
| Attributed avoided emissions per EUR million outstanding | 589 tCO2 |
Try it. Halve the emission factor to 0.30, as if the plant displaced gas instead of diesel: the avoided emissions halve. The baseline, not the plant, drives the number.
Reading. The avoided figure depends entirely on a counterfactual. If the solar output mostly displaces hydropower in the wet season, or if the battery is dispatched for grid stability and not to replace diesel, the true figure is far lower. Manufacturing emissions of modules and cells are outside the operating inventory. And the ECA, which carries 95% of the risk, has no “outstanding amount”: how guarantors and insurers should account for emissions is unsettled, and the NZECA published a first paper on the question in November 2025. Meridian reports the 1.0 kt in its financed emissions and the 139.4 kt in a separate, clearly labelled line, with the emission factor disclosed.
| Stage | Key figure | Value |
|---|---|---|
| 5.2 Sizing | Down payment / supported export share / local costs | EUR 30m / 170m / 40m |
| 5.2 Sizing | Base loan; share of contract and local costs | EUR 210m; 87.5% |
| 5.2 Content | Foreign content; headroom under 70% ceiling | 62%; EUR 16m |
| 5.3 Premium | Horizon of risk; MPR | 19 years; 12.5885% |
| 5.3 Premium | Premium; loan; saving from term adjustment | EUR 26.436m; 236.436m; 4.665m |
| 5.4 Tenor | First-year debt service, 18 against 12 years | EUR 21.529m against 27.345m (−21.3%) |
| 5.4 Tenor | Per MWh; extra premium; extra interest | EUR 76.89 against 97.66; 5.835m; 26.848m |
| 5.5 Interest | CIRR held; market fixed rate | 4.05%; 3.60% |
| 5.6 Construction | Commitment fee; interest during construction | EUR 0.693m; 11.353m |
| 5.7 All-in cost | All-in; premium as spread; fee as spread | 5.37%; 164 bp; 13 bp |
| 5.9 Bank | Covered / uncovered exposure | EUR 224.614m / 11.822m |
| 5.9 Bank | Revenues; costs; expected loss | EUR 1.983m; 0.841m; 0.243m |
| 5.9 Bank | RWA; capital; RAROC | EUR 16.501m; 2.145m; 31.4% |
| 5.9 Bank | Without cover: capital; RAROC | EUR 42.90m; −6.0% |
| 5.10 Claim | Missed instalment; indemnity; bank’s share | EUR 9.405m; 8.935m; 0.470m |
| 6.3 Funding | Break-even margin at the 12% hurdle | 70.8 bp |
| 5.11 Emissions | Avoided emissions; attributed to Meridian in year 1 | 168.0 kt; 139.4 kt CO2 |
IN ONE SENTENCE — When an eligible guarantor covers part of a loan, the bank replaces the borrower’s risk weight with the guarantor’s on the covered part and keeps the borrower’s on the rest.
FORMULA
is the exposure; the covered share (95%); the risk weight of a direct exposure to the guarantor; the risk weight of the borrower.
An ECA acting for its state is treated as the central government, an eligible provider of unfunded credit protection. Under the standardised approach, exposures to EU member states’ central governments denominated and funded in the domestic currency are weighted 0% (Article 114(4) CRR), and Article 235 extends that treatment to the guaranteed part of an exposure when the guarantee is denominated in the guarantor’s domestic currency and the exposure is funded in it. An EBA answer of 2024 on this article confirms that both conditions are read literally. Meridian uses the standardised approach for EU sovereigns under the permanent partial use allowed by Article 150, and CRR3 (Regulation (EU) 2024/1623, applicable since 1 January 2025) provides for exactly this case: the guaranteed exposure is under IRB, the guarantor under the standardised approach, and the covered part takes the guarantor’s standardised risk weight.
Three points decide whether the 0% is really available.
Currency and guarantor. A euro loan covered by a euro-area ECA meets the test. A US dollar loan covered by the same ECA does not benefit from Article 114(4); the risk weight then follows the sovereign’s rating, 0% down to AA−, 20% for single-A, 50% for BBB. A dollar loan covered by a BBB-rated state costs capital on its covered part. A UK or Korean guarantee in euros or dollars is weighted on the rating as well.
Eligibility of the policy. Credit protection must be direct, explicit, irrevocable and unconditional, and pay in a timely manner. Guarantees on first demand pass easily. Insurance policies carry conditions (compliance with the policy, a waiting period), and each bank needs a legal opinion that the conditions are within its own control. The EBA’s October 2024 report on credit insurance shows that supervisors watch this area closely.
The uncovered part. It stays an exposure to the borrower. For Tanesi: PD 4%, LGD 45%, risk weight 139.58%. Under the standardised approach a single-B sovereign is weighted 100%, and Article 137 lets banks use the OECD country classification directly: categories 4 to 6 give 100%, category 7 gives 150%. The output floor (72.5% of standardised RWA when fully phased in) does not bind on this loan, since standardised RWA, EUR 11.82m, is below the IRB figure.
Two other ratios matter. The leverage ratio would treat a zero-weighted EUR 224.6m like any other asset and require 3% of Tier 1 against it, but Article 429a(1)(f) CRR excludes the guaranteed parts of export credits from the exposure measure when the guarantor is an ECA or central government weighted 0%. The large exposures regime exempts exposures to 0%-weighted sovereigns; the exposure to Tanesi counts only for the uncovered part.
WHY IT MATTERS ON THE DESK — The whole business model rests on a legal reading: that the policy is an eligible guarantee at 0%. The structurer who agrees a special condition without asking whether it endangers eligibility can turn EUR 2.1m of capital into EUR 42.9m.
The table of section 5.9 is the one that goes into the credit application. What does the sustainable feature change? Compared with a 12-year loan for a conventional plant: the amount is 2.5% larger and the revenue lasts six more years, which raises the lifetime income of the deal by roughly half; the funding is longer and dearer; capital per euro is unchanged, since Meridian’s F-IRB maturity is fixed at 2.5 years (an effective maturity of five years, the regulatory cap, would raise the risk weight on the uncovered part). If the ECA grants 98% cover to a green project, the uncovered exposure falls from EUR 11.822m to EUR 4.757m and RAROC, mechanically, triples. No prudential rule rewards the climate purpose: CRR3 contains no green supporting factor (see E02). The benefit is indirect, through terms that the ECA decides.
A bank that lends for eighteen years must fund for eighteen years, or accept a maturity gap that Treasury charges for. On Meridian’s grid the liquidity premium for about ten years of average life is 60 bp, more than half the margin. Export finance desks have therefore always looked for cheaper funding for the covered part:
The covered loan is not itself a high-quality liquid asset. For the net stable funding ratio it requires stable funding like other long-term loans, unless encumbered in a cover pool, which changes the calculation (see E04).
INTERACTIVE LAB — Funding cost and break-even margin of the Tanesi loan
See how the liquidity premium charged on the covered part drives RAROC, and find the margin at which the loan just meets the hurdle.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Margin over EURIBOR | 40 to 200 bp | 110 bp |
| FTP liquidity premium, covered part | 0 to 100 bp | 35 bp |
| FTP liquidity premium, uncovered part | 0 to 100 bp | 60 bp |
| RAROC hurdle after tax | 8 to 20 % | 12 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Blended liquidity premium | 36.25 bp |
| Net margin over FTP | 73.75 bp |
| RAROC | 31.4 % |
| Break-even margin at the hurdle | 70.8 bp |
| Margin above break-even | 39.2 bp |
Try it. Set the covered-part premium to 60 bp, as for a bank with no covered-bond outlet: the break-even margin rises from 71 to 95 bp and the bank loses the mandate to a competitor that has one.
CASE — At 110 bp the loan clears the hurdle with a cushion of 39.2 bp: the break-even margin is 70.8 bp. With the covered part funded at 60 bp instead of 35 bp, RAROC falls to 19.6% and the break-even margin rises to 94.6 bp. Funding access, not capital, sets the competitive price in export finance.
The lender, IFRS 9. The loan pays principal and interest only and is held to collect: amortised cost. The arrangement fee is part of the effective interest rate and is spread over the life, which is what the RAROC table did approximately. The premium is not Meridian’s revenue: it passes through to the ECA.
The cover is taken out at inception as part of the transaction, so it is treated as integral to the contractual terms and its cash flows enter the measurement of expected credit losses. Two consequences follow, and they are regularly confused. Staging looks at the borrower’s risk of default, without the guarantee: if the host country is downgraded, the loan moves to Stage 2, and to Stage 3 on a missed instalment. The amount of the allowance, by contrast, reflects the cover: lifetime losses on the covered part are close to nil. A Stage 3 loan with an allowance of a few percent of its amount is normal in this business and must be explained to anyone reading the bank’s asset-quality tables.
The borrower. The premium and the arrangement fee are transaction costs included in the effective interest rate of the liability, which is why 5.37%, not 3.60%, is the cost that appears in Tanesi’s accounts over time.
Green Asset Ratio and BTAR. The loan finances a solar plant, an activity described in the EU Taxonomy, yet it does not enter the numerator of Meridian’s Green Asset Ratio: Tanesi is a non-EU entity outside the scope of EU sustainability reporting, and under Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/73, applicable from 1 January 2026, such exposures are excluded from both the numerator and the denominator. The Banking Book Taxonomy Alignment Ratio of the Pillar 3 templates was designed to capture them on a best-effort basis; it is not in Delegated Regulation 2026/73 and the EBA’s final draft of 22 June 2026 drops it from Pillar 3 for large institutions (see E06). The point for the desk: its greenest loans count least in the headline ratio, and several banks present a separate figure for them.
Financed emissions (PCAF). For a loan with known use of proceeds, the PCAF standard attributes the project’s emissions to the lender in proportion to its outstanding amount over the project’s total equity and debt. Avoided emissions may be reported, separately from the inventory and never netted against it.
FORMULA
is the attribution factor in year ; the loan outstanding; the total project cost; the net energy delivered; the emission factor of the generation displaced.
The calculation for the Tanesi loan is in section 5.11: 1.0 kt CO2e of financed emissions and 139.4 kt of attributed avoided emissions in the first year, reported on separate lines.
| Risk | What can happen | Control | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loss of cover | Drawing outside notified terms; waiver without consent; late default notice | Drawdown checklist; ECA consent register; diary of policy deadlines | Loan agency, Legal |
| Ineligible guarantee | Policy conditions fail the CRR test; currency mismatch | Legal opinion per policy form; currency check at structuring | Legal, Risk, Finance |
| Content misdeclaration | Exporter overstates national content; cover reduced | Exporter’s undertaking with recourse; origin documents | ECA structurer |
| Residual credit risk | Borrower default; restructuring | Country and obligor limits on the uncovered share; sovereign monitoring | Credit risk |
| Funding and prepayment | Long gap; early repayment | Matched funding or cover-pool eligibility; break-cost clause | Treasury |
| Environmental and social | Resettlement or labour grievance; halted works | Category A process; ESAP as covenant; independent monitoring | ESRM, ECA |
| Supply chain | Forced labour or conflict minerals in modules and cells | Traceability clause; audit right; supplier exclusion list | ESRM, exporter |
| Integrity | Bribery in the award of the contract | OECD anti-bribery declaration to the ECA; KYC on agents | Compliance |
| Debt sustainability | Loan breaches the country’s borrowing limits | Check of IMF programme limits; ministry authorisation as CP | Country risk |
| Reputational | Claims of “green” finance contested | Label only with documented use of proceeds; avoided emissions disclosed with baseline | Sustainable finance team |
The integrity line deserves a word. The OECD Recommendation on Bribery and Officially Supported Export Credits requires exporters and applicants to declare that they have not engaged in bribery, and ECAs to act on indications of it. A conviction or a credible allegation can lead to the denial of cover or of indemnity, which makes the bank’s own due diligence on agents and commissions a credit control as much as a compliance one.
Red-flag checklist for the sustainable layer.
The rulebook, as of November 2026.
Orders of magnitude.
Open debates.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Check your understanding of export finance
Twelve questions on the product, the rulebook, the sustainable layer and the bank’s economics.
Q1. In an ECA-covered buyer credit, to whom does the bank disburse the loan?
Answer: B. The loan pays the exporter directly against qualifying certificates; the borrower owes the bank without having handled the cash.
Q2. Under the Arrangement, the minimum down payment is:
Answer: A. At least 15% of the export contract value must be paid at or before the starting point of credit; official support is limited to 85%.
Q3. The horizon of risk used in the minimum premium formula is:
Answer: C. HOR = 0.5 x disbursement period + repayment period for a standard profile.
Q4. A ministry of finance in a category 4 country borrows with 1 year of disbursement and 10 years of repayment, 95% standard cover. The MPR is:
Answer: D. 0.550 x 10.5 + 0.350 = 6.125%. The term adjustment in the module’s model applies to sovereigns in categories 5 to 7 only.
Q5. What did the 2023 modernisation NOT introduce?
Answer: B. The only fossil-fuel prohibition in the Arrangement is Article 6 on unabated coal-fired power, in force since November 2021.
Q6. A solar plant requiring the physical relocation of households is most likely classified:
Answer: A. Classification follows the potential impacts. Resettlement is a significant, irreversible impact.
Q7. For a Category A project, the Common Approaches ask that the ESIA be public:
Answer: C. Ex ante disclosure at least 30 calendar days before final commitment is the rule for Category A.
Q8. The CIRR for a loan with 2 years of drawdown and 18 years of repayment in semi-annual instalments is based on a government bond of:
Answer: D. 2 + 9 + 0.25 = 11.25, rounded to 11 and capped at 10 years.
Q9. A euro-area bank holds a US dollar loan covered at 95% by the ECA of a BBB-rated euro-area state. The risk weight of the covered part under the standardised approach is:
Answer: B. The 0% of Article 114(4) requires denomination and funding in the sovereign’s domestic currency. Otherwise the rating applies: BBB gives 50%.
Q10. In the Tanesi case, which item is the largest financing cost for the borrower when expressed as a running spread?
Answer: D. The premium is equivalent to about 164 bp a year, against 110 bp of margin and 13 bp for the arrangement fee.
Q11. Under IFRS 9, a 95% covered loan whose borrower misses a payment is:
Answer: A. Staging follows the borrower’s default risk; the measurement of expected credit losses includes the cash flows expected from an integral guarantee.
Q12. Why does the Tanesi loan not enter the numerator of Meridian’s Green Asset Ratio?
Answer: C. Exposures to non-EU counterparties not subject to EU sustainability reporting are excluded from the numerator; the BTAR was designed to capture them.
Q13. An untied ECA guarantee differs from a classic export credit because:
Answer: B. Untied cover supports a borrower or project for a broader national interest (supplier access, raw materials) without an underlying export contract.
A euro-area exporter sells rail signalling equipment for EUR 80m to the ministry of transport of a category 4 country, with a ministry of finance guarantee. Local costs are EUR 10m. Disbursement takes one year; repayment is over ten years; cover is 95%, standard product. Compute the base loan, the minimum premium and the loan if the premium is financed.
Solution. Down payment: 15% × 80 = EUR 12m. Supported export share: EUR 68m. Local-cost limit: 50% × 80 = EUR 40m, so the EUR 10m is supported in full. Base loan: EUR 78m. Horizon of risk: 0.5 × 1 + 10 = 10.5 years. MPR: 0.550 × 10.5 + 0.350 = 6.125%; the buyer coefficient is zero, the cover factors are 1, and no term adjustment applies. Premium: 6.125% × 78 = EUR 4.778m. Loan: EUR 82.778m. Check with the simulator of section 2.4 (category 4).
Meridian lends EUR 100m to a BB-rated corporate buyer, 95% covered in euros by a euro-area ECA. Margin 90 bp; blended liquidity premium 30 bp; no fees; cost-income 40%. Uncovered part: PD 1.00%, LGD 40%, for which the F-IRB risk weight is 82.06%. Covered part: PD 0.03%, LGD 45%, risk weight 0%.
Solution. Net margin: 100 × 0.60% = EUR 0.600m. Costs: EUR 0.240m. Expected loss: 0.03% × 45% × 95 + 1% × 40% × 5 = 0.0128 + 0.0200 = EUR 0.0328m. Pre-tax result: EUR 0.3272m; after tax EUR 0.2454m. RWA: 82.06% × 5 = EUR 4.103m; capital EUR 0.533m. RAROC: 0.2454 / 0.533 = 46.0%. With an internal floor of 10% on the covered part, RWA would be EUR 13.603m, capital EUR 1.768m and RAROC 13.9%.
A sovereign borrower in category 6 needs a base loan of EUR 50m for a water treatment plant (22 years allowed under the CCSU). Disbursement takes one year. Compare repayment over 10 and 15 years: premium, loan with financed premium, and annual principal repayment.
Solution. Ten years: HOR 10.5; gross rate 0.900 × 10.5 + 1.200 = 10.65%; term adjustment 0.018 × 0.5 = 0.9%; MPR 10.65% × 0.991 = 10.554%; premium EUR 5.277m; loan EUR 55.277m; annual principal EUR 5.528m. Fifteen years: HOR 15.5; gross rate 15.15%; term adjustment 0.018 × 5.5 = 9.9%; MPR 15.15% × 0.901 = 13.650%; premium EUR 6.825m; loan EUR 56.825m; annual principal EUR 3.788m. Five more years cost EUR 1.548m of premium and cut the annual principal repayment by EUR 1.740m, or 31%.
1. Explain an ECA-covered buyer credit to someone who knows corporate loans. It is a term loan to a foreign buyer whose proceeds are paid directly to an exporter, with an insurance policy or guarantee from the exporter’s state covering 95% to 100% of non-payment. The borrower pays the bank a margin and the ECA a premium. The bank’s credit risk is mostly on its own sovereign, so capital is low, but the loan is long and the cover is conditional on flawless administration. The terms (down payment, tenor, premium floor) are set by the OECD Arrangement and not by negotiation alone.
2. What is the OECD Arrangement and why does it exist? It is an agreement among eleven Participants that sets the most generous terms governments may offer when supporting export credits of two years or more: 15% down payment, maximum tenors, repayment profile, minimum premium and minimum fixed rate. Its purpose is that exporters compete on price and quality of goods and not on subsidised finance. It is not a treaty; the EU makes it binding by regulation. Its limits are that major exporters such as China are outside and that untied support escapes it.
3. How is the minimum premium determined, and who pays it? For countries in categories 1 to 7 a formula combines a per-year country coefficient, a constant, the horizon of risk, a buyer-risk add-on, and factors for the percentage and quality of cover, with a discount of up to 15% for long horizons and weak obligors since 2023. It is expressed upfront as a percentage of principal. The borrower pays it, usually financed in the loan. For a single-B sovereign over eighteen years it exceeds 12% of the loan, more than the bank earns over the life.
4. What does the Climate Change Sector Understanding change for a solar project? It allows a repayment term of up to 22 years instead of 12 for a conventional power plant, and more flexible repayment profiles. It does not lower the premium rate per year of risk, and a longer horizon raises the upfront premium. The benefit is a lower annual debt service, which is often what makes the project fit a utility’s tariff. Storage is eligible in its own class since 2023.
5. Why is a renewable project often Category A? Because classification under the Common Approaches and the Equator Principles depends on potential adverse impacts, not on the climate benefit. Large solar, wind and hydro projects need land, may displace people, affect habitats and require transmission lines. Category A triggers a full ESIA to IFC Performance Standards and its disclosure 30 days before the ECA commits, which often sets the critical path of the deal.
6. Where does the capital relief come from, and what could remove it? From substitution: the covered part takes the risk weight of the guarantor state, 0% for an EU sovereign when the exposure is in its domestic currency. It disappears if the policy is not an eligible guarantee, if the currency condition is not met and the sovereign is not highly rated, or if the bank loses the cover through its own breach. The uncovered part keeps the borrower’s risk weight and carries all the capital.
7. The RAROC of this loan is above 30%. Why is the desk not growing faster? Because regulatory capital is not the binding constraint. The loan needs eighteen-year funding, and the liquidity premium takes a third or more of the margin; access to covered bonds or public refinancing decides competitiveness. The deals are few, slow and labour-intensive, with agency duties for two decades. And the ratio is fragile: a modest internal floor on the covered part brings it close to the hurdle.
8. Is export finance “sustainable finance”? Partly. Its rulebook now gives better terms to climate projects, bans coal power and imposes environmental and social due diligence that is stricter than in most corporate lending. But there is no Arrangement rule on oil and gas, national policies diverge, most renewable volumes go to high-income countries, and avoided-emission claims depend on baselines. I would present a covered solar loan as green with its use of proceeds and due diligence documented, and avoid describing the business line as a whole in those terms.
Rulebook
EU policy and national programmes
Prudential and accounting
Market data and analysis