Global Markets is the part of Meridian Bank that makes prices. Its Rates desk trades interest-rate swaps, government bonds, futures and options; its FX desk trades spot, forwards, swaps and options in the main currency pairs. Most of the volume is with other banks, asset managers and hedge funds. This module looks at a smaller but strategic slice: the corporate derivatives franchise, which sells hedges to the treasurers of companies that borrow from the bank’s Corporate Banking division (see B03) or issue bonds through its DCM desk (see C01, C02).
The clients are the treasurers of investment-grade and crossover companies, infrastructure and project companies (see B06, B07) and leveraged borrowers (see B05). Their needs are simple to state: turn floating-rate debt into fixed, turn a fixed-rate bond into floating if they want a target mix, lock today’s rates for a bond they will issue in two months, convert debt into the currency of the assets it finances, and hedge the currency of sales and purchases. Every one of these is an interest-rate swap (IRS), a cross-currency swap (CCS) or an FX forward.
How the desk earns money. On a corporate hedge the bank does not keep the market risk: the trader offsets the client’s swap within minutes with another bank or a clearing house, at mid-market. What remains is a spread between the rate quoted to the client and the mid-market rate. That spread has three parts, and only one of them is profit: a charge for counterparty credit risk (CVA), a charge for funding an uncollateralised position (FVA), and the sales margin. On a five-year euro swap for a BBB company the whole spread is a handful of basis points of running rate. Expressed in present value the numbers look larger: in our case, a 5 bp sales margin on a EUR 400m five-year swap is worth EUR 929,000 on the trade date. The desk books that “sales credit” the day the trade is done. The bank then holds capital for five or seven years against the client’s credit risk.
WHO DOES WHAT — The corporate derivatives salesperson owns the hedging dialogue with the treasurer and works with the coverage banker (see B01). The rates or FX trader quotes mid-market and executes the offsetting hedge. The XVA desk prices and manages counterparty credit, funding and capital charges across all trades with a client. The structurer designs non-standard features, including sustainability-linked ones, with the sustainable finance solutions team. Credit risk sets the counterparty limit and approves the line. Derivatives documentation negotiates the ISDA Master Agreement and confirmations. Middle office and product control book the trade, reconcile it and produce the daily profit and loss and fair-value levels. Collateral management runs margin calls when there is a credit support annex.
Adjacent functions: Treasury charges funding and liquidity (see E04); Finance decides the accounting and Pillar 3 disclosures (see E05, E06); Compliance checks MiFID suitability and any claim that a trade is “sustainable” (see E10); market risk management sets the desk’s sensitivity limits (see E09).
A realistic week in mid-November 2026. Monday: Borealis Packaging executes a EUR 400m sustainability-linked swap and a forward-starting pre-hedge for its January green bond. Tuesday: the XVA desk asks sales to re-price two long-dated project-finance swaps because Meridian’s credit spread curve moved after the ECB held rates at 2.50% on 29 October. Wednesday: documentation chases three clients whose EMIR clearing-threshold calculations change under the new regime that applies from 10 November 2026. Thursday: a chemical group’s treasurer asks whether the KPI clause in its swap should be dropped now that it has refinanced its sustainability-linked loan as a plain one. Friday: the weekly review of day-one profit, where product control decides how much of the sales credit on Level 3 trades may be recognised.
IN ONE SENTENCE — An interest-rate swap is a contract in which two parties exchange, on the same notional amount and for a fixed period, a fixed rate against a floating rate, without exchanging the notional.
INTUITION — A swap is a fixed-price energy contract for money. A company whose loan resets every six months with EURIBOR is like a household on a variable electricity tariff; the swap lets it pay a fixed price for five years while the bank takes the variable bill.
Mechanics. Borealis pays Meridian a fixed rate once a year (30/360 day count is the usual euro convention) and receives six-month EURIBOR twice a year (actual/360) on EUR 400m. Its loan still pays EURIBOR plus margin to its lenders. Net, Borealis pays the swap’s fixed rate plus the loan margin: its floating debt has become fixed. The notional never changes hands in an IRS; only the net interest difference does. Since the EURIBOR reform, discounting of collateralised swaps is done on the euro short-term rate (€STR) curve; EURIBOR remains the floating index of most corporate loans and swaps.
Pricing. At inception the fixed rate is set so that the present values of both legs are equal: the par swap rate.
FORMULA
is the par fixed rate; the discount factor to date ; the annuity (present value of 1 paid each year on the fixed leg); the year fraction of period ; the number of fixed payments; the notional; the change in value of the swap for a one basis point parallel move of the curve. The formula for uses the single-curve shortcut, exact when the same curve projects EURIBOR and discounts.
The value of a swap after inception is the difference between the current par rate and the contract rate, times the annuity: for the payer of the fixed rate . A payer gains when rates rise. The DV01 tells the trader how much one basis point is worth and therefore how much of the offsetting hedge to execute.
CASE — With the guide’s flat curve at 2.50% (annual compounding), the five-year par rate is 2.50%, the annuity 4.6458 and the DV01 of a EUR 400m swap EUR 185,833. If rates rise by 30 bp the next day, the payer swap is worth EUR 5.527m to Borealis; the DV01 approximation gives EUR 5.575m, the difference being convexity.
INTERACTIVE LAB — A plain interest-rate swap: par rate, annuity, DV01 and mark-to-market
Price a fixed-for-floating swap on a flat curve, measure its DV01 and see how its value changes when rates move.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Notional | 10 to 1000 EUR m | 400 EUR m |
| Tenor | 1 to 30 years | 5 years |
| Flat swap curve level (annual compounding) | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Contract fixed rate paid by the client | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Parallel move of the curve after the trade | -200 to 200 bp | 0 bp |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Par swap rate at the curve level | 2.5000 % |
| Annuity A(T) | 4.6458 years |
| DV01 | 185.8 EUR k |
| Value to the fixed-rate payer after the move (exact) | 0.000 EUR m |
| Value estimated with DV01 only | 0.000 EUR m |
Try it. Set the tenor to 30 years and move rates by 200 bp: the gap between the exact value and the DV01 estimate (convexity) becomes material.
Every OTC derivative between Meridian and a client sits under an ISDA Master Agreement (1992 or 2002 version) with its Schedule, which sets the elections: events of default, termination events, netting, governing law. Each trade is evidenced by a confirmation. Between banks, a credit support annex (CSA) makes both sides post variation margin daily, so that exposure is close to zero, and the EU uncleared margin rules add initial margin for large portfolios. Most interest-rate swaps between banks are cleared through a central counterparty.
Corporate clients are different. Under EMIR, a non-financial counterparty below the clearing thresholds (an “NFC−”) is neither obliged to clear nor to exchange margin, and almost no corporate treasurer wants to post cash collateral on a hedge. The swap is therefore uncollateralised: if rates fall, the value of the swap to Meridian becomes a claim on Borealis that is unsecured for years. Meanwhile Meridian’s offsetting hedge with another bank is collateralised. That asymmetry creates the two charges that dominate corporate derivatives pricing.
IN ONE SENTENCE — XVA is the family of valuation adjustments that turn the mid-market price of a derivative into the price for a particular client, by charging for that client’s credit risk, for the funding of uncollateralised exposure and for the capital consumed.
INTUITION — Mid-market is the wholesale price. The client price adds the insurance premium against the client’s default (CVA), the cost of the cash the bank must advance to its own hedge counterparty when the client owes it money (FVA), and a return on the capital the bank must hold (KVA). The sales margin comes on top.
FORMULA
is the expected positive exposure of the bank to the client at date ; the client’s survival probability implied by its credit spread ; the default intensity; the market convention loss given default (60%); the discount factor. FVA has the same structure with the bank’s funding spread in place of the default probability.
For an at-the-money swap the expected exposure is zero at inception, grows as rates diffuse away from today’s level, and falls again as fewer payments remain: a hump that peaks around one third of the life. CVA is the expected loss on that hump under market-implied default probabilities; DVA, its mirror for the bank’s own default, is recognised in accounting but most banks do not give it to clients. FVA charges the cost of funding the collateral posted on the hedge while the client owes the bank. KVA prices capital; Meridian, like many banks, does not charge it as a separate line but checks capital through the RAROC of the trade (section 6). MVA, the cost of funding initial margin, is zero for an uncleared, unmargined corporate swap.
PITFALL — CVA is not the expected loss of the credit committee. It uses market-implied default probabilities (from credit spreads), which are several times the real-world PD of the internal rating. Section 5.2 computes both for Borealis; the gap is the risk premium the market charges for credit, and it is why the XVA desk hedges CVA with credit default swaps where they exist.
A cross-currency swap exchanges principal and interest in two currencies. At the start the parties swap notionals at today’s spot rate; each period they pay interest in the currency they received; at maturity they re-exchange the same notionals. A company that issues in euros but owns US plants can swap its euro bond into a dollar liability: it receives euros that pay the bond coupon and pays dollars, which match the dollar income of the assets. The price contains the interest differential between the two currencies and the cross-currency basis, a spread that reflects the relative demand for dollar and euro funding and that has been non-zero since 2008. An FX forward is the short-dated, single-payment version: an exchange of currencies at a future date at a rate fixed today, equal to spot adjusted for the interest differential.
The risk profile differs from an IRS. Because notionals are re-exchanged at maturity at the original rate, a CCS carries the full currency move on the principal. A 10% fall in the euro against the dollar moves the value of a EUR 200m CCS by about EUR 20m, a hundred times more than a 1 bp rate move on the same notional. The exposure, the CVA and the regulatory capital are correspondingly larger.
| Risk | What it is | Managed by |
|---|---|---|
| Market (delta, vega, basis) | Value changes with rates, FX, volatility | Trader hedges at mid; market risk limits |
| Counterparty credit | Client defaults when the swap is in the bank’s favour | Credit limit; XVA desk; CVA hedges |
| Funding and liquidity | Collateral on hedges, outflows in stress | Treasury via FVA and FTP |
| Legal and documentation | Unenforceable netting, wrong confirmation | Documentation, Legal |
| Conduct | Unsuitable hedge, opaque margin | Sales supervision, Compliance |
Conduct deserves a line. The swaps mis-selling cases of the 2000s and 2010s, in several European countries, concerned complex hedges sold to municipalities and small companies without clear disclosure of the embedded margin and risk. MiFID II requires an appropriateness or suitability assessment depending on the service, a disclosure of costs and charges including the margin, and a target market for each product. The sustainability-linked layer adds a new temptation: to sell a KPI clause as the reason to hedge.
IN ONE SENTENCE — A sustainability-linked derivative is an ordinary derivative whose cash flows change with the client’s performance against pre-agreed sustainability targets; a “green” derivative is one that hedges or references a green asset or instrument.
Market vocabulary is loose, so it pays to separate three families.
This module covers the first two. The case uses both: a KPI-linked swap hedging floating debt, and plain hedges of a green bond.
ISDA has not written “principles” for SLDs in the way ICMA and the LMA did for bonds and loans. It has produced three documents that frame practice.
The clause library’s building blocks are worth learning, because every SLD term sheet now uses them:
| Building block | What it does |
|---|---|
| KPI, SPT, observation period | Define the metric, the target and the year tested |
| KPI compliance certificate | The party states its score, whether each SPT is met and the consequence, by a deadline |
| Verification agent | A third party verifies the KPI score |
| Sustainability consequence | A rate change on a leg, or a separate sustainability-linked payment |
| KPI review event, discussion period | Reopens a KPI after a methodology, regulatory or scientific change |
| Declassification event | Ends the sustainability features; the trade continues as a plain derivative |
| KPI dispute | A CSA-style process; failing resolution, verifier decides, consequence lapses or trade is declassified |
Three features differ from loans and deserve attention. First, failure to pay a sustainability-linked payment is not an event of default under the library; the parties may elect an additional termination event or a declassification instead. The hedge is protected from the KPI clause. Second, consequences can be positive or negative and per KPI or for all KPIs together, so the same two-way grid as in a loan can be reproduced. Third, the library contemplates payments directed to a sustainable purpose: rather than going to the bank, a premium for a missed target can be applied to a project or a charity agreed in the confirmation. The case uses that option.
NOTE — In practice the KPIs of an SLD are rarely designed for the derivative. They are recycled from the client’s sustainability-linked loan or bond, and the swap confirmation cross-refers to the certificate delivered under the facility agreement. This keeps the cost of reporting close to zero; it also means the SLD inherits every weakness of the loan’s KPIs.
Classification under MiFID II and EMIR. A Category 1 SLD remains an OTC derivative: it must be reported to a trade repository under EMIR Article 9; none of the reporting fields captures the KPI terms. For a non-financial counterparty, the important question is whether the swap still counts as a hedge “objectively measurable as reducing risks directly relating to commercial or treasury financing activity”, because hedges are excluded from the clearing-threshold calculation. ISDA’s 2021 analysis is that a Category 1 SLD normally keeps hedge status, absent unusual KPI cash flows or a change in the hedging structure. EMIR 3 (Regulation (EU) 2024/2987) changed the threshold regime: from 10 November 2026, under the Commission’s delegated regulation published in the Official Journal on 21 October 2026, NFCs test only their uncleared OTC positions against the thresholds, at entity level, and the existing hedging criteria are unchanged. A large corporate that writes KPI clauses into its hedges should keep the hedge rationale documented.
Benchmarks. If a KPI is an index (an ESG rating, for example) that determines an amount payable under a financial instrument, the Benchmarks Regulation may apply. Operational KPIs measured by the company itself avoid the issue, one more reason why ESG-rating KPIs have fallen out of favour.
Accounting. For the client, an SLD raises the question of the IFRS 9 definition of a derivative, which excludes contracts whose underlying is a non-financial variable specific to a party to the contract. A company’s emissions are such a variable. The dominant reading is that an IRS with a small KPI adjustment remains a derivative because its main underlying is an interest rate, but the KPI component creates hedge ineffectiveness: the hypothetical derivative used to measure the hedged risk has no KPI clause. The IASB’s amendments to IFRS 9 and IFRS 7 on classification and measurement (May 2024, effective for periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026, endorsed in the EU in 2025 by Regulation (EU) 2025/1047) clarify when financial assets with ESG-linked features meet the “solely payments of principal and interest” test; they concern the lender’s loan (see B03), not the derivative, which is measured at fair value through profit or loss in any case.
Prudential. CRR3 contains no specific treatment of SLDs. Capital follows the derivative: SA-CCR for counterparty credit risk, the CVA framework, and market risk. The EU has kept, in Article 382(4) CRR, the exemption of transactions with non-financial counterparties from the CVA risk capital requirement, which matters enormously for corporate hedging (section 6). The revised market-risk framework (FRTB) applies from 1 January 2027 with a temporary relief adopted by the Commission on 4 June 2026.
Sustainability reporting. Derivatives sit outside the bank’s financed emissions under the PCAF standard, and outside the Green Asset Ratio: Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/73 removed derivatives from the denominator of financial undertakings’ Taxonomy KPIs, applicable from 1 January 2026. An SLD can therefore appear only in the bank’s voluntary “sustainable finance” volumes, where definitions are internal.
No public source gives a reliable volume of SLDs: they are bilateral, unlisted and often not announced. Banks’ press releases since 2019 cover a few dozen named trades, mostly interest-rate swaps and FX forwards attached to sustainability-linked loans, some cross-currency swaps for project companies and utilities. Three practices dominate. KPIs and SPTs are copied from the client’s loan or bond. Adjustments are a fraction of a basis point to a few basis points on the fixed rate. Premiums for missed targets are often directed to a sustainable purpose rather than kept by the bank.
The broader climate is cooler than in 2021. Sustainability-linked loans and bonds have lost volume since their peak, and some large borrowers have dropped the format at refinancing (see B03, C02). An SLD attached to a loan that becomes plain is declassified with it. The green bond market is steady, and its hedges, plain swaps, are as busy as ever. The questions a desk faces in late 2026 are therefore less about volume than about integrity: whether a swap KPI adds anything to the loan’s, who pays for the discount, and how to value a cash flow that depends on a client’s emissions.
A corporate hedge is executed in seconds; preparing it takes weeks, and servicing it lasts for its whole life. The flow below follows the Borealis sustainability-linked swap from the treasurer’s hedging policy to the last KPI adjustment.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Life of a sustainability-linked swap, from hedging policy to maturity
Follow the actors, documents and controls of a corporate sustainability-linked interest-rate swap.
| # | Who | Does what | Deliverable |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Borealis treasurer and board | Reviews the hedging policy: target share of fixed-rate debt, instruments allowed, counterparties | Board-approved hedging policy and annual hedging plan |
| 2 | Corporate derivatives sales and coverage | Discuss the plan with the treasurer, propose a swap and a KPI clause mirroring the RCF | Indicative term sheet and pricing grid |
| 3 | Sales (MiFID) | Classifies the client, checks appropriateness, discloses costs and charges including the margin | Client file, ex-ante cost disclosure |
| 4 | Credit risk | Sets or increases the counterparty limit on potential future exposure; checks the ISDA netting opinion | Approved derivatives line |
| 5 | Sustainable finance solutions | Reviews KPIs, SPTs and the link to the RCF; checks the classification under Meridian’s internal framework | Classification memo |
| 6 | Documentation and Legal | Negotiate the ISDA Schedule and the sustainability-linked provisions from the clause library | Agreed confirmation template |
| 7 | XVA desk | Prices CVA and FVA on the incremental exposure of the netting set | XVA charge in bp, valid for the day |
| 8 | Rates trader and sales | Quote the all-in rate on a recorded line; execute; hedge the DV01 in the interbank market or at a CCP | Executed trade and offsetting hedge |
| 9 | Middle office and product control | Book the trade, record the sales credit, classify fair-value level, decide day-one profit recognition | Trade in the risk system; P&L and Level 3 flag |
| 10 | Operations | Send and match the confirmation; report the trade under EMIR | Signed confirmation; trade repository report |
| 11 | Borealis and verifier | Deliver the KPI compliance certificate and verification report by 30 April each year | Certificate cross-referred from the RCF |
| 12 | Structuring and middle office | Determine the adjustment, amend the fixed rate for the next calculation period, notify the client | Rate adjustment notice |
| 13 | Operations and sustainable finance | Pay any premium for missed SPTs to the agreed charity and record it | Payment evidence and annual SLD report |
| 14 | Credit risk and XVA desk | Annual review of the line; restructure, novate or terminate the swap if Borealis refinances | Credit review; termination or novation agreement |
Policy and request. The trigger is never the bank’s product but the client’s hedging policy, a board document that sets the share of debt at fixed rates (Borealis targets 60 to 80%), the instruments allowed (no options sold, no leverage) and the minimum rating of counterparties. The treasurer allocates hedges to banks that lend to the group, usually in proportion to their commitment in the revolving facility. Meridian, with 10% of the Borealis RCF and the role of sustainability coordinator (see B03), expects its share.
Conduct checks before the trade. Borealis is a professional client under MiFID II. Sales still documents the appropriateness of the hedge (the notional and maturity match an identified exposure) and sends the ex-ante disclosure of costs and charges, which must show the total spread over mid-market, including XVA and margin, in euros. For an SLD, the disclosure should show separately what the KPI clause can cost or earn the client. A swap whose only purpose is the KPI clause would fail the hedge test under the client’s policy and, possibly, under EMIR.
Credit and documentation. Credit risk sizes the line on the potential future exposure of the netting set, not on the notional, and relies on Meridian’s legal opinion that close-out netting under the ISDA Master Agreement is enforceable in Borealis’s jurisdiction. Documentation negotiates the Schedule once and the sustainability-linked provisions for the new trade: KPI definitions by cross-reference to the facility agreement, the certificate deadline, the verification agent, the consequence, review and declassification events, and the charity clause.
Pricing and execution. On the trade date, the XVA desk prices the incremental CVA and FVA of the new trade inside the existing netting set; sales adds the margin; the trader quotes mid-market live. The treasurer often runs a competitive quote among two or three relationship banks on the same terms; the KPI clause makes comparison harder, which is a conduct point in itself. Once executed, the trader hedges the DV01 within minutes, usually through a cleared interbank swap.
Booking, control and reporting. Middle office books the trade with its KPI terms. Product control decides whether the valuation relies on significant unobservable inputs: if so, the trade is Level 3 under IFRS 13 and part of the day-one profit may have to be deferred (section 5.4). Operations matches the confirmation and reports the trade to a trade repository the next working day.
The annual cycle. Each spring the certificate delivered under the RCF also feeds the swap. Middle office applies the new fixed rate from the next calculation period. If an SPT is missed, the premium is paid by Borealis to the charity named in the confirmation, and Meridian’s sustainable finance team keeps the evidence. If the RCF is refinanced as a plain facility or its KPIs are amended, the swap’s review event is triggered; failing agreement, the swap is declassified and continues at its original rate.
Question. What does Borealis need to hedge, and why now?
Data (case assumptions). Borealis Packaging is the BBB-rated European packaging group of module B03. On 2 November 2026 it signed a EUR 750m five-year sustainability-linked RCF with three KPIs, in which Meridian holds EUR 75m and acts as sustainability coordinator.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Revenue / EBITDA (FY2025) | EUR 5.2bn / EUR 780m |
| Gross debt / cash / net debt | EUR 2.1bn / EUR 0.15bn / EUR 1.95bn (2.5x EBITDA) |
| Fixed-rate bonds | EUR 1.0bn |
| Floating debt | EUR 500m commercial paper, EUR 150m average RCF drawings, EUR 450m bank term loan |
| Hedging policy | 60% to 80% of gross debt at fixed rates; no options sold |
| US subsidiary | Net assets about USD 600m (recycling and flexible packaging plants) |
| Credit spread (5-year, market estimate) | 100 bp over swaps |
| Internal rating at Meridian | BBB, one-year PD 0.20% |
With EUR 1.0bn fixed out of EUR 2.1bn, Borealis is below the floor of its own policy. The ECB raised its deposit rate twice in 2026, to 2.25% on 11 June and 2.50% on 10 September, and held it on 29 October; the treasurer wants to lock rates before further moves. Three requests reach Meridian’s sales team in the week of 9 November 2026:
INTERACTIVE LAB — Borealis’s fixed-rate share before and after the hedges
Check the hedging requests against the client’s policy range of 60% to 80% fixed-rate debt.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed-rate bonds outstanding | 0 to 3000 EUR m | 1000 EUR m |
| Floating-rate debt (CP, RCF drawings, term loan) | 0 to 3000 EUR m | 1100 EUR m |
| Payer swap notional | 0 to 1000 EUR m | 400 EUR m |
| New fixed-rate green bond, proceeds held until spent | 0 to 1000 EUR m | 500 EUR m |
| Pre-hedge notional | 0 to 1000 EUR m | 300 EUR m |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Fixed share today | 47.6 % |
| Fixed share after the swap | 66.7 % |
| Fixed share after swap and bond | 73.1 % |
| Pre-hedge as share of the planned bond | 60.0 % |
Try it. Set the swap to zero: even after the green bond the fixed share stays below the 60% floor, which is why the treasurer wants the swap now rather than after the bond.
Reading. The swap takes the fixed share from 47.6% to 66.7%; the bond, while its proceeds are held in cash pending allocation, lifts it to 73.1%. Borealis lands inside its policy range. The pre-hedge covers 60% of the planned bond, a prudent ratio for a forecast transaction whose size is not yet certain. Only the first trade carries KPIs. The second and third are plain hedges of a green bond; calling them “green swaps” would add a label, not a substance.
Question. Before any KPI, what fixed rate does Meridian quote, and what is each component for?
Data. Curve flat at 2.50% on 16 November 2026 (course convention; three-month EURIBOR was close to 2.67% in late October 2026). Notional EUR 400m, five years, Borealis pays fixed annually and receives six-month EURIBOR. XVA inputs (case assumptions): normal volatility of swap rates 80 bp a year, Borealis credit spread 100 bp, market LGD 60%, Meridian’s funding spread 30 bp (the guide’s five-year FTP liquidity premium), sales margin 5 bp.
Calculation. The XVA desk simulates the expected exposure of a receiver swap (Meridian receives fixed) on a quarterly grid. For an at-the-money swap under a normal model, expected positive exposure at date is approximately:
is the notional; the annuity of the remaining payments; the normal volatility of the swap rate; the standard normal density at zero, which gives the expected value of the positive part of a centred normal variable per unit of standard deviation. CVA and FVA then follow the formula of section 2.3, and each is converted into a running spread by dividing by .
Result. Expected exposure peaks at EUR 5.20m after about 1.6 years. CVA is EUR 166,700, or 0.90 bp a year; FVA EUR 49,900, or 0.27 bp. With the 5 bp sales margin the total spread is 6.17 bp and Meridian quotes Borealis 2.5617%, against a mid-market of 2.50%. The sales credit booked on the trade date is EUR 929,200.
INTERACTIVE LAB — From mid-market to the client’s swap rate: CVA, FVA and sales margin
Compute the expected exposure profile of an uncollateralised corporate swap, its CVA and FVA, and the all-in fixed rate quoted to the client.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Notional | 50 to 1000 EUR m | 400 EUR m |
| Tenor | 1 to 15 years | 5 years |
| Mid-market swap rate (flat curve) | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Normal volatility of swap rates | 20 to 150 bp per year | 80 bp per year |
| Client credit spread | 20 to 600 bp | 100 bp |
| Market LGD | 20 to 80 % | 60 % |
| Bank funding spread | 0 to 100 bp | 30 bp |
| Sales margin | 0 to 20 bp | 5 bp |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Peak expected exposure | 5.20 EUR m |
| Time of the peak | 1.625 years |
| Market-implied default intensity | 1.667 % per year |
| CVA | 166.7 EUR k |
| CVA as running spread | 0.90 bp |
| FVA (funding cost) | 49.9 EUR k |
| FVA as running spread | 0.27 bp |
| Total spread over mid-market | 6.17 bp |
| Fixed rate quoted to the client | 2.5617 % |
| Sales credit booked on trade date (PV of margin) | 929.2 EUR k |
Try it. Raise the client’s credit spread to 300 bp, a crossover name: CVA almost triples, and the client pays more for credit than the bank earns in margin.
Reading. Three lessons for the desk. First, the margin is the largest component but not the only one; a salesperson who quotes “mid plus 5” to a BBB client is giving away the XVA. Second, the components belong to different owners: the CVA goes to the XVA desk, which reserves it and hedges where it can; the FVA goes to Treasury; the sales margin is the desk’s profit. Third, the real-world expected loss that the credit committee sees (PD 0.20% times LGD 40%) is a fraction of the CVA, which uses the market-implied default intensity of 1.67% a year (100 bp divided by 60%). That gap is the market price of credit risk; it is not profit, because the XVA desk’s hedges cost the same.
WHY IT MATTERS ON THE DESK — When the treasurer runs a competition between three banks, the winning quote is often the one with the lowest XVA, that is, the bank with the largest existing netting benefit or the cheapest funding. Sales needs to know the decomposition to defend a price or to explain why a competitor is cheaper.
Question. How should the three RCF KPIs be wired into the swap, and what do they move in euros?
Design choices. The structuring team and the sustainable finance solutions team propose, and Borealis accepts, the following provisions, drafted from the ISDA clause library:
| Provision | Borealis swap |
|---|---|
| KPIs and SPTs | The three KPIs and FY2026 to FY2030 SPTs of the RCF (see B03), by cross-reference |
| Certificate and verifier | The RCF sustainability compliance certificate and verification report, due 30 April |
| Consequence | Fixed rate adjusted by 0.5 bp per KPI: lower if met, higher if missed (maximum 1.5 bp either way) |
| Application | Fixed-rate calculation period starting on the 18 November after the certificate |
| Premium for missed SPTs | Paid by Borealis to an agreed environmental charity, not to Meridian |
| Review and declassification | Linked to the RCF: amendment or declassification of the RCF triggers the same in the swap |
| Failure to pay the premium | Declassification event, not an event of default |
The SPTs are those of B03: scope 1 and 2 emissions of at most 832, 790, 748, 706 and 664 ktCO2e for FY2026 to FY2030; recycled content in plastic packaging of at least 22, 26, 30, 34 and 38%; share of purchased-goods emissions covered by suppliers with science-based targets of at least 35, 42, 50, 58 and 67%.
Why 0.5 bp per KPI and not the RCF’s 1 bp. The step is set against the bank’s margin, not the client’s cost. On the RCF, Meridian’s 3 bp maximum is 4.3% of a 70 bp margin. On the swap the sales margin is 5 bp; a 3 bp step would take 60% of it. Even at 0.5 bp per KPI, the maximum adjustment of 1.5 bp is 30% of the margin.
Why the charity clause. In the RCF, lenders keep the premium when Borealis misses an SPT, and the B03 pitfall warned against budgeting for a client’s failure. Borealis asked for a cleaner structure in the swap, and Meridian agreed: discounts are paid by Meridian through a lower fixed rate, premiums are paid by Borealis to a charity. The client faces a two-way incentive; the bank faces only the cost.
FORMULA
is the change in Borealis’s all-in fixed rate for the period that follows test year ; the step per KPI (0.5 bp); the number of SPTs met (0 to 3); the notional. One basis point on EUR 400m is EUR 40,000 a year.
Timing. The swap pays fixed each 18 November from 2027 to 2031. The FY2026 certificate (April 2027) sets the rate for the period November 2027 to November 2028, paid in November 2028; FY2029 sets the last period, paid in November 2031. Four tests count; the FY2030 result, known in April 2031, comes too late for a swap ending in November 2031. A lump-sum sustainability-linked payment, an option of the clause library, would have captured it.
Case path. We replay the outcomes of B03: SPTs met 3, 1, 2 and 3 in FY2026 to FY2029. Borealis’s rate changes by -1.5, +0.5, -0.5 and -1.5 bp in the four periods.
Result. Borealis saves EUR 120,000 over the life of the swap, undiscounted (3 basis-point-years at EUR 40,000), with a present value of EUR 109,700 at 2.50%. Meridian pays EUR 180,000 in discounts (present value EUR 165,000), and the charity receives EUR 60,000 in premiums (FY2027 and FY2028 misses). With all SPTs met every year, Borealis’s saving is EUR 60,000 a year; adding the RCF discount of B03 (EUR 108,000 at 20% utilisation), the whole sustainability-linked package is worth EUR 168,000 a year to a group with EUR 780m of EBITDA.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Sustainability-linked swap: who pays what, period by period
Turn the annual KPI tests into fixed-rate adjustments and show the flows for Borealis, Meridian and the charity, with the premium either donated or kept by the bank.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Swap notional | 50 to 1000 EUR m | 400 EUR m |
| Adjustment per KPI | 0 to 2 bp | 0.5 bp |
| KPI outcome | Case path / All SPTs met / All SPTs missed | Case path |
| Premium for missed SPTs paid to | Charity / Meridian | Charity |
| Discount rate | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Sales margin of the swap | 1 to 20 bp | 5 bp |
| RCF discount if all SPTs met (from B03) | 0 to 300 EUR k per year | 108 EUR k per year |
| Borealis EBITDA | 100 to 3000 EUR m | 780 EUR m |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Value of 1 bp for one year | 40.0 EUR k |
| Maximum adjustment | 1.50 bp |
| Maximum adjustment as share of sales margin | 30.0 % |
| Borealis saving over the life, undiscounted | 120.0 EUR k |
| Borealis saving, present value | 109.7 EUR k |
| Meridian net flow, undiscounted | -180.0 EUR k |
| Meridian net flow, present value | -165.0 EUR k |
| Paid to charity, undiscounted | 60.0 EUR k |
| Swap plus RCF saving in a year with all SPTs met | 168.0 EUR k |
| Maximum annual swap saving as share of EBITDA | 0.77 bp |
Try it. Switch the premium to ‘Meridian’ and the outcome to ‘All SPTs missed’: the bank now earns EUR 240k from its client’s failure. That is the incentive the charity clause removes.
Reading. The swap KPI clause is small for Borealis (at most 0.77 bp of EBITDA a year) and large for the desk (up to 30% of its margin). It adds no new information: the KPIs, the targets, the certificate and the verifier are those of the RCF. What it adds is a second price tag on the same targets. The treasurer’s argument (“the whole package tells the same story”) is a communication argument; Meridian’s sustainable finance team records in its memo that the swap does not raise ambition and should not be counted as a separate sustainable transaction in the bank’s volumes, only flagged as linked to a classified facility.
PITFALL — Do not quote the adjustment in basis points of the fixed rate without converting it. “Minus 1.5 bp” sounds like the RCF’s “minus 3 bp” halved. In euros the swap discount (EUR 60,000 a year) is more than half the RCF one, because the swap notional is fully “drawn” while the RCF is 80% undrawn and pays only 35% of the margin on that part.
Question. On the trade date, what is the KPI clause worth to Meridian, and what does product control do with that number?
Data. The KPI flows of the four periods depend on whether Borealis meets its SPTs. No market prices this probability. The desk’s best estimate, agreed with the sustainable finance team after reviewing Borealis’s capex plan, is a 70% probability of meeting each SPT each year (case assumption, applied independently to each KPI for simplicity). Discount factors from the flat 2.50% curve; the sum of discount factors for payment years 2 to 5 is 3.6702.
Calculation. With the charity design, Meridian pays for each SPT met and receives nothing for a miss, so its expected annual flow is . If Meridian kept the premiums, the expected flow would be .
is the step per KPI; the probability of meeting an SPT; the notional; the discount factor of the payment in year .
Result. Expected cost to Meridian EUR 42,000 a year, present value EUR 154,100. In the worst case for Meridian (every SPT met) the present value is EUR 220,200. The gap, EUR 66,100, measures the valuation uncertainty. Set against the day-one sales credit of EUR 929,200, the worst-case KPI leg is 23.7%: the unobservable input is significant.
Three consequences follow inside the bank.
A last option, and the most debated: the desk could have priced the expected KPI cost into the fixed rate. Spreading EUR 154,100 over the swap’s annuity gives 0.83 bp. Borealis would then have been quoted a fixed rate 0.83 bp higher, and would have financed its own expected discount. The structure would still carry a two-way incentive at the margin, but the “discount” would no longer be a concession. Meridian chose not to, as a relationship decision, and records the KPI leg as a cost of the relationship.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Valuing the KPI leg: expected cost, worst case and the share of day-one profit
Value the sustainability-linked component of the swap as a function of the probability of meeting each SPT, compare the charity and bank-keeps-premium designs, and measure the unobservable share of day-one profit.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Swap notional | 50 to 1000 EUR m | 400 EUR m |
| Adjustment per KPI | 0 to 2 bp | 0.5 bp |
| Probability of meeting each SPT | 0 to 100 % | 70 % |
| Premium for missed SPTs paid to | Charity / Meridian | Charity |
| Sales margin | 1 to 20 bp | 5 bp |
| Flat curve | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Sum of discount factors, payment years 2 to 5 | 3.6702 |
| Expected annual KPI flow for Meridian | -42.0 EUR k |
| Fair value of the KPI leg (best estimate) | -154.1 EUR k |
| Value if every SPT is met | -220.2 EUR k |
| Valuation reserve to the worst case | 66.1 EUR k |
| Day-one sales credit | 929.2 EUR k |
| Worst-case KPI leg as share of day-one sales credit | 23.7 % |
| Running spread that would make the client fund the expected discount | 0.83 bp |
Try it. Choose ‘Meridian’ and a 50% probability: the KPI leg is worth zero on average, yet the valuation uncertainty doubles. Keeping the premium does not remove the Level 3 problem; it makes it two-sided.
WHO DOES WHAT — Product control owns the fair-value level and the day-one deferral, using the probability set in the desk’s valuation memo, which the sustainable finance team reviews each spring after the certificate. Market risk cannot hedge the KPI leg; it reports it as an unhedgeable residual. The independent price verification team checks the probability against the client’s published progress.
Question. Borealis will price a seven-year green bond in late January 2027. What does a pre-hedge lock, and what does it not?
Data (case assumptions). On 16 November 2026 Borealis enters a forward-starting seven-year payer swap on EUR 300m with Meridian, starting on the expected settlement date of the bond, 26 January 2027. The forward seven-year rate on the flat curve is 2.50%; Meridian charges 1 bp (the XVA is small because the swap will be terminated within ten weeks), so the pre-hedge rate is 2.51%. Had Borealis issued on 16 November, its new-issue spread of 110 bp would have given a yield of 3.60%. Scenario: on pricing day, 19 January 2027, the seven-year mid-swap rate is 2.80% (+30 bp) and the spread is unchanged; the bond is priced at par with a 3.90% coupon.
Calculation. On pricing day the pre-hedge is terminated at its market value, which Meridian pays to Borealis:
is the termination payment; the hedge notional (EUR 300m); the seven-year swap rate on pricing day; the pre-hedge rate; the seven-year annuity at . Spread over the bond’s life at the bond yield, the gain reduces the effective cost of the hedged part:
is the bond yield (3.90%) and the annuity at that yield.
Result. The termination payment is EUR 5.461m. The effective cost of the hedged EUR 300m is 3.598%, essentially the 3.60% available in November; across the EUR 500m bond the blended cost is 3.719%, against 3.90% without hedge. The DV01 of the pre-hedge is EUR 190,500, so Meridian’s 1 bp charge is worth EUR 190,500 on the trade date. If rates had fallen by 30 bp instead, Borealis would have paid EUR 5.973m on termination and still ended with a hedged cost of 3.623%: the pre-hedge locks a level, it does not bet on a direction. If Borealis’s credit spread widens by 20 bp before pricing, the hedged cost rises to 3.796%: the pre-hedge covers the swap rate, not the credit spread.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Pre-hedging a green bond with a forward-starting swap
Compute the termination value of a pre-hedge on pricing day and the issuer’s effective cost of debt, for any rate and spread move between hedge and issue.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-hedge notional | 0 to 1000 EUR m | 300 EUR m |
| Bond size | 100 to 1500 EUR m | 500 EUR m |
| Bond and swap tenor | 3 to 15 years | 7 years |
| Forward swap rate on hedge date | 0 to 6 % | 2.5 % |
| Bank charge on the pre-hedge | 0 to 5 bp | 1 bp |
| Swap rate move to pricing day | -100 to 100 bp | 30 bp |
| New-issue spread on hedge date | 30 to 400 bp | 110 bp |
| Spread move to pricing day | -50 to 100 bp | 0 bp |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Pre-hedge fixed rate | 2.510 % |
| Swap rate on pricing day | 2.800 % |
| Termination payment to the issuer (negative = paid by issuer) | 5.461 EUR m |
| Bond yield and coupon at par | 3.900 % |
| Effective cost of the hedged part | 3.598 % |
| Yield available on hedge date | 3.600 % |
| Effective cost of the whole bond | 3.719 % |
| DV01 of the pre-hedge | 190.5 EUR k |
| Hedge result released to interest expense per year (straight line) | 0.780 EUR m |
| Bank revenue on trade date (charge x DV01) | 190.5 EUR k |
Try it. Move the spread by +50 bp with rates unchanged: the pre-hedge pays nothing and the issuer bears the whole widening. Rate risk and credit risk are two different hedges, and only the first exists for a corporate.
Reading and accounting. Borealis designates the pre-hedge as a cash-flow hedge of a highly probable forecast issuance under IFRS 9. The EUR 5.461m gain goes to other comprehensive income on termination and is released to interest expense over the seven years of the bond (about EUR 0.78m a year on a straight-line view; the actual release follows the bond’s interest profile). The hedged amount must remain highly probable: had Borealis issued only EUR 250m, the excess EUR 50m of hedge would have gone straight to profit or loss. This is why treasurers rarely hedge 100% of a planned issue.
Is the pre-hedge green? No. It hedges the rate on a green bond, and Meridian books it as a plain swap. The use-of-proceeds commitments, the allocation report and any EU Green Bond Standard alignment belong to the bond (see C01). A bank that adds the pre-hedge notional to its “green” volumes counts the same euros twice.
WHO DOES WHAT — Sales and the DCM syndicate desk coordinate on pricing day (see C01): the swap trader terminates the pre-hedge at the moment the bond’s reoffer spread is set, using the same mid-market swap rate that fixes the coupon, so that the issuer is not exposed to a move between the two. Compliance manages the information barrier, since the rates desk knows of an imminent bond issue.
Question. At what dollar rate can Borealis convert EUR 200m of the green bond into a dollar liability, and what risk does Meridian take?
Data (case assumptions on 19 January 2027). EUR/USD spot 1.12 (close to where it traded in early November 2026); USD seven-year swap rate 3.75% (consistent with a federal funds target range of 3.75% to 4.00%, unchanged on 28 October 2026); EUR seven-year swap rate 2.80%; green bond coupon 3.90%; cross-currency basis −10 bp on the euro leg (case assumption; the sign and size move with dollar funding conditions); EUR/USD volatility 8% a year; Borealis credit spread 100 bp; sales margin 8 bp. Structure: fixed-for-fixed, seven years. At start Borealis pays EUR 200m and receives USD 224m; each year it receives 3.90% on EUR 200m (which pays the bond coupon) and pays a fixed dollar rate on USD 224m; at maturity the notionals are re-exchanged.
Calculation. Receiving a euro fixed rate is equivalent to receiving the euro swap rate plus the bond’s spread over it; through the basis market, a euro floating leg is worth the dollar floating leg minus the basis. Ignoring the small difference between euro and dollar annuities:
is the mid-market dollar fixed rate; and the seven-year swap rates; the euro coupon received; the cross-currency basis on the euro leg. With bp, the euro receiver earns 10 bp less in the basis market, so the dollar rate it can pay rises by 10 bp.
The CVA is driven by the currency move on the final exchange: expected exposure is approximately , a profile that grows to maturity instead of a hump.
Result. Mid-market dollar rate 4.95%; CVA EUR 657,000, or 5.23 bp a year; with the 8 bp margin Borealis pays 5.0823% on USD 224m, a dollar coupon of USD 11.38m a year. The sales margin is worth EUR 160,000 a year. Under SA-CCR the trade’s exposure at default is EUR 27.74m at inception, more than twice the EUR 12.39m of the five-year IRS on twice the notional. If the euro falls by 10% (to 1.008), the swap is worth EUR 22.22m to Meridian and the exposure at default rises to EUR 58.85m. Borealis loses the same amount on the swap and gains it on its US net assets: the hedge works, and Meridian’s credit risk on Borealis doubles.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Fixed-for-fixed cross-currency swap: dollar rate, CVA and exposure
Price the dollar rate of a EUR/USD cross-currency swap that converts a euro bond into a dollar liability, and see how the bank’s exposure moves with the exchange rate.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Euro notional | 50 to 1000 EUR m | 200 EUR m |
| EUR/USD spot at inception | 0.9 to 1.4 USD per EUR | 1.12 USD per EUR |
| EUR/USD spot today | 0.8 to 1.5 USD per EUR | 1.12 USD per EUR |
| Tenor | 2 to 15 years | 7 years |
| USD swap rate | 0 to 7 % | 3.75 % |
| EUR swap rate | 0 to 6 % | 2.8 % |
| Euro coupon received (bond coupon) | 0 to 8 % | 3.9 % |
| Cross-currency basis on the euro leg | -60 to 30 bp | -10 bp |
| EUR/USD volatility | 3 to 20 % per year | 8 % per year |
| Client credit spread | 20 to 600 bp | 100 bp |
| Sales margin | 0 to 30 bp | 8 bp |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Dollar notional | 224.0 USD m |
| Mid-market dollar fixed rate | 4.950 % |
| CVA (FX component) | 657.0 EUR k |
| CVA as running spread | 5.23 bp |
| Dollar rate paid by the client | 5.0823 % |
| Annual dollar coupon | 11.384 USD m |
| Sales margin per year | 160.0 EUR k |
| Value to the bank of the notional re-exchange at today’s spot | 0.00 EUR m |
| SA-CCR add-on (FX plus two interest-rate legs) | 19.81 EUR m |
| SA-CCR exposure at default | 27.74 EUR m |
Try it. Move today’s spot to 1.25: the swap is now in Borealis’s favour, Meridian’s replacement cost is zero and the SA-CCR multiplier reduces the potential future exposure, but the add-on never falls to zero.
Reading. The CCS is the trade that consumes the bank’s credit appetite: its CVA is 5.23 bp a year against 0.90 bp for the five-year IRS, and its exposure is driven by a variable, the dollar, whose large moves tend to come in crises. It is also the trade where Borealis’s own hedge is cleanest: under IFRS 9 a net investment hedge of the US subsidiary, in which the swap’s currency revaluation offsets the translation of the subsidiary’s net assets in equity. Treasurers often exclude the cross-currency basis from the hedge relationship and account for it as a cost of hedging, which removes most of the ineffectiveness.
PITFALL — A cross-currency swap that converts a green bond into dollars does not make the dollars green, nor does it change the allocation of proceeds. The allocation report must still trace the EUR 500m to eligible projects, wherever they sit. The swap only changes the currency of the liability.
Question. Is the package worth Meridian’s capital, and what does the KPI clause do to the answer?
Data. Revenues per year: IRS sales margin 5 bp on EUR 400m (EUR 200,000); CCS sales margin 8 bp on EUR 200m (EUR 160,000); the pre-hedge’s EUR 190,500 spread over five years (EUR 38,100). The CVA and FVA charges are transferred to the XVA desk and to Treasury, which use them to reserve credit losses and pay funding; they are not counted as revenue. Operating costs: 60% of revenues before the KPI clause (the guide’s ratio for markets revenues). Expected loss: Meridian’s convention, PD 0.20% times LGD 40% times EAD, which overlaps the CVA reserve and is therefore conservative. Capital: 13% of RWA. Both swaps sit in one netting set under the ISDA Master Agreement. Borealis is a non-financial counterparty, so the trades are exempt from the CVA risk capital requirement under Article 382(4) CRR. Market risk is hedged at mid with other banks; residual market-risk capital is ignored. The KPI clause is assessed, like the RCF ratchet in B03, at its full discount (1.5 bp on EUR 400m, EUR 60,000 a year).
Calculation: SA-CCR. For an unmargined netting set:
; the replacement cost (zero at inception); the potential future exposure, the sum of asset-class add-ons times a multiplier equal to 1 when the netting set has no negative value; the interest-rate supervisory factor; the effective notional of each currency’s hedging set, built from adjusted notionals (notional times supervisory duration , with the end date in years) aggregated across the maturity buckets of one year or less, one to five years and more than five years with correlations of 70% between adjacent buckets and 30% between the extreme ones; the FX add-on is 4% of the notional converted into euros.
In the euro hedging set, the IRS (Meridian receives fixed, five years) and the euro leg of the CCS (Meridian pays fixed, seven years) have opposite signs and sit in adjacent buckets, so they partly offset. The F-IRB risk weight for a PD of 0.20% and an LGD of 40% is 39.02%, as in B03.
Result.
| Line | EUR k per year |
|---|---|
| Revenues (IRS 200.0, CCS 160.0, pre-hedge 38.1) | 398.1 |
| Operating costs (60%) | -238.9 |
| Expected loss (0.20% x 40% x EUR 28.32m) | -22.7 |
| Pre-tax result before KPI clause | 136.6 |
| Net result after 25% tax | 102.4 |
| KPI clause at full discount, before tax | -60.0 |
Exposure at default of the netting set: EUR 28.32m, against EUR 12.39m and EUR 27.74m for the two swaps taken separately (EUR 40.12m in total): netting saves 29%. RWA EUR 11.05m, allocated capital EUR 1.437m.
The amounts are in EUR thousand. With the KPI clause at full discount, RAROC falls to 4.00%. To reach the 12% hurdle, the package would need EUR 631,300 of revenues without the KPI clause and EUR 781,300 with it. Without the CVA exemption, the BA-CVA capital charge would add EUR 24.33m of RWA, more than twice the counterparty credit RWA, and RAROC would fall to 2.23%.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Meridian’s RAROC on the Borealis hedging package: SA-CCR, CVA exemption and KPI clause
Rebuild exposure at default, RWA, capital and RAROC of the IRS plus CCS netting set, and test netting, the EU CVA exemption and the cost of the KPI clause.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| IRS sales margin on EUR 400m, 5 years | 0 to 15 bp | 5 bp |
| CCS sales margin on EUR 200m, 7 years | 0 to 30 bp | 8 bp |
| Pre-hedge revenue spread over five years | 0 to 200 EUR k per year | 38.1 EUR k per year |
| KPI discount borne by Meridian | 0 to 3 bp on EUR 400m | 1.5 bp on EUR 400m |
| Both swaps in one ISDA netting set | yes / no | yes |
| EU exemption from CVA capital for non-financial counterparties | yes / no | yes |
| One-year PD | 0.05 to 4 % | 0.2 % |
| Cost-income ratio on markets revenues | 30 to 80 % | 60 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| EAD of the IRS alone | 12.39 EUR m |
| EAD of the CCS alone | 27.74 EUR m |
| EAD used | 28.32 EUR m |
| F-IRB risk weight | 39.02 % |
| Counterparty credit RWA | 11.05 EUR m |
| BA-CVA RWA if not exempt | 24.33 EUR m |
| Total RWA used | 11.05 EUR m |
| Allocated capital (13%) | 1.437 EUR m |
| Revenues before KPI clause | 398.1 EUR k |
| Operating costs | 238.9 EUR k |
| Expected loss | 22.7 EUR k |
| Pre-tax result before KPI clause | 136.6 EUR k |
| Net result before KPI clause | 102.4 EUR k |
| KPI clause cost per year | 60.0 EUR k |
| RAROC without KPI clause | 7.13 % |
| RAROC with KPI clause | 4.00 % |
| Revenues needed for 12%, without KPI clause | 631.3 EUR k |
| Revenues needed for 12%, with KPI clause | 781.3 EUR k |
| EAD saved by netting | 29.4 % |
| RWA per euro of annual revenue | 27.8 EUR |
Try it. Switch the CVA exemption off: the package needs three times the capital. Then set the KPI discount to 3 bp, the RCF’s step: the package’s return on capital falls below 1%.
Reading. Four findings for the credit application. First, corporate hedging is not cheap in capital: the package carries EUR 27.8 of RWA per euro of annual revenue, against the EUR 2.5 assumed in B03’s account plan for ancillary business. The shortcut is right for payments and FX spot, wrong for long-dated uncollateralised swaps; B03’s relationship RAROC is therefore flattered on its hedging line. Second, the EU’s CVA exemption for non-financial counterparties is worth more to this business than any green feature: without it the package returns about 2%. Third, the package does not reach the hurdle on its own, with or without the KPI clause; it is approved as part of the Borealis relationship, whose revenues the coverage banker tracks. Fourth, the KPI clause that costs Borealis’s lenders 4% of their RCF margin costs the swap desk 30% of its margin and three points of RAROC. That is the arithmetic behind the rarity of SLDs.
Decision. The credit committee approves the package with three conditions that follow from these numbers. The trades must be booked under the existing ISDA Master Agreement with Borealis’s parent, so that netting applies; a CCS signed by the US subsidiary would lose 29% of the netting benefit and need its own limit. The KPI clause is approved at its full discount, not at the 70% best estimate, as for the RCF in B03. And the coverage banker’s relationship review must show, a year later, that the hedging revenues materialised and that Borealis’s next mandates (the green bond’s bookrunner role, cash management) came to Meridian. If they did not, the next hedge request will be priced to the hurdle on its own, with or without KPIs.
WHY IT MATTERS ON THE DESK — When a treasurer asks for “the same KPIs in the swap”, the salesperson must answer with this table: the step that is harmless on a loan is heavy on a derivative, and the bank can offer either a smaller step, a price that includes the expected cost, or no KPI clause. Pretending that the discount is free leads to deals that the desk later tries to recover in other ways, which is a conduct risk.
| Figure | Value | Stage |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed share of debt: today / after swap / after bond | 47.6% / 66.7% / 73.1% | 5.1 |
| Five-year swap: mid / annuity / DV01 | 2.50% / 4.6458 / EUR 185,833 | 2.1 |
| CVA / FVA / sales margin (bp) | 0.90 / 0.27 / 5.00 | 5.2 |
| Client fixed rate / day-one sales credit | 2.5617% / EUR 929,200 | 5.2 |
| KPI step / maximum / share of margin | 0.5 bp per KPI / 1.5 bp / 30% | 5.3 |
| Case path: Borealis saving (PV) / Meridian cost (PV) / charity | EUR 109,700 / EUR 165,000 / EUR 60,000 | 5.3 |
| KPI leg PV at 70% / worst case / reserve | EUR -154,100 / EUR -220,200 / EUR 66,100 | 5.4 |
| Worst-case KPI leg / day-one credit; self-funding spread | 23.7%; 0.83 bp | 5.4 |
| Pre-hedge: gain at +30 bp / hedged cost / blended cost | EUR 5.461m / 3.598% / 3.719% | 5.5 |
| CCS: mid USD rate / client rate / CVA | 4.95% / 5.0823% / 5.23 bp | 5.6 |
| CCS EAD at inception / after a 10% euro fall | EUR 27.74m / EUR 58.85m | 5.6 |
| Package EAD / RWA / capital | EUR 28.32m / EUR 11.05m / EUR 1.437m | 5.7 |
| RAROC without / with KPI clause / without CVA exemption | 7.13% / 4.00% / 2.23% | 5.7 |
| Revenues needed for 12%: without / with KPI clause | EUR 631,300 / EUR 781,300 | 5.7 |
IN ONE SENTENCE — A derivative consumes capital three times: for the client’s default (counterparty credit risk), for the volatility of the credit adjustment on the client (CVA risk), and for the market risk that the trader did not hedge.
Counterparty credit risk. Since 2021 EU banks without an internal model method compute exposure with SA-CCR (CRR Articles 274 to 280f), recalled in section 5.7. Three points matter on the desk. The alpha of 1.4 multiplies everything, so an unmargined corporate swap carries 40% more exposure than its add-on; the industry has argued for years that alpha should not apply to end-users, so far without success in the EU. Margined netting sets benefit from a lower maturity factor and from collateral in the replacement cost, which is why bank-to-bank trades consume little capital and corporate trades a lot. And netting only works inside one netting set: a CCS booked under a different legal entity of Borealis would have lost the 29% saving of section 5.7. The resulting EAD is then risk-weighted like a loan: F-IRB with the regulatory LGD of 40% and Meridian’s convention of M = 2.5 years (39.02% for Borealis), or 75% for a BBB corporate under the standardised approach.
CVA risk. CRR3 replaced the old CVA charge from 1 January 2025 by three approaches: the standardised approach (SA-CVA, sensitivity-based, requiring supervisory approval), the basic approach (BA-CVA, used in section 5.7 for comparison) and, for small books, a simplified approach. The EU kept the exemptions of Article 382(4): transactions with non-financial counterparties, pension funds in a transitional period, intragroup trades and some sovereign exposures do not attract CVA capital. The Basel standard has no such exemption, and supervisors monitor the exempted CVA through reporting; the EBA’s November 2025 follow-up report on part of the exemption asked supervisors to continue that monitoring. The economic CVA charged to Borealis is unaffected: the XVA desk still prices and reserves it.
Market risk. The trader’s offsetting hedge leaves little delta, but residual basis and curve risks remain in the trading book. FRTB applies in the EU from 1 January 2027, with a temporary multiplier adopted by the Commission on 4 June 2026 (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/1221) to offset part of the impact for three years. The KPI leg is a non-modellable residual: it cannot be hedged and sits in the residual risk add-on or the valuation reserves.
Leverage ratio. SA-CCR exposure also enters the leverage ratio exposure measure. A bank close to its leverage constraint prices long-dated corporate swaps more expensively whatever their risk weight.
Section 5.7 is the credit application’s table. The sustainable feature touches three lines and leaves two unchanged. Revenues: the KPI discount, up to EUR 60,000 a year, is a direct reduction, since the charity design gives the bank no premium to offset it; Meridian chose not to price the expected cost into the rate. Costs: structuring, documentation and the annual adjustment add a few hours of work per year, not charged to the trade. Valuation: the Level 3 classification defers part of the day-one profit and the reserve of EUR 66,100 is deducted from CET1. Capital and expected loss do not move: SA-CCR ignores the KPI flows, which are too small to change the replacement cost materially, and nothing in CRR3 rewards a sustainability-linked derivative. The RAROC falls from 7.13% to 4.00% at full discount. The B03 lesson applies with more force: the bank pays for the KPI clause out of a thin residual, and only the relationship justifies it.
INTUITION — Meridian stands between an unmargined client and a margined market. When rates fall, Borealis owes Meridian money on the swap but pays nothing until each coupon date, while Meridian’s hedge counterparty calls cash collateral every day. Treasury lends that cash to the desk, and the FVA pays for it.
The FVA of section 5.2 (0.27 bp on the IRS) is the desk’s FTP for derivatives: the expected positive exposure times Meridian’s funding spread. The mirror case, when the swap is in Borealis’s favour, creates a funding benefit (the hedge counterparty posts collateral to Meridian); Meridian, like most banks, does not pass it to clients. The liquidity regulation adds two charges that Treasury allocates to derivative desks: under the LCR, an outflow equal to the largest net 30-day collateral flow observed over the previous 24 months (the historical look-back approach of Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/208), and under the NSFR a required stable funding factor on gross derivative liabilities. For a corporate franchise whose client trades are all one-way (corporates pay fixed when they hedge floating debt), these charges are concentrated and grow when rates fall.
Meridian. All derivatives are measured at fair value through profit or loss under IFRS 9. Fair value includes CVA, DVA and FVA. The Borealis SLD is Level 3 under IFRS 13 because of the KPI leg (section 5.4), with the day-one profit deferred under paragraph B5.1.2A for the unobservable part and a sensitivity disclosure of the KPI assumption. The pre-hedge and the CCS are Level 2. Meridian does not apply hedge accounting to client trades and their market hedges, which offset in profit or loss.
Borealis. The client’s accounting is where the KPI clause bites.
| Trade | Hedge type under IFRS 9 | Effect of the sustainable layer |
|---|---|---|
| 5-year SL payer swap | Cash-flow hedge of floating debt | KPI flows are not in the hypothetical derivative: ineffectiveness in P&L |
| Pre-hedge | Cash-flow hedge of a forecast issuance | None; the bond’s green label is irrelevant to the hedge |
| CCS | Net investment hedge, basis as cost of hedging | None |
For the SL swap, Borealis must also document that the instrument meets the definition of a derivative despite a non-financial variable specific to itself; most auditors accept that the interest-rate underlying dominates when the KPI flows are small. A large KPI step would weaken that argument, and with it hedge accounting: one more reason why steps stay small.
Green Asset Ratio and Pillar 3. Derivatives are outside the numerator and, since Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/73 (Official Journal 8 January 2026, applicable from 1 January 2026), outside the denominator of the GAR as well. The EBA’s final draft Pillar 3 ESG standards of June 2026 remove the GAR and BTAR templates (see E06); the transition-risk templates concern the banking book’s loans, debt securities and equity, not derivatives. The SLD therefore appears in no regulatory sustainability ratio.
Financed and facilitated emissions. The PCAF standard does not cover derivatives, and the December 2025 amendments to IFRS S2 allow financial institutions to exclude derivatives from their category 15 disclosure. The green bond that the pre-hedge serves generates facilitated emissions for its bookrunners (see C01), not for the rates desk.
Voluntary targets. Many banks publish sustainable finance mobilisation targets with internal definitions. Counting the notional of SLDs, or of hedges of green bonds, inflates them: EUR 900m of notional in this case for a client whose sustainability-linked facility is already counted. Meridian’s classification policy counts neither; it flags the SLD as “linked to a classified facility” for internal tracking. A bank that counts swap notionals should say so and disclose the amount.
| Risk | Control | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| SLD sold as the reason to hedge | Hedge rationale in client file; MiFID appropriateness | Sales supervision, Compliance |
| KPI recycled with no added ambition | Classification memo; no separate volume count | Sustainable finance solutions |
| KPI leg mis-valued, day-one profit overstated | Level 3 policy; independent price verification | Product control |
| Bank profits from client’s failure | Charity clause or disclosed premium policy | Structuring, Legal |
| KPI dispute or late certificate | Clause library dispute and declassification terms | Documentation, middle office |
| RCF refinanced, swap orphaned | Review event cross-referring the facility | Structuring, coverage |
| Counterparty exposure on CCS after FX move | Limit on potential future exposure; CVA hedging | Credit risk, XVA desk |
| Client hedge accounting fails | Small steps; early discussion with client’s auditor | Sales, structuring |
| Pre-hedge information leak before bond | Wall-crossing, information barrier | Compliance, DCM |
| Double counting in sustainable finance volumes | Classification policy and disclosure | Finance, sustainability reporting |
Red-flag checklist for a sustainability-linked or “green” derivative.
| Date | Fact | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Aug 2019 | First publicised sustainability-linked swap, ING with SBM Offshore | Environmental Finance; Risk.net |
| Sep 2021 | ISDA KPI guidelines for SLDs; paper on accounting for ESG features | ISDA |
| Dec 2021 | ISDA regulatory considerations; Category 1 and Category 2 SLDs | ISDA |
| 17 Jan 2024 | ISDA SLD Clause Library launched on MyLibrary | ISDA |
| May 2024 | IASB amendments on classification and measurement, ESG-linked features | IFRS Foundation |
| 1 Jan 2025 | CRR3 applies; new CVA framework; Article 382(4) exemptions kept | CRR3; EBA |
| 1 Jan 2026 | IFRS 9 amendments effective; Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/73 applies | EUR-Lex |
| 4 Jun 2026 | Commission adopts temporary FRTB adjustments, application 1 Jan 2027 | European Commission |
| Jun and Sep 2026 | ECB raises deposit rate to 2.25%, then 2.50%; held on 29 Oct 2026 | ECB |
| 10 Nov 2026 | EMIR 3 clearing threshold regime applies | Official Journal, 21 Oct 2026 |
Orders of magnitude. No public statistic measures the SLD market; volumes are bilateral and announcements selective. All figures for pricing in this module are case assumptions: a few basis points of sales margin on a five-year corporate IRS, about 1 bp of CVA for a BBB client, and a KPI step of a fraction of a basis point to a few basis points. Rates at the time of the case: ECB deposit rate 2.50% and US federal funds target range 3.75% to 4.00% (both held in late October 2026); EUR/USD around 1.12 in early November 2026.
What changed recently. The ISDA clause library has standardised vocabulary, and most new SLDs reference the client’s loan certificate rather than define their own KPIs. Sustainability-linked loans and bonds have shrunk from their peak and several borrowers have dropped the format at refinancing (see B03, C02), which drags SLDs with them. Accounting has become clearer for lenders, through the 2024 IFRS 9 amendments, but not for derivatives. The EU’s new clearing-threshold regime counts only uncleared positions and keeps the hedging exemption.
Open debates.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Rates, FX and sustainability-linked derivatives: check your understanding
Test the mechanics of swaps and XVA, the design and valuation of sustainability-linked derivatives, pre-hedging, cross-currency swaps and the capital of a corporate derivatives book.
Q1. A five-year swap has an annuity of 4.65 and a notional of EUR 200m. What is its DV01?
Answer: B. DV01 = N x A x 0.0001 = 200m x 4.65 x 0.0001 = EUR 93,000.
Q2. Why is a corporate swap usually uncollateralised?
Answer: B. NFC- counterparties are exempt from clearing and margin requirements; most treasurers do not want the liquidity drain of collateral calls.
Q3. Which component of the spread over mid-market is the sales desk’s profit?
Answer: C. CVA goes to the XVA desk to reserve and hedge credit risk, FVA to Treasury for funding; only the margin is profit.
Q4. Why does the CVA of an at-the-money IRS come from a hump-shaped exposure?
Answer: B. Diffusion increases with the square root of time while the remaining annuity shrinks; the product peaks around one third of the life.
Q5. In the ISDA SLD Clause Library, what is the default consequence of a failure to pay a sustainability-linked payment?
Answer: C. The library protects the hedge: non-payment of the sustainability-linked payment is not an event of default.
Q6. What distinguishes a Category 1 SLD in ISDA’s 2021 regulatory analysis?
Answer: A. Category 1 SLDs embed KPI terms in an existing derivative and are likely to keep their regulatory treatment; Category 2 arrangements are separate KPI agreements.
Q7. On the Borealis swap, why is the KPI step 0.5 bp per KPI rather than the RCF’s 1 bp?
Answer: B. A 3 bp maximum would take 60% of a 5 bp margin; the step is sized against the desk’s economics and the client’s hedge accounting.
Q8. Why is the Borealis SLD a Level 3 instrument for Meridian?
Answer: B. The worst-case KPI leg is 23.7% of the day-one sales credit; no market prices the client’s KPI outcomes.
Q9. A pre-hedge at 2.51% is terminated when the seven-year swap rate is 2.80%. Who pays whom?
Answer: B. The issuer paid fixed at 2.51% and rates rose; the swap has positive value to the issuer, which compensates its higher coupon.
Q10. What does a pre-hedge not protect against?
Answer: C. The pre-hedge covers the swap rate component; a widening of the new-issue spread is borne fully by the issuer.
Q11. Why does a cross-currency swap consume much more capital than an IRS of the same notional?
Answer: B. The FX add-on alone is 4% of the notional, against 0.5% times supervisory duration for interest rates; the exposure grows to maturity.
Q12. What is the effect of Article 382(4) CRR on the Borealis package?
Answer: B. Without the exemption, BA-CVA would add EUR 24.33m of RWA and RAROC would fall from 7.13% to 2.23%.
Q13. Where does a sustainability-linked swap appear in Meridian’s Green Asset Ratio?
Answer: C. Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/73 removed derivatives from the denominator of financial undertakings’ KPIs; they were never in the numerator.
Q14. A treasurer proposes to describe the pre-hedge of a green bond as a ‘green swap’. Best answer?
Answer: C. No standard labels derivatives green; counting the hedge would double count the same euros.
Q15. Pricing the expected KPI discount into the initial fixed rate means that…
Answer: A. The expected cost is spread into the rate (0.83 bp in the case); the incentive becomes a self-funded bet and must be disclosed.
A BBB+ utility asks for a seven-year payer swap on EUR 250m. The curve is flat at 3.00% (annual compounding). The XVA desk quotes a CVA of EUR 260,000 and an FVA of EUR 70,000; sales wants a margin of 4 bp. Compute the annuity, DV01, the running spreads, the client rate and the day-one sales credit.
Solution. . = EUR 1,557.6m. DV01 = EUR 1,557.6m x 0.0001 = EUR 155,757. CVA running = 260,000 / 1,557.6m = 1.67 bp; FVA running = 70,000 / 1,557.6m = 0.45 bp. Total spread 1.67 + 0.45 + 4.00 = 6.12 bp; client rate 3.0612%. Sales credit = 4 bp x EUR 1,557.6m = EUR 623,000. Reading: the margin is two thirds of the spread; on a longer swap the same running margin produces a larger day-one profit because the annuity is larger.
A company enters a three-year swap on EUR 150m with two KPIs, adjusted by 1 bp per KPI (maximum 2 bp), each adjustment applying to the next annual payment at = 1, 2 and 3. It meets 2, then 0, then 1 SPTs. Discount rate 3%. Compute the company’s present value saving and the bank’s present value, (a) when the bank keeps premiums, (b) when premiums go to a charity.
Solution. One basis point is EUR 15,000 a year. Adjustments : -2, +2 and 0 bp, so the company saves EUR 30,000, pays EUR 30,000 more, then nothing: zero undiscounted, and a present value of = EUR 848. (a) The bank’s flows mirror the company’s: present value EUR -848. (b) The bank pays only discounts, : EUR 30,000, 0 and 15,000, present value = EUR 42,853; the charity receives EUR 0, 30,000 and 15,000. The client’s incentive is identical in both designs; the bank’s economics are not.
Meridian sells an unmargined ten-year IRS on EUR 100m to a BBB corporate (PD 0.20%, F-IRB LGD 40%, M 2.5 years, risk weight 39.02%) with a sales margin of 6 bp a year. Cost-income 60%, tax 25%, capital 13% of RWA, CVA exemption applies. Compute EAD, RWA, capital and RAROC.
Solution. Supervisory duration . Add-on = 0.5% x EUR 100m x 7.869 = EUR 3.935m. EAD = 1.4 x 3.935 = EUR 5.509m. RWA = 39.02% x 5.509 = EUR 2.149m; capital EUR 279,400. Revenues EUR 60,000; costs EUR 36,000; expected loss 0.20% x 40% x 5.509m = EUR 4,407. Pre-tax EUR 19,593; after tax EUR 14,695. RAROC = 14,695 / 279,400 = 5.26%. Reading: even a healthy margin on a long-dated uncollateralised swap leaves the trade below the hurdle; collateral or a shorter tenor would change the result more than the margin.
1. Walk me through how you price a swap for a corporate client. I start from mid-market: the par swap rate from the €STR-discounted, EURIBOR-projected curve for the requested dates. I then add the XVA desk’s charges for the incremental exposure in the client’s netting set: CVA from the expected exposure profile and the client’s credit spread, FVA from Meridian’s funding spread, and sometimes a capital charge. Sales adds the margin. I would quote the all-in rate and be able to decompose it in basis points and in euros, because the MiFID cost disclosure requires it.
2. What is a sustainability-linked derivative and why are they rare? It is an ordinary swap, CCS or FX forward whose rate or a separate payment moves with the client’s performance against sustainability targets, documented with the ISDA clause library. They are rare because the margin on a corporate derivative is a few basis points, so even a small KPI step takes a large share of it, and because the KPIs usually duplicate those of the client’s loan. They also complicate the client’s hedge accounting and the bank’s valuation.
3. A client wants the same KPIs in its swap as in its RCF. How do you respond? I would welcome the consistency but show the arithmetic: the RCF’s 1 bp per KPI is 4% of the loan margin, the same step on a swap would be 60% of ours. I would propose a smaller step, perhaps with premiums paid to a charity, cross-reference the RCF certificate to keep costs down, and make sure the hedge rationale stands on its own. I would also tell the client that the swap does not raise the ambition of its targets and that we will not count it as a separate sustainable transaction.
4. Why is CVA larger than the expected loss in the credit application? CVA uses market-implied default probabilities derived from credit spreads, which include a risk premium and liquidity component, while expected loss uses the real-world PD of the internal rating. For a BBB client the implied intensity can be several times the rated PD. The difference is not profit: it is the price of hedging or warehousing the credit risk at market levels.
5. Explain a pre-hedge and its limits. A pre-hedge is a forward-starting payer swap that the issuer enters weeks before a planned bond and terminates on pricing day. If rates rise, the termination gain offsets the higher coupon; if they fall, the loss offsets the lower coupon, so the issuer locks the swap-rate level of the hedge date. It does not cover the credit spread, it needs a highly probable forecast issue for hedge accounting, and it requires an information barrier because the rates desk knows of the issue.
6. Why does a cross-currency swap consume so much more capital than an interest-rate swap? The notionals are re-exchanged at maturity at the original rate, so the full currency move on the principal is at risk. SA-CCR captures it with a 4% FX supervisory factor on the notional, plus interest-rate add-ons for both legs. In the case the CCS’s EAD is more than twice that of an IRS on twice the notional, and it more than doubles if the euro falls by 10%.
7. How do you value the KPI component of an SLD, and what are the consequences? I estimate the probability of meeting each SPT from the client’s trajectory and plans, compute expected flows and discount them. Since that probability is unobservable and the leg can be significant relative to day-one profit, the trade is Level 3: part of the day-one profit is deferred, a valuation reserve is held, and the assumption is reviewed each year after the certificate. I would also check that the leg is never left at zero simply because it is small.
8. What does the EU CVA exemption mean for a corporate derivatives business? Article 382(4) CRR exempts trades with non-financial counterparties from CVA risk capital, a feature of the EU rules that the Basel standard does not have. In the case it avoids about EUR 24m of RWA, more than twice the counterparty credit RWA, and keeps the package’s RAROC above 7% instead of about 2%. The economic CVA is still charged and reserved; supervisors monitor the exempted exposures through reporting.
Standards and industry documentation
Regulation and supervisory documents
Accounting
Market and academic reading