Where it sits. At Meridian Bank, sustainability reporting is a team inside Group Finance, reporting to the Head of Financial Reporting and, through the Chief Financial Officer, to the Audit Committee. That location is not an accident. Since the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), the sustainability statement is a section of the management report, published together with the financial statements, approved by the board and covered by an assurance opinion from the statutory auditor. It is treated like accounts, not like a brochure. The Group Sustainability Office, attached to the Chief Executive’s office, owns the strategy, the net-zero targets and the public commitments; Finance owns the numbers. The Pillar 3 ESG tables, a prudential disclosure under the Capital Requirements Regulation (CRR), are produced by the Regulatory Reporting team, also in Finance, which already publishes the capital, leverage and liquidity disclosures. The two teams share one data platform and one set of controls, because a supervisor and an investor will compare the two documents line by line.
Clients. The team has no external clients and earns no revenue. Its “clients” are the readers of its output: investors and rating agencies (equity and credit), ESG rating providers, the European Central Bank as supervisor, the statutory auditor, the board, and the bank’s own business lines, which quote the figures in pitches and in green bond reports. Its product is credibility. A bank that has to restate a published ratio, or that receives a qualified assurance opinion, pays in reputation and, since the supervisor started using penalty payments on climate matters (see A02), possibly in cash.
How it “earns money”: orders of magnitude. The function is a cost centre. For a bank of Meridian’s size (total assets EUR 310bn), a realistic annual budget for the full sustainability reporting chain, including staff, data vendors, IT and the assurance fee, is in the low tens of millions of euros; section 6 builds Meridian’s figure from its components. The value is indirect: access to investors who screen on disclosure quality, eligibility for green funding (C15), a lower risk of supervisory findings, and data that the risk and pricing functions reuse (E01, E03, E07).
The team. Meridian’s sustainability reporting team has about twenty people. A head of sustainability reporting, a former auditor, signs off the statement. A CSRD lead runs the double materiality assessment and drafts the narrative sections with the Group Sustainability Office. A Taxonomy and GAR lead owns the calculation of the Green Asset Ratio and its templates. Data analysts run the extraction from the loan systems and the counterparty KPIs from the data vendor. A controls manager maintains the risk and control matrix and the evidence files for the auditor. Next door, three people of Regulatory Reporting produce the Pillar 3 ESG tables; the ESG data office (part of the Chief Data Officer’s organisation) owns the golden sources of counterparty data; Credit Risk owns the financed-emissions model shared with E07; Investor Relations owns the investor presentation that quotes the numbers.
A realistic week in late November 2026.
WHO DOES WHAT — The reporting team is judged on three things nobody outside sees: the reporting calendar is met, no figure is restated, and the auditor finds no material weakness. A good day is a boring day.
Before the green layer, the team’s product is simply regulated financial disclosure. A bank publishes three families of documents, each with its own law, owner, frequency and assurance level.
| Document | Legal basis | Owner | Frequency | Assurance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financial statements | IFRS, Accounting Directive | Financial reporting | Annual, half-year | Audit (reasonable) |
| Management report | Accounting Directive | Finance, Secretary | Annual | Consistency check |
| Pillar 3 report | CRR Part Eight | Regulatory reporting | Quarterly to annual | Internal, board-approved |
| Supervisory reporting (COREP, FINREP) | CRR, EBA ITS | Regulatory reporting | Quarterly | Internal, supervisor |
Financial statements are the anchor. Under IFRS, a loan is measured at amortised cost, its gross carrying amount is the figure before the expected credit loss allowance, and it is classified in stage 1, 2 or 3 (E01). Almost every sustainability indicator of a bank is built on that same gross carrying amount, which is why sustainability reporting sits in Finance: the denominator of every ratio must reconcile to the balance sheet.
The management report comments on the year: business, risks, outlook. Since the CSRD it contains the sustainability statement, a clearly identified section prepared under the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS). The Taxonomy disclosure (Article 8 of the Taxonomy Regulation) is part of that statement.
Pillar 3 is the market-discipline leg of the Basel framework. Large listed banks publish standardised tables on capital, risk-weighted assets, credit risk, liquidity, leverage and, since 2022, ESG risks, under Article 449a CRR. The format is fixed by an EBA implementing technical standard (ITS) adopted by the Commission as an implementing regulation; the current base text is Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/3172. Pillar 3 must be consistent with the supervisory reports (COREP for capital, FINREP for financial data) that the bank sends to its supervisor, which is why the EBA keeps a mapping tool between the two.
Every published number goes through the same chain, whether it is a CET1 ratio or a Green Asset Ratio.
IN ONE SENTENCE — A bank’s sustainability ratio is a financial reporting product: an aggregation of gross carrying amounts, filtered and weighted by rules, that must reconcile to the balance sheet.
INTUITION — Think of a restaurant’s allergen menu. The kitchen already knows every dish (the accounts). The allergen menu adds one attribute per ingredient, and the risk is not the arithmetic but a missing or wrong label on one ingredient that contaminates many dishes. In a bank, the “ingredient” is the counterparty record, and one wrong flag propagates into hundreds of loans.
Financial reporting runs on materiality: information is material if omitting or misstating it could reasonably influence the decisions of users. Sustainability reporting under the CSRD adds a second perspective, which gives double materiality:
A matter is reported if it is material from either perspective. The assessment is done on impacts, risks and opportunities (IROs). Impacts are scored on severity (scale, scope, irremediable character) and likelihood; risks and opportunities on the magnitude of financial effect and likelihood. The thresholds are set by the bank and documented.
FORMULA
is the severity of an impact, the average of its scale, scope and irremediability scores (each from 1 to 5); the likelihood of the impact (from 0 to 1, equal to 1 for an actual impact); the impact materiality score; the magnitude of the financial effect (1 to 5); its likelihood; the financial materiality score. A matter is material if or exceeds the threshold the bank has set.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Scoring one sustainability matter in the double materiality assessment
See how the severity and likelihood scores of an impact, and the magnitude and likelihood of a financial effect, decide whether a topic enters the bank’s sustainability statement.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Scale of the impact | 1 to 5 1-5 | 4 1-5 |
| Scope of the impact | 1 to 5 1-5 | 4 1-5 |
| Irremediable character | 1 to 5 1-5 | 3 1-5 |
| Likelihood of the impact | 0 to 1 0-1 | 1 0-1 |
| Magnitude of the financial effect | 1 to 5 1-5 | 3 1-5 |
| Likelihood of the financial effect | 0 to 1 0-1 | 0.6 0-1 |
| Materiality threshold | 1 to 5 score | 2.5 score |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Severity | 3.67 score |
| Impact materiality score | 3.67 score |
| Financial materiality score | 1.80 score |
| Material (1 = yes, 0 = no) | 1 |
Try it. The defaults describe financed greenhouse gas emissions: an actual impact, so the likelihood is 1, and material on impact alone. Lower the likelihood to 0.5 to see how a potential impact can fall below the threshold.
The defaults describe “climate change mitigation: emissions of financed activities”, which almost every European bank finds material on the impact side. Its financial effect (transition risk on the book) scores 1.8, below Meridian’s threshold of 2.5 on its own, but the topic is material anyway because one perspective is enough. The pitfall is to treat these scores as measurements: they are documented judgements, and the auditor tests the process (who scored, on what evidence, how thresholds were set), not the decimals.
The statutory auditor (or, where a member state allows it, an independent assurance services provider) gives a limited assurance opinion on the sustainability statement: a negative-form conclusion (“nothing has come to our attention that causes us to believe…”), based on inquiries, analytical procedures and a sample of tests. It is less than the reasonable assurance of a financial audit. The Omnibus directive abandoned the earlier plan to move to reasonable assurance later. Inside the bank, the first line (the business and operations that enter the data) owns data quality, the second line (Risk, Compliance and an internal control over sustainability reporting function modelled on financial reporting controls) sets and tests the controls, and Internal Audit gives the third-line view.
PITFALL — “Limited assurance” does not mean “unaudited”. The auditor samples loans, checks that the counterparty KPI used matches the counterparty’s own published report, re-performs the calculation and reviews the controls. A GAR that cannot be traced from the published percentage down to individual contracts will fail.
WHY IT MATTERS ON THE DESK — On a reporting desk the question is never “is the ratio high?” but “can I prove every euro in it?”. That shapes everything: the choice to exclude an exposure for lack of evidence, the refusal of estimates in regulated ratios, the documentation of every judgement.
The CSRD (Directive (EU) 2022/2464) replaced the Non-Financial Reporting Directive. The Omnibus I directive, Directive (EU) 2026/470, published in the Official Journal on 26 February 2026 and in force since 18 March 2026, narrowed it considerably. An EU undertaking is now in scope only if it exceeds, at individual or group level, both 1,000 employees on average and EUR 450m of net turnover. Member states must transpose most provisions by 19 March 2027. Undertakings with up to 1,000 employees in a reporter’s value chain may refuse requests for information beyond the voluntary standard, which caps what a bank can ask of its smaller clients for its own reporting.
For Meridian the scope question is simple: a large listed bank, it has published a CSRD statement since financial year 2024 and remains in scope. The scope change matters on the other side of the balance sheet: many of Meridian’s corporate clients left the CSRD perimeter, and that directly reshapes the GAR (section 3.3).
The standards. The first set of ESRS (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2023/2772) had two cross-cutting standards (ESRS 1 general requirements, ESRS 2 general disclosures) and ten topical standards (five environmental, four social, one governance). On 3 July 2026 the Commission adopted a revised set of ESRS that cuts mandatory datapoints by more than 60% and total datapoints by more than 70%. The revised standards apply to financial years beginning on or after 1 January 2027, subject to the two-month (extendable) scrutiny by Parliament and Council; for FY2026, companies already reporting may keep the existing ESRS, apply the revised ones in full, or use certain reliefs. The revised approach to materiality is top-down, starting from the business model, and the assessment of fair presentation applies to the statement as a whole. Reliefs allow anticipated financial effects to be omitted for early years. No sector-specific standard for banks will be adopted.
What a bank’s statement contains. In practice: ESRS 2 (governance, strategy, the double materiality process and its result); ESRS E1 climate (transition plan, targets, energy, own scope 1 and 2 emissions, and scope 3 category 15, which for a bank means financed emissions, see A03 and E07); social standards on own workforce and on consumers (financial inclusion, responsible lending, mis-selling); governance (business conduct, anti-corruption); and the Taxonomy disclosure with the GAR.
Article 8 of the Taxonomy Regulation (EU) 2020/852 requires undertakings subject to the CSRD to disclose how far their activities are associated with Taxonomy-aligned activities. For a credit institution, the Disclosures Delegated Act, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2021/2178, sets the key performance indicator: the Green Asset Ratio (GAR), the share of the bank’s covered assets financing Taxonomy-aligned activities. Annex V defines the calculation and Annex VI the templates.
IN ONE SENTENCE — The GAR is the proportion of a bank’s eligible on-balance-sheet exposures that finance activities meeting the Taxonomy’s technical screening criteria, do-no-significant-harm tests and minimum safeguards.
How an exposure enters the numerator depends on what the bank knows about the use of the money:
The act. Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/73, adopted on 4 July 2025 and published in the Official Journal on 8 January 2026, amends the Disclosures Delegated Act (and the Climate and Environmental Delegated Acts). It applies from 1 January 2026, so to FY2026 reports published in 2027; for financial years starting in 2025, undertakings could still apply the old rules. The Commission’s estimate is a cut of 64% in data points for non-financial undertakings and 89% for financial undertakings.
The denominator rule. The amended Article 7(3) and Annex V section 1.1.2 now exclude from both the numerator and the denominator of the GAR:
Under the original 2021 text, items 2 to 6 were excluded from the numerator only: they sat in the denominator and dragged the ratio down although they could never be green. The recitals give the reason: numerator and denominator should cover the same population, so that the ratio measures the alignment of what can be assessed. Sovereign, central bank and supranational exposures remain outside the covered assets, as before (the template still shows them as “not covered”).
The transitional opt-out. A new Article 7(9) provides that, until 31 December 2027, the detailed provisions of the act (Articles 2 to 8, except Article 8(2)) do not apply to financial undertakings that do not claim any Taxonomy alignment, provided they disclose the information required by Article 8(1) of the Taxonomy Regulation and include in their management report a prescribed statement that no activities are claimed as associated with environmentally sustainable activities. In plain words: a bank may skip the GAR and its templates for its reports until the end of 2027, but only if it stays silent on alignment.
Materiality. A financial undertaking may treat activities as non-material where they represent less than 10% of loans and investments financing activities with a known use of proceeds; this does not cover exposures with unknown use of proceeds. A separate derogation lets a credit institution omit the Annex V KPIs where its credit institution activity generates less than 10% of the group’s net turnover (relevant for conglomerates, not for Meridian).
The trading book and fees. The trading book KPI and the fees and commissions KPI apply only from 1 January 2028. On 29 October 2026 the EBA advised the Commission to remove both altogether and to simplify the GAR templates, as input to a review of the Disclosures Delegated Act; at the time of writing the Commission has not acted on that advice.
PITFALL — “The GAR was simplified” is often read as “the GAR was abolished for 2026-2027”. It was not: the opt-out is conditional on claiming no alignment. A bank that issues green bonds under the European Green Bond Standard, markets “Taxonomy-aligned” mortgages or quotes an alignment figure in its investor presentation cannot honestly use it.
The first generation. The EBA’s ITS of January 2022, now incorporated in Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/3172, gave large listed institutions ten quantitative ESG templates: transition risk by sector with financed emissions (template 1), energy efficiency of real-estate collateral (2), alignment metrics against a scenario (3), exposures to the top 20 carbon-intensive firms (4), physical risk (5), GAR summary, assets and percentages (6 to 8), the BTAR (9) and other climate change mitigating actions (10), plus qualitative tables on environmental, social and governance risk. The GAR was first disclosed at the 31 December 2023 reference date and the BTAR from 30 June 2024.
The pause. On 6 August 2025 the EBA issued a no-action letter asking supervisors not to prioritise enforcement of the Taxonomy-related templates while the Taxonomy rules were being changed.
The final draft of 22 June 2026. CRR3 extended ESG disclosure to all institutions, proportionately. The EBA’s final draft ITS (EBA/ITS/2026/02), published on 22 June 2026, amend Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/3172 with a “core plus supplement” design:
NOTE — We verified the Pillar 3 points against the EBA press release of 22 June 2026 and its ITS page, and the template-level detail against public summaries; the full final report could not be opened from our environment. Template numbering in the amended ITS may change at adoption. In this module we refer to templates by content, not by number.
Outside the EU, banks report under IFRS S1 (general requirements) and IFRS S2 (climate), issued by the ISSB in June 2023 and effective for periods from 1 January 2024 where jurisdictions adopt them. In December 2025 the ISSB amended IFRS S2 to ease bank reporting: an entity may limit scope 3 category 15 measurement to financed emissions (leaving out facilitated and insurance-associated emissions and derivatives), may use an industry classification other than GICS for the breakdown of financed emissions, and benefits from clarified jurisdictional reliefs; the amendments apply from 1 January 2027 with early application permitted. IFRS S2 is a financial-materiality standard: it has no equivalent of impact materiality or of the GAR.
For Meridian, which has a New York broker-dealer and a London branch, the practical question is interoperability: EFRAG and the IFRS Foundation published joint guidance in May 2024 showing that an ESRS climate report contains almost everything IFRS S2 requires, with a few additions (for example, industry-based metrics and some financed-emissions breakdowns). The team keeps a mapping table so that one data set feeds both.
| Text | Status, November 2026 | What it changes for Meridian |
|---|---|---|
| CSRD as amended by Directive 2026/470 | In force; transposition by March 2027 | Fewer clients in scope |
| Revised ESRS (adopted 3 July 2026) | Scrutiny; applies FY2027 | Fewer datapoints, options for FY2026 |
| Delegated Regulation 2026/73 | Applies from FY2026 | New GAR denominator; opt-out to end-2027 |
| Pillar 3 ESG final draft ITS | Awaiting Commission adoption | No GAR or BTAR in Pillar 3 |
| IFRS S2 amendments (Dec 2025) | Effective 2027 | Lighter scope 3 for non-EU entities |
WHY IT MATTERS ON THE DESK — The reporting team works with rules that changed three times in eighteen months. The habit that saves it is to separate the data (one golden set of exposures and attributes) from the rules (a calculation layer that can be re-parameterised). Section 5 shows that the same balance sheet gives a GAR of 4.6% or 6.7% depending on the rule applied.
For a reporting function the “deal” is the annual reporting cycle. Meridian’s FY2026 cycle runs from September 2026 to the publication of the annual report in March 2027 and of the year-end Pillar 3 report shortly after.
INTERACTIVE LAB — The FY2026 sustainability reporting cycle at Meridian Bank
Follow the year-end production of the CSRD statement, the GAR and the Pillar 3 ESG tables through the people and documents involved.
| # | Who | Does what | Deliverable |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Head of sustainability reporting with the CSRD lead | Refresh the double materiality assessment with the Group Sustainability Office, Risk and business lines (September) | Updated list of material impacts, risks and opportunities, approved by the Audit Committee |
| 2 | Taxonomy and GAR lead, Regulatory Reporting | Translate new texts into calculation rules: Delegated Regulation 2026/73, Pillar 3 final draft ITS; decide on the opt-out (October) | Methodology note and decision paper to the CFO |
| 3 | ESG data office | Refresh counterparty reference data: CSRD scope flag, published Taxonomy KPIs, emissions, NACE codes, EPC labels (October to January) | Golden source with data-quality indicators |
| 4 | Statutory auditor | Planning and interim visit: risk assessment, walk-through of controls, early sample tests on the GAR and financed emissions (November to December) | Audit plan, interim findings letter |
| 5 | Finance data warehouse team | Year-end close: extract exposures at gross carrying amount, reconcile to the general ledger and to FINREP (January) | Reconciled exposure file at 31 December 2026 |
| 6 | Data analysts, sustainability reporting | Run the calculation engine: exclusions, counterparty weighting, asset tests, template mapping (January) | Draft GAR templates, BTAR (voluntary), Pillar 3 ESG tables |
| 7 | Controls manager and second line | Analytical review, reconciliations, manual adjustment log, four-eyes checks (late January) | Control evidence pack |
| 8 | CSRD lead and Group Sustainability Office | Draft narrative sections: strategy, transition plan, targets, metrics (February) | Draft sustainability statement |
| 9 | Investor Relations, Legal and Compliance | Check consistency of all public green figures and wording with the statement (February) | Reconciliation table of public figures |
| 10 | Statutory auditor | Final procedures and limited assurance conclusion (late February) | Assurance report on the sustainability statement |
| 11 | Audit Committee and board | Review and approve the management report including the sustainability statement (early March) | Approved annual report |
| 12 | Regulatory Reporting | Publish the Pillar 3 report including ESG tables, under the ITS in force at that date; submit data to the EBA Pillar 3 data hub (spring) | Pillar 3 report |
Step 1: the double materiality refresh. The assessment is not redone from scratch each year; it is updated for changes in the business and in the evidence. The output is a short list of material topics with the reasoning, which determines which ESRS disclosures the bank makes. The Audit Committee approves it because it defines the scope of what the auditor will test.
Step 2: rules before data. The Taxonomy and GAR lead writes a methodology note for each change of law: which exposures are excluded, which counterparty KPI is used and how, what happens when a client’s report is late. For FY2026 the note has to deal with two moving texts: Delegated Regulation 2026/73, which is law, and the Pillar 3 final draft, which is not yet law. The opt-out decision is formally a CFO decision, documented in a paper that weighs the cost of reporting against the bank’s claims elsewhere (green bonds, product marketing).
Step 3: reference data. This is where most of the work and most of the errors lie. The CSRD scope flag of each corporate client is the new critical attribute, because it now decides whether an exposure is in the GAR denominator at all. The data office uses a combination of public registers, data vendors and the relationship managers’ knowledge of the client’s size; a client whose scope status is unknown is a decision point (section 7).
Step 4: the auditor’s interim visit. The auditor walks through the process end to end, tests controls, and picks samples early so that issues are fixed before year-end.
Steps 5 to 7: close, calculate, control. The exposure file at 31 December is reconciled to the balance sheet before any sustainability attribute is used. The calculation engine produces all templates from one file, so that the GAR, the Pillar 3 tables and the financed emissions are computed on the same population. Every manual adjustment is logged with its author, reason and approver.
Steps 8 and 9: narrative and consistency. The statement is drafted around the numbers, not the other way round. Investor Relations, Legal and Compliance compare every green figure that the bank publishes anywhere (investor presentation, green bond report, website) with the statement, a step introduced at Meridian after an ESG rating agency spotted two different figures for the same metric.
Steps 10 to 12: assurance, approval, Pillar 3. The auditor’s conclusion is attached to the statement. Pillar 3 is approved under the bank’s formal disclosure policy and published shortly after the annual report.
Question. At the January 2027 close, the sustainability reporting team must produce Meridian’s FY2026 Taxonomy KPIs under the rules of Delegated Regulation 2026/73, a voluntary BTAR, and the Pillar 3 ESG tables at the 31 December 2026 reference date. The Chief Financial Officer wants to understand, before the numbers go to the Audit Committee, why the GAR moves, what the business contributed, and how each green figure the bank publishes reconciles with the others.
Data (case assumptions, consistent with A02 and C15). Meridian’s consolidated balance sheet is EUR 310bn. Its asset side, as seen by the GAR, is:
| Asset category | EUR bn | Treatment under 2026/73 |
|---|---|---|
| Sovereigns, central banks, supranationals | 62 | Not covered (unchanged) |
| Trading book | 28 | Not covered (unchanged) |
| Residential mortgages | 70 | Covered, building test |
| Corporates in CSRD scope, general purpose | 48 | Covered, counterparty KPI |
| Specialised and use-of-proceeds lending | 12 | Covered, asset test |
| Local authorities, housing | 3 | Covered, asset test |
| Corporates and SMEs outside CSRD scope | 52 | Now excluded |
| Banking-book derivatives | 4 | Now excluded |
| On-demand interbank loans | 6 | Now excluded |
| Cash and cash-related assets | 2 | Now excluded |
| Goodwill and other excluded assets | 5 | Now excluded |
| Financial corporations in CSRD scope | 18 | Covered, counterparty KPI |
| Total | 310 |
The last six lines together are the EUR 87bn that A02 split into “outside CSRD scope” (52) and “other” (35); here the “other” line is broken down because the 2026 rules treat its parts differently. Meridian’s financial counterparties (banks, insurers, funds) in CSRD scope account for EUR 18bn; for FY2026 their published KPIs give no aligned amount, because several of them used the opt-out and the others published after Meridian’s cut-off (a realistic and conservative choice that the methodology note documents).
First decision: report or opt out? Before any calculation, the CFO has to decide whether Meridian uses the Article 7(9) opt-out for FY2026. The methodology note lists the bank’s existing claims. Meridian has EUR 3.5bn of green bonds outstanding under a framework that refers to the Taxonomy for its eligibility criteria; the retail bank sells a “green mortgage” whose marketing mentions energy class A; the investor presentation quotes an aligned share; and the bank is considering a first issue under the European Green Bond Standard in 2027, which requires Taxonomy alignment of the proceeds. Any one of these is an alignment claim in the ordinary meaning of the words. Opting out would require withdrawing them, or publishing a statement that no activity is claimed as aligned while the rest of the bank says the opposite, a textbook inconsistency that the auditor, the supervisor and ESG analysts would spot. The cost saving would be modest, because most of the data must be collected anyway for Pillar 3, financed emissions and the green bond pool. Decision: Meridian reports full KPIs. A small regional bank without green issuance and with a mortgage book lacking certificates could rationally decide the other way; the opt-out was designed for it.
Second decision: cut-off and data vintage. Counterparty KPIs are those published in clients’ FY2025 statements, available by the end of the first half of 2026; a client that publishes after 31 October 2026 is not used. Exposures are taken at 31 December 2026. The mismatch (2026 exposures, 2025 client KPIs) is disclosed, as every bank faces it.
Method. Six stages: the denominator under the old and the new rules (5.2), the numerator line by line (5.3), stock and flow (5.4), the BTAR (5.5), two Pillar 3 templates (5.6 and 5.7), and the reconciliation of public figures (5.8).
Question. What are Meridian’s covered assets under the original Disclosures Delegated Act, under the partial reading used in A02 (only non-CSRD counterparties removed), and under the full 2026/73 rule? What does each give for the GAR, holding the aligned amount at the EUR 10.1bn established in A02?
Calculation.
FORMULA
is total assets; sovereign, central bank and supranational exposures; the trading book; the covered assets of the original rule; exposures to undertakings outside the CSRD scope; the other assets now excluded from the denominator (banking-book derivatives, on-demand interbank loans, cash, goodwill and similar); the covered assets of the 2026 rule; the Taxonomy-aligned exposures.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Meridian’s GAR denominator under the original and the 2026 rules
Rebuild the covered assets from the balance sheet and see how much of the change in the GAR comes from each category removed by Delegated Regulation 2026/73.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Total assets | 100 to 600 EUR bn | 310 EUR bn |
| Sovereigns, central banks, supranationals | 0 to 150 EUR bn | 62 EUR bn |
| Trading book | 0 to 150 EUR bn | 28 EUR bn |
| Exposures to undertakings outside CSRD scope | 0 to 150 EUR bn | 52 EUR bn |
| Banking-book derivatives | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 4 EUR bn |
| On-demand interbank loans | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 6 EUR bn |
| Cash and cash-related assets | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 2 EUR bn |
| Goodwill and other excluded assets | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 5 EUR bn |
| Taxonomy-aligned exposures | 0 to 60 EUR bn | 10.1 EUR bn |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Covered assets, original rule | 220.0 EUR bn |
| Covered assets, non-CSRD removed only | 168.0 EUR bn |
| Covered assets, 2026/73 rule | 151.0 EUR bn |
| GAR, original rule | 4.59 % |
| GAR, non-CSRD removed only | 6.01 % |
| GAR, 2026/73 rule | 6.69 % |
| Change due to definition alone | 2.10 points |
| Part of the change due to non-CSRD exclusion | 67.7 % |
| Covered assets (2026 rule) as share of total assets | 48.7 % |
Try it. Raise the exposures outside CSRD scope from 52 to 71, as if more mid-caps had fallen below the Omnibus thresholds: the GAR reaches 7.65% with an unchanged balance sheet.
Result. Covered assets fall from EUR 220bn under the original rule to EUR 168bn when only non-CSRD counterparties are removed, and to EUR 151bn under the full 2026/73 rule. The GAR moves from 4.59% to 6.01% and then to 6.69%: a rise of 2.10 points without a single new loan. About two-thirds of the rise (67.7%) comes from the removal of non-CSRD counterparties, the rest from derivatives, on-demand interbank loans, cash and goodwill. Covered assets are now only 48.7% of the balance sheet.
Reading. Three remarks. First, the intermediate 6.01% (the CSRD-scope rule applied alone) is a step of the reasoning, not a figure any bank publishes: the FY2026 GAR, the one A02 also reports, is 6.69%, and the reporting team must apply the full rule. Second, the new GAR is a ratio on less than half of the bank: it answers “how aligned is what can be assessed?”, not “how green is the bank?”. Third, the ratio is now sensitive to the CSRD scope of clients, which is decided by member-state transposition and by clients’ size: if more clients fall out of scope, the GAR rises mechanically. That is why Meridian’s methodology note fixes the scope flag on the client’s legal obligation at the reporting date, not on whether the client chose to publish.
PITFALL — Comparing Meridian’s FY2026 GAR of 6.69% with its FY2025 GAR of 4.59% and reporting “+2.1 points of green progress” would be misleading. The statement must present the comparative restated on the new basis, or explain the break in series. The auditor will look for exactly this.
Question. Where do the EUR 10.1bn of aligned exposures come from, and what is the CapEx-based GAR?
Data (case assumptions).
FORMULA
is the gross carrying amount of portfolio ; its aligned share; the general-purpose corporate exposures in scope; and the exposure-weighted average of the counterparties’ turnover-aligned and CapEx-aligned shares; the aligned amount of the other portfolios; and the aligned totals on a turnover and on a CapEx basis.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Building Meridian’s aligned exposures and the two GARs
Compute the aligned amount by portfolio, the turnover-based and CapEx-based GAR, and see which portfolios drive the ratio.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Residential mortgages | 0 to 150 EUR bn | 70 EUR bn |
| Aligned share of mortgages | 0 to 40 % | 8 % |
| Corporates in CSRD scope, general purpose | 0 to 150 EUR bn | 48 EUR bn |
| Weighted counterparty turnover KPI | 0 to 30 % | 3.96 % |
| Weighted counterparty CapEx KPI | 0 to 30 % | 6.04 % |
| Specialised and use-of-proceeds lending | 0 to 50 EUR bn | 12 EUR bn |
| Aligned share of use-of-proceeds lending | 0 to 100 % | 20 % |
| Local authorities, housing | 0 to 20 EUR bn | 3 EUR bn |
| Aligned share of local authority lending | 0 to 50 % | 6.7 % |
| Covered assets (2026/73 rule) | 50 to 400 EUR bn | 151 EUR bn |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Aligned mortgages | 5.60 EUR bn |
| Aligned general-purpose corporate, turnover | 1.90 EUR bn |
| Aligned general-purpose corporate, CapEx | 2.90 EUR bn |
| Aligned use-of-proceeds | 2.40 EUR bn |
| Aligned local authority | 0.20 EUR bn |
| Total aligned, turnover basis | 10.10 EUR bn |
| Total aligned, CapEx basis | 11.10 EUR bn |
| GAR, turnover basis | 6.69 % |
| GAR, CapEx basis | 7.35 % |
| Mortgages in aligned total (turnover) | 55.4 % |
Try it. Raise the aligned share of mortgages from 8% to 10%, for example by collecting missing energy certificates: the GAR gains almost a point, more than doubling the corporate book’s turnover KPI would give.
Result. Aligned exposures are EUR 10.10bn on a turnover basis: EUR 5.60bn of mortgages, EUR 1.90bn of general-purpose corporate loans, EUR 2.40bn of use-of-proceeds lending and EUR 0.20bn of local authority housing. On a CapEx basis the corporate contribution is EUR 2.90bn and the total EUR 11.10bn. The two GARs are 6.69% (turnover) and 7.35% (CapEx). Mortgages make up 55.4% of the aligned total.
Reading. The ratio is driven by the mortgage book and by data collection, not by the corporate bank. If the retail network collected energy certificates on 2% more of the mortgage book, the GAR would rise from 6.69% to 7.62%, more than any plausible year of green corporate lending. The CapEx GAR is higher because companies in transition spend on aligned assets before they earn aligned revenue: for a lender financing transition it is the more informative of the two, which is why many banks comment on it first. Two practical points the analysts know well: the counterparty KPI is the one published in the client’s latest CSRD statement, so it lags by a year; and a client that did not publish on time contributes zero, not an estimate.
How the counterparty KPI is obtained. The data office takes each in-scope client’s turnover and CapEx KPIs from its published Taxonomy table, through a data vendor that extracts them, and checks a sample against the original reports. Three frequent problems: a client that reports at group level while Meridian lends to a subsidiary (the methodology note says to use the subsidiary’s KPI if it publishes one, otherwise the group’s); a client whose KPI includes activities that are only eligible, not aligned (only the aligned column is used); and a client whose report was published with a qualified assurance opinion (the KPI is used but flagged). For specialised lending the work is different: the sustainable finance desk prepares an alignment file for each asset at origination, with the technical screening evidence, the do-no-significant-harm checklist and the minimum safeguards review, and the reporting team only checks completeness. An incomplete file means zero, however green the asset looks.
CASE — For the corporate line, the engine multiplies each of about 1,400 exposures by its counterparty’s published KPI. A EUR 200m loan to a utility with 45% of aligned turnover contributes EUR 90m; the same loan to a chemicals company with 2% contributes EUR 4m; a use-of-proceeds loan for a wind farm to the chemicals company is tested on the asset instead and can contribute the full EUR 200m.
PITFALL — Double counting. A use-of-proceeds loan to a company that also publishes a KPI must not be counted twice: the methodology note gives priority to the asset test and excludes the exposure from the KPI weighting.
Question. The GAR is a stock ratio. How fast can new business move it, and what does one large aligned loan add?
Data (case assumptions). Under the flow template, Meridian reports the new covered exposures originated during 2026 and their aligned part: EUR 24bn of new in-scope lending, of which EUR 2.4bn aligned, a flow GAR of 10.0%. The covered book runs off at about 15% a year (amortisation, prepayment, maturity) and is replaced by new business, so the denominator is stable. The bank is also considering a EUR 500m loan to finance an offshore wind farm, fully aligned after the asset test.
FORMULA
is the stock GAR at the end of year ; the GAR today; the annual run-off rate of the covered book, replaced by the same amount of new business; the flow GAR of new business; a new fully aligned exposure; and the aligned and covered amounts today; the GAR after adding .
INTERACTIVE LAB — How fast new business moves Meridian’s stock GAR
Project the stock GAR when a stable book runs off and is replaced by new business with a given flow GAR, and measure the effect of one aligned deal.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Aligned exposures today | 0 to 60 EUR bn | 10.1 EUR bn |
| Covered assets today | 50 to 400 EUR bn | 151 EUR bn |
| New in-scope lending in the year | 1 to 80 EUR bn | 24 EUR bn |
| Of which aligned | 0 to 40 EUR bn | 2.4 EUR bn |
| Annual run-off of the covered book | 5 to 40 % | 15 % |
| One additional fully aligned loan | 0 to 3000 EUR m | 500 EUR m |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Stock GAR today | 6.69 % |
| Flow GAR of new business | 10.00 % |
| Stock GAR after five years | 8.53 % |
| Years to close half the gap to the flow GAR | 4.3 years |
| Stock GAR with the additional loan | 7.00 % |
| Effect of the additional loan | 30.8 bp |
Try it. Set the run-off to 25%, as for a bank with shorter loans: the stock GAR converges faster to the flow GAR. Then set the aligned new business to zero: the ratio decays towards zero at the same speed.
Result. Meridian’s stock GAR is 6.69% and its flow GAR 10.0%. If new business keeps that profile, the stock GAR reaches 8.53% after five years; half of the gap to the flow GAR is closed in 4.27 years. One EUR 500m fully aligned loan lifts the stock GAR to 7.00%, by 30.8 bp.
Reading. The flow GAR is the better management indicator: it shows today’s origination decisions, while the stock ratio carries the past for years. That is why Meridian’s internal dashboard tracks the flow GAR by business line monthly, with the stock GAR only at the half-year. A single large deal has a visible effect only because the new denominator is small; in the old denominator of EUR 220bn the same loan would have moved the ratio by roughly two-thirds as much. Note also the asymmetry: a loan to a non-CSRD mid-cap, however green, moves neither the numerator nor the denominator. The pitfall on the desk is to sell a loan internally as “GAR-accretive” when the client is out of scope.
Question. What would Meridian’s Banking Book Taxonomy Alignment Ratio be, and is it worth publishing?
Background. The BTAR was introduced by the 2022 Pillar 3 ITS to address the main weakness of the original GAR: exposures to companies outside the reporting perimeter (SMEs, non-EU companies) sat in the denominator but could never be in the numerator. The BTAR let banks bring them into the numerator on the basis of estimates or voluntary data. It was disclosed from mid-2024 on a best-effort basis, sat in Pillar 3, and was never part of the Taxonomy delegated act. The June 2026 final draft ITS stops Taxonomy-related Pillar 3 disclosures; once adopted, the BTAR will have no regulatory home and becomes voluntary.
Data (case assumptions). Meridian’s estimate, from energy certificates on commercial real estate collateral and a sample of SME renewable and building loans, is that EUR 1.3bn of the EUR 52bn non-CSRD book would pass the technical screening criteria.
FORMULA
is the aligned amount of the GAR; the estimated aligned exposures to undertakings outside the CSRD scope; the covered assets of the 2026 GAR; the exposures to undertakings outside the CSRD scope.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Meridian’s BTAR next to its GAR
Add estimated alignment of exposures outside the CSRD scope back into the ratio and compare it with the GAR.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Aligned exposures in the GAR | 0 to 60 EUR bn | 10.1 EUR bn |
| Covered assets, 2026/73 rule | 50 to 400 EUR bn | 151 EUR bn |
| Exposures outside CSRD scope | 0 to 150 EUR bn | 52 EUR bn |
| Estimated aligned exposures outside CSRD scope | 0 to 20 EUR bn | 1.3 EUR bn |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| GAR | 6.69 % |
| BTAR | 5.62 % |
| Estimated alignment of the non-CSRD book | 2.50 % |
| BTAR minus GAR | -1.07 points |
| Estimate needed for BTAR to equal GAR | 3.48 EUR bn |
Try it. Find the estimate at which the BTAR equals the GAR: Meridian would need to show that its SME and mid-cap book is as aligned as its covered book, almost three times its current estimate.
Result. The BTAR is 5.62%, below the GAR of 6.69%: the non-CSRD book is estimated at only 2.50% aligned. For the BTAR to equal the GAR, Meridian would have to evidence EUR 3.48bn of alignment in that book.
Reading. Under the original rules, the BTAR was always at least equal to the GAR, because both had the same denominator and the BTAR only added to the numerator; banks liked publishing it. Under the 2026 rules the GAR denominator already excludes the out-of-scope book, so the BTAR adds a population that is typically less aligned (SMEs rarely have the evidence the criteria require) and comes out lower. Meridian’s decision: compute the BTAR internally, use it to steer the SME green lending offer, and not publish it, since it rests on estimates that the auditor would scrutinise and no rule requires it. A contrarian argument, which the Group Sustainability Office makes, is that a bank serious about SMEs should publish it precisely because it is unflattering.
PITFALL — Mixing the two generations. Comparing a BTAR computed on the 2024 basis (denominator EUR 220bn: (10.1 + 1.3) / 220) with a GAR on the 2026 basis gives a meaningless difference. State the basis each time.
Question. Fill an extract of the Pillar 3 template on the banking book’s exposure to sectors that contribute to climate change, with financed emissions, and add the physical-risk headline.
Background. The template breaks down exposures to non-financial corporations by NACE sector, with the high-impact sectors of the Climate Benchmarks Regulation (NACE sections A to H and L) shown separately, fossil-fuel sector exposures identified, and financed emissions (scope 1, 2 and 3 of the counterparties, attributed as in PCAF, see A03) with the share coming from reported rather than estimated data. Unlike the GAR, it covers all non-financial corporations, inside or outside the CSRD scope: Pillar 3 is about risk, and risk does not depend on the client’s reporting obligation.
Data (case assumptions). Meridian’s banking-book exposures to non-financial corporations total EUR 112bn (the EUR 48bn, EUR 12bn and EUR 52bn lines of section 5.1). Average financed scope 1 and 2 emissions intensity per sector, from the PCAF model of E07 (tCO2e per EUR m of exposure): fossil fuels 420, power generation 260, manufacturing excluding refining 140, transport 180, construction and real estate 25, agriculture 300, other sectors 20. Exposures to counterparties located in areas exposed to acute or chronic physical hazards: EUR 9.4bn.
FORMULA
is the gross carrying amount to sector in EUR m; the attributed emissions per EUR m of exposure in that sector; the financed scope 1 and 2 emissions in tCO2e; the average intensity of the book.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Pillar 3 extract: exposures and financed emissions by sector
Fill the sector template from exposures and intensities, and read the share of high-impact and fossil-fuel sectors and the physical-risk headline.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Fossil fuels (mining, refining, gas supply) | 0 to 20 EUR bn | 4 EUR bn |
| Power generation | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 9 EUR bn |
| Manufacturing excl. refining | 0 to 60 EUR bn | 30 EUR bn |
| Transport | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 8 EUR bn |
| Construction and real estate | 0 to 50 EUR bn | 24 EUR bn |
| Agriculture | 0 to 20 EUR bn | 3 EUR bn |
| Other sectors | 0 to 60 EUR bn | 34 EUR bn |
| Intensity, power generation | 50 to 600 tCO2e per EUR m | 260 tCO2e per EUR m |
| Exposures in areas exposed to physical hazards | 0 to 40 EUR bn | 9.4 EUR bn |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Exposures to non-financial corporations | 112.0 EUR bn |
| Share in high-impact sectors (NACE A-H, L) | 69.6 % |
| Share in fossil-fuel sectors | 3.57 % |
| Financed scope 1 and 2 emissions | 11.84 MtCO2e |
| Average intensity | 105.7 tCO2e per EUR m |
| Share of emissions from fossil, power and manufacturing | 69.4 % |
| Share exposed to physical hazards | 8.4 % |
Try it. Halve the power sector’s intensity to 130 t per EUR m, as if the portfolio had moved to renewables: financed emissions fall by about 10% while the exposure is unchanged.
Result. The extract shows EUR 112bn of exposures to non-financial corporations, of which 69.6% in high-impact sectors and 3.57% in fossil-fuel sectors. Financed scope 1 and 2 emissions are 11.84 MtCO2e, an average of 105.7 tCO2e per EUR m. Fossil fuels, power and manufacturing produce 69.4% of the emissions on well under half of the exposure. EUR 9.4bn, 8.4% of the corporate book, is in areas exposed to physical hazards.
Reading. First, “high-impact” is a classification by sector, not a measure of risk: 70% of almost any corporate book is in sections A to H and L, because they include all of manufacturing, construction, transport and real estate. Readers who take the headline as “70% brown” misread it. Second, the emissions concentration is the useful information: three sectors carry most of the transition-risk exposure, which is where the credit and sector policies of E01 and the targets of E07 concentrate. Third, the template mixes reported and estimated emissions; the share of estimates must be shown, and at Meridian it is still above half for scope 3. Fourth, the GAR and this template are computed on different populations (EUR 151bn covered assets of all types versus EUR 112bn of corporate exposures in and out of CSRD scope), so no line of one can be read across to the other.
The other Pillar 3 templates, briefly. Three further tables complete the year-end disclosure. The alignment metrics table reports, for each carbon-intensive sector where Meridian has set a target (power, oil and gas, steel, cement, automotive, aviation, shipping, commercial real estate), the portfolio’s physical intensity, the baseline year, the reference scenario and the target for 2030; under the final draft the table gains standardised metrics and short- and long-term targets, and it is fed by the steering work of E07. The physical risk table shows exposures sensitive to acute and chronic hazards by sector and, under the final draft, by country rather than by NUTS 3 region; Meridian’s EUR 9.4bn comes from mapping collateral and production sites against hazard maps, a method whose limits are discussed in E08. The other mitigating actions table lists exposures that support climate change mitigation or adaptation without meeting the Taxonomy test (section 5.8). Each table states its data sources and the share of estimates, and each is cross-checked against the CSRD statement, because the same financed emissions appear in ESRS E1 as scope 3 category 15.
Question. Fill the extract of the template on loans collateralised by residential immovable property by energy performance class, and reconcile with the aligned mortgages of the GAR.
Data (case assumptions). Residential mortgages of EUR 70bn by EPC class of the collateral: A 3.5, B 6.0, C 12.0, D 15.0, E 9.0, F 4.5, G 2.0, and EUR 18.0bn without a certificate on file (mostly older loans). Typical primary energy demand by class (kWh per m2 per year): A 40, B 75, C 120, D 170, E 230, F 300, G 380.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Pillar 3 extract: mortgage collateral by energy performance class
Compute the coverage of energy certificates, the share of efficient and inefficient collateral, and the average energy demand of the mortgage book.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| EPC A | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 3.5 EUR bn |
| EPC B | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 6 EUR bn |
| EPC C | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 12 EUR bn |
| EPC D | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 15 EUR bn |
| EPC E | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 9 EUR bn |
| EPC F | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 4.5 EUR bn |
| EPC G | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 2 EUR bn |
| No certificate on file | 0 to 60 EUR bn | 18 EUR bn |
| Aligned mortgages in the GAR | 0 to 30 EUR bn | 5.6 EUR bn |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Mortgage book | 70.0 EUR bn |
| Share with a certificate | 74.3 % |
| Share in classes A and B (of total) | 13.6 % |
| Share in classes F and G (of certified) | 12.5 % |
| Average energy demand of certified collateral | 168.5 kWh/m2/yr |
| Class B loans counted as aligned (top 15%) | 2.10 EUR bn |
Try it. Move EUR 9bn from ‘no certificate’ to class C, as if a data-collection campaign found mostly average homes: coverage rises to 87% and the average energy demand falls.
Result. The mortgage book of EUR 70bn has a certificate on file for 74.3% of the exposure. Classes A and B are 13.6% of the book; classes F and G are 12.5% of the certified part. The average primary energy demand of certified collateral is about 168.5 kWh per m2 per year. Of the EUR 5.6bn of aligned mortgages, EUR 3.5bn are class A and EUR 2.1bn are class B loans that the bank has evidenced to be in the national top 15%.
Reading. The template and the GAR use the same certificates: the reconciliation (A plus evidenced top-15% B equals aligned) is one of the auditor’s favourite tests. The uncertified quarter of the book is the main data gap, and it is not neutral: older loans without certificates are probably on older, less efficient homes, so a naive average over certified loans flatters the book. The F and G classes matter beyond reporting, because the recast Energy Performance of Buildings Directive pushes member states to renovate the worst-performing stock, with an effect on collateral values (see B08 and E01).
Question. Before the Audit Committee, the CFO wants one table that explains every green figure Meridian publishes, so that no reader can find two numbers that seem to contradict each other.
Data (case assumptions). Five figures circulate:
INTERACTIVE LAB — One balance sheet, five green figures
Put the bank’s published green figures side by side, compute the ratios that link them and see which are stocks, flows, on or off balance sheet.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Aligned exposures in the GAR (stock) | 0 to 40 EUR bn | 10.1 EUR bn |
| Other mitigating actions, not aligned (stock) | 0 to 40 EUR bn | 6.8 EUR bn |
| Green bond eligible pool (stock) | 0 to 40 EUR bn | 5.1 EUR bn |
| Green bonds outstanding | 0.1 to 30 EUR bn | 3.5 EUR bn |
| Sustainable loans signed in the year (flow) | 0 to 40 EUR bn | 6 EUR bn |
| Labelled bonds facilitated in the year (flow) | 0 to 60 EUR bn | 12 EUR bn |
| Total assets | 100 to 600 EUR bn | 310 EUR bn |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Green or sustainability-linked exposures on balance sheet | 16.9 EUR bn |
| Of total assets | 5.45 % |
| Pool coverage of green bonds | 145.7 % |
| Pool as share of aligned exposures | 50.5 % |
| Sustainable finance volume of the year | 18.0 EUR bn |
| Of which facilitated, off balance sheet | 66.7 % |
Try it. Lower the pool to EUR 3.0bn: coverage falls below 100%, the bank is over-allocated and must explain unallocated proceeds in its green bond report.
Result. Green or sustainability-linked exposures on the balance sheet total EUR 16.9bn, 5.45% of total assets. The green bond pool covers the green bonds outstanding at 145.7% and is only 50.5% of the aligned exposures. The EUR 18.0bn “volume” is a flow, two-thirds of it (66.7%) bonds facilitated for clients that never sit on Meridian’s balance sheet.
Reading. The five figures answer five different questions: what share of assessable assets is aligned (GAR), what else the bank does that it considers green or transition-related (mitigating actions), what backs its own green bonds (pool), what it owes green bond investors (bonds outstanding), and what activity it generated in the year (volume). They differ in stock versus flow, on versus off balance sheet, and Taxonomy versus market standard. The pool is smaller than the aligned stock because the framework has stricter look-back and eligibility rules than the Taxonomy and because some aligned mortgages are kept out of the pool for covered bond purposes. None of these differences is a problem if a reader can find the bridge; each becomes a greenwashing allegation if the bridge is missing. Meridian’s statement therefore includes a reconciliation table, and the investor presentation footnotes the volume with its definition.
WHO DOES WHAT — The most frequent question from ESG analysts after publication is “why is your sustainable finance volume larger than your aligned assets?”. The answer is in the table: different period, different perimeter, different standard. Give it in one sentence and point to the footnote.
| Stage | Key figure | Value |
|---|---|---|
| 5.2 Denominator | Covered assets: original, partial, 2026/73 | EUR 220bn; 168bn; 151bn |
| 5.2 Denominator | GAR on the three bases | 4.59%; 6.01%; 6.69% |
| 5.2 Denominator | Change from definition alone; part due to non-CSRD | 2.10 points; 67.7% |
| 5.2 Denominator | Covered assets as share of total assets | 48.7% |
| 5.3 Numerator | Aligned, turnover basis; CapEx basis | EUR 10.10bn; 11.10bn |
| 5.3 Numerator | GAR turnover; GAR CapEx | 6.69%; 7.35% |
| 5.3 Numerator | Mortgages in aligned total | 55.4% |
| 5.4 Stock and flow | Flow GAR; stock GAR in five years | 10.0%; 8.53% |
| 5.4 Stock and flow | Half-life of the gap; effect of a EUR 500m deal | 4.27 years; 30.8 bp |
| 5.5 BTAR | BTAR; gap to GAR; break-even estimate | 5.62%; −1.07 points; EUR 3.48bn |
| 5.6 Sector template | High-impact share; fossil share | 69.6%; 3.57% |
| 5.6 Sector template | Financed emissions; intensity | 11.84 MtCO2e; 105.7 t per EUR m |
| 5.6 Sector template | Physical-risk share | 8.4% |
| 5.7 EPC template | Certified share; A and B share; F and G of certified | 74.3%; 13.6%; 12.5% |
| 5.7 EPC template | Average energy demand of certified collateral | 168.5 kWh/m2/yr |
| 5.8 Reconciliation | On-balance-sheet green stock; share of assets | EUR 16.9bn; 5.45% |
| 5.8 Reconciliation | Pool coverage; volume; facilitated share | 145.7%; EUR 18.0bn; 66.7% |
The sustainability reporting function has no balance sheet of its own. This section therefore looks at the economics in two ways: the cost and risk of the function itself, and what its metrics do (and do not do) to the economics of the loans it measures, taking the EUR 500m wind-farm loan of section 5.4 as the deal.
No Pillar 1 effect. None of the indicators of this module enters the calculation of RWA. A Taxonomy-aligned loan carries the same risk weight as any other loan to the same borrower: CRR3 contains no “green supporting factor”. Article 501c of the CRR asked the EBA to assess whether a dedicated prudential treatment of exposures related to environmental or social objectives would be justified; the EBA’s report on the role of environmental and social risks in the prudential framework (October 2023) did not recommend a dedicated green discount on capital and favoured targeted improvements to the existing tools. The infrastructure supporting factor (Article 501a CRR), used in B06, applies to qualifying infrastructure whether green or not.
Operational risk. The function’s own risks are operational: misstatement, a restatement, a regulatory sanction, litigation for misleading green claims. Under CRR3 operational risk capital follows the standardised approach based on the business indicator, so no capital is allocated to the reporting function as such; its risk is managed through controls and the operational risk framework, and greenwashing litigation is a scenario in the bank’s ICAAP (E10).
Pillar 2 and supervision. The ECB uses Pillar 3 ESG data and the bank’s own disclosures in its assessment of climate risk management; deficiencies can lead to qualitative findings, binding decisions and periodic penalty payments, as the published cases show (A02). Good disclosure is part of avoiding a Pillar 2 add-on, not a source of capital relief.
Data (case assumptions). EUR 500m 5-year term loan to a utility in CSRD scope, rated BBB (PD 0.20%), senior unsecured (F-IRB LGD 40%, M 2.5 years), proceeds used to build an offshore wind farm that passes the Taxonomy test. Net margin over FTP 95 bp (the FTP includes the 30 bp liquidity premium of a 5-year tenor); upfront fee of 50 bp, accrued at 10 bp a year. An interest-rate hedge sold alongside earns EUR 1.0m a year of ancillary revenue (cost-income 60%, EUR 2.5 of RWA per euro of revenue). Green features: Treasury’s 3 bp green FTP rebate for pool-eligible assets (C15), treated as revenue without operating cost; an annual cost of EUR 60,000 for the Taxonomy assessment (asset test, do-no-significant-harm evidence, minimum safeguards check, file for the auditor). Cost-income 40% on lending revenue.
FORMULA
is the net margin over FTP plus fees plus ancillary revenue (plus the green FTP rebate in the green case); the operating costs (40% of lending revenue, 60% of ancillary revenue, plus the assessment cost in the green case); the expected loss; the tax rate of 25%; the risk-weighted assets of the loan plus those of the ancillary business; , and the probability of default, loss given default and exposure at default.
INTERACTIVE LAB — RAROC of the EUR 500m aligned wind-farm loan, with and without its green features
Compute the RAROC of a Taxonomy-aligned corporate loan line by line and see how much the green FTP rebate and the assessment cost change it, compared with its effect on the GAR.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Loan amount | 50 to 2000 EUR m | 500 EUR m |
| One-year PD | 0.03 to 4 % | 0.2 % |
| Net margin over FTP | 30 to 300 bp | 95 bp |
| Annualised upfront fee | 0 to 40 bp | 10 bp |
| Ancillary revenue | 0 to 5 EUR m | 1 EUR m |
| Green FTP rebate | 0 to 10 bp | 3 bp |
| Annual Taxonomy assessment cost | 0 to 0.5 EUR m | 0.06 EUR m |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| F-IRB risk weight | 39.02 % |
| RWA, loan and ancillary | 197.6 EUR m |
| Allocated capital | 25.69 EUR m |
| Revenues, conventional case | 6.25 EUR m |
| Operating costs, conventional case | 2.70 EUR m |
| Expected loss | 0.40 EUR m |
| RAROC, loan alone | 8.13 % |
| RAROC with ancillary, conventional | 9.20 % |
| RAROC with ancillary and green features | 9.46 % |
| Net margin needed for 12% (green case) | 124.0 bp |
Try it. Set the rebate to 10 bp: the RAROC moves by well under a point. Then raise the margin until the green line crosses the hurdle. The GAR effect of the loan (30.8 bp, section 5.4) appears nowhere in this calculation.
Line by line. The F-IRB risk weight is 39.02%, so the loan and the hedge carry EUR 197.59m of RWA and EUR 25.69m of allocated capital. Revenues in the conventional case are EUR 6.25m (EUR 4.75m of margin, EUR 0.50m of fee accrual, EUR 1.0m of ancillary); operating costs EUR 2.70m; expected loss EUR 0.40m. The loan alone returns 8.13%; with the hedge, 9.20%; with the green features, 9.46%. To reach the 12% hurdle in the green case, the net margin would have to be 124.0 bp.
What the sustainable feature changes. Very little in RAROC: the rebate adds EUR 150,000 of revenue and the assessment costs EUR 60,000, a net gain of a quarter of a point. The loan is below the hurdle for the usual reasons of investment-grade lending (thin margin, full capital), and a green label does not fix that. Its value for the bank lies elsewhere: 30.8 bp of GAR, eligibility for the green bond pool, a relationship with a client that will need much more financing (B07), and a decision by the credit committee that it is strategically acceptable below the hurdle. Some banks put a shadow value on GAR points in their pricing tools; Meridian does not, because a ratio that can move 2.1 points through a definitional change is a poor basis for a transfer price.
PITFALL — Counting the green FTP rebate as value created. It is a transfer inside the bank: Treasury gives up 3 bp so that the business line gains 3 bp. It is economically justified only to the extent the green bond issued against the pool saves the bank funding cost (C15), which on the evidence of C01 is a few basis points at most.
The reporting team does not manage liquidity, but its outputs feed Treasury in two ways. First, the eligible pool of green and EU Green Bonds is a subset of the aligned exposures and of the mitigating-actions exposures; Treasury relies on the reporting team’s flags to size green issuance and to keep coverage above its buffer (C15). A wrong flag can create over-allocation, a reportable breach of the green bond framework. Second, green deposits offered to corporate clients consume the same pool and must be tracked in it. In the liquidity metrics themselves (LCR, NSFR) a green asset or liability is treated exactly like its conventional twin.
Gross carrying amount. The GAR, the BTAR and the Pillar 3 templates use the IFRS 9 gross carrying amount, before the expected credit loss allowance. A stage 3 loan stays in the GAR denominator at its gross amount until it is written off, and a written-off aligned loan leaves the numerator, a small but real source of volatility.
ESG-linked features. The IASB’s May 2024 amendments to IFRS 9 and IFRS 7 on the classification and measurement of financial instruments, effective for periods beginning on or after 1 January 2026, clarify how to assess the contractual cash flows of loans with ESG-linked features (such as sustainability-linked margin ratchets, see B03) and add disclosures. Most such loans remain at amortised cost; the reporting team must make sure that the accounting classification and the sustainability tagging use the same product data.
Provisions. A greenwashing claim or regulatory proceeding may require a provision or a contingent liability disclosure under IAS 37; the sustainability statement and the notes to the accounts must tell the same story.
Connectivity. ESRS require the sustainability statement to refer to the financial statements where figures overlap (for example, the carrying amounts of exposures used in the GAR). Meridian presents a reconciliation from total assets to covered assets, the bridge of section 5.2, which also helps the auditor.
This module is about the metrics themselves; the summary of their effects is section 5.9. Two points remain: what producing them costs, and how the 2026 simplifications change that cost.
Data (case assumptions). Meridian’s annual cost of the sustainability reporting chain: 22 full-time equivalents at a loaded cost of EUR 0.13m each; external data vendors EUR 2.5m; IT run and change EUR 4.0m; the assurance fee for the sustainability statement EUR 1.6m; external advisers EUR 0.8m. Finance estimates that data, IT and adviser costs are driven by the number of datapoints, and that the simplifications (revised ESRS, Delegated Regulation 2026/73, Pillar 3 final draft) could cut those costs by 25% from 2027, once the change projects are paid for.
INTERACTIVE LAB — What Meridian’s sustainability reporting costs, and what simplification saves
Build the annual cost of the reporting chain and estimate the saving from the 2026 simplifications.
| Parameter you can move | Range | Default |
|---|---|---|
| Full-time equivalents | 5 to 80 FTE | 22 FTE |
| Loaded cost per FTE | 0.05 to 0.3 EUR m | 0.13 EUR m |
| Data vendors | 0 to 10 EUR m | 2.5 EUR m |
| IT run and change | 0 to 20 EUR m | 4 EUR m |
| Assurance fee | 0 to 5 EUR m | 1.6 EUR m |
| External advisers | 0 to 5 EUR m | 0.8 EUR m |
| Saving on datapoint-driven costs | 0 to 60 % | 25 % |
| Result at default settings | Value |
|---|---|
| Annual cost | 11.76 EUR m |
| Staff share of cost | 24.3 % |
| Annual saving from simplification | 1.82 EUR m |
| Annual cost after simplification | 9.94 EUR m |
| Cost per EUR bn of total assets (310) | 37.9 EUR k |
Try it. Set the saving to zero: the fixed cost of people and assurance does not fall with the number of datapoints, which is why banks report less relief than the headline percentages suggest.
Result. The chain costs EUR 11.76m a year, of which staff are only 24.3%; the rest is data, systems, assurance and advice. A 25% cut in datapoint-driven costs saves EUR 1.83m, bringing the cost to EUR 9.93m. The cost is EUR 37.9k per EUR bn of total assets.
Reading. The headline reductions (89% fewer Taxonomy datapoints for financial undertakings in the Commission’s estimate, 37% fewer Pillar 3 datapoints for large institutions, more than 60% fewer mandatory ESRS datapoints) do not translate into the same cut in cost. The expensive parts (golden-source counterparty data, lineage, controls, assurance) are needed whatever the number of cells in the templates, and the risk and pricing functions use the same data. The real saving comes from not having to chase SMEs for Taxonomy evidence, which the new denominator makes pointless for the GAR.
| Risk | Example | Control | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wrong CSRD scope flag | Mid-cap kept in denominator after leaving scope | Annual scope review, register checks | ESG data office |
| Stale counterparty KPI | Prior-year KPI used without disclosure | KPI date field, ageing report | Data analysts |
| Double counting | Use-of-proceeds loan also weighted by KPI | Engine priority rule, exception report | GAR lead |
| Undocumented alignment | Mortgage flagged A without certificate | Evidence check on samples | Retail operations |
| Break in series hidden | 2025 and 2026 GAR compared directly | Restated comparative, disclosure | Head of reporting |
| Inconsistent public figures | Volume quoted as “green assets” | Reconciliation table, sign-off | Investor Relations |
| Misuse of opt-out | Opt-out taken while claiming alignment | Legal review of all claims | Legal, Compliance |
| Draft rules applied as law | Pillar 3 filed on unadopted ITS without note | Legal status check at close | Regulatory reporting |
| Manual adjustments | Late top-side entry to reach a target | Adjustment log, four eyes | Controls manager |
| Estimates presented as data | BTAR estimates mixed with reported KPIs | Data quality score per line | Data analysts |
| Model risk in emissions | Wrong sector proxy factor | Model validation | Credit risk, validation |
| Assurance failure | Auditor cannot trace sample loans | Lineage documentation | Controls manager |
Two controls deserve a comment. The CSRD scope flag is now the most consequential attribute in the GAR. When a client’s status is uncertain (for example, a group close to the 1,000-employee threshold, or a member state that has not yet transposed the Omnibus), Meridian’s rule is to keep the exposure in the denominator until evidence shows it is out of scope: the conservative choice lowers the ratio rather than inflating it. The legal status check at close addresses the unusual situation of FY2026: the Pillar 3 ITS that everyone is preparing for may or may not be adopted by the reference date. The disclosure must state which version of the templates was used and why.
Greenwashing red flags in a bank’s own reporting.
WHY IT MATTERS ON THE DESK — European supervisors define greenwashing as a claim that does not clearly and fairly reflect the underlying sustainability profile. A bank’s own reporting is a claim. The reporting team is therefore part of the bank’s first defence against greenwashing, not just a producer of tables (see E10).
Regulatory calendar, verified to November 2026.
Orders of magnitude. Published GARs of large European banks have been in the low single digits since the first disclosures in 2024, with a wide dispersion driven by the weight of mortgages and by methodological choices; FY2026 ratios will be higher for most banks because of the new denominator, and not comparable with earlier years without restatement. Turnover-based GARs are typically below CapEx-based ones. Coverage of energy certificates on mortgage books varies widely between countries, depending on national certificate databases.
What changed recently, in one sentence each. The GAR became a ratio on the assessable part of the balance sheet; the BTAR is losing its regulatory home; Pillar 3 moved from Taxonomy alignment to risk (sectors, emissions, physical risk, alignment metrics); the CSRD covers far fewer of the bank’s clients, which means more estimates in the bank’s own scope 3.
Open debates.
INTERACTIVE LAB — Self-assessment: the bank’s sustainability reporting
Fourteen questions on CSRD, the GAR, the BTAR, Pillar 3 ESG and controls.
Q1. Which act changed the GAR denominator for FY2026 reports?
Answer: B. Delegated Regulation 2026/73 amends the Disclosures Delegated Act 2021/2178; it was published on 8 January 2026 and applies from 1 January 2026.
Q2. Under the 2026 rules, exposures to undertakings outside the CSRD scope are:
Answer: B. The amended Article 7(3) and Annex V exclude them from both, with a carve-back for SPVs financing in-scope groups.
Q3. Until when may a financial undertaking that claims no Taxonomy alignment skip the detailed Taxonomy KPIs?
Answer: C. Article 7(9) applies until 31 December 2027, on condition that the undertaking publishes the prescribed statement and claims no alignment.
Q4. Meridian’s covered assets are EUR 151bn and aligned exposures EUR 10.1bn. What is its GAR?
Answer: C. 10.1 / 151 = 6.69%. 4.59% and 6.01% use older denominators; 7.35% is the CapEx-based GAR.
Q5. A general-purpose loan of EUR 200m to a company with 30% aligned turnover and 50% aligned CapEx contributes to the turnover-based numerator:
Answer: B. The exposure is weighted by the counterparty’s turnover KPI: 200 x 30% = EUR 60m; EUR 100m is the CapEx-based contribution.
Q6. Why is Meridian’s BTAR now lower than its GAR?
Answer: B. The 2026 GAR denominator already excludes the non-CSRD book; the BTAR brings it back with an estimated alignment of only 2.5%.
Q7. What does the EBA’s final draft Pillar 3 ITS of June 2026 do with Taxonomy disclosures for large institutions?
Answer: B. Taxonomy-related disclosures are stopped in Pillar 3 to avoid duplication with the CSRD statement; the GAR stays in the CSRD statement.
Q8. What is the legal status of that final draft ITS in mid-November 2026?
Answer: B. The EBA submitted it to the Commission for adoption; the first reference date of 31 December 2026 is expected subject to the Commission’s work.
Q9. The Pillar 3 sector template covers exposures to non-financial corporations:
Answer: C. Pillar 3 is about risk, which does not depend on the client’s reporting obligation.
Q10. Which threshold defines CSRD scope after Directive (EU) 2026/470?
Answer: C. Both conditions must be met; 5,000 and EUR 1.5bn are the CSDDD thresholds.
Q11. Under double materiality, a topic is reported when:
Answer: B. Either impact materiality or financial materiality is sufficient.
Q12. What kind of assurance does the statutory auditor give on the sustainability statement?
Answer: B. Limited assurance, a negative-form conclusion; the Omnibus abandoned the planned move to reasonable assurance.
Q13. A EUR 500m fully aligned loan added to Meridian’s book raises the GAR by about:
Answer: B. (10.1 + 0.5) / 151.5 = 7.00% against 6.69%: about 31 bp. 2.1 points is the effect of the change of definition.
Q14. Which statement about the green FTP rebate on an aligned loan is correct?
Answer: B. It moves revenue between Treasury and the business line; it creates value only if green funding is cheaper.
A bank has total assets of EUR 120bn: sovereigns and central banks EUR 20bn, trading book EUR 10bn, exposures to undertakings outside CSRD scope EUR 25bn, derivatives, on-demand interbank, cash and goodwill EUR 9bn. Aligned exposures are EUR 3.6bn. Compute the GAR under the original rule and under the 2026/73 rule, and the change due to definition.
Solution. Original covered assets: 120 − 20 − 10 = EUR 90bn; GAR = 3.6 / 90 = 4.00%. New covered assets: 90 − 25 − 9 = EUR 56bn; GAR = 3.6 / 56 = 6.43%. The change is 2.43 points, entirely definitional. Removing only the non-CSRD exposures would give 3.6 / 65 = 5.54%, so 1.54 of the 2.43 points (63%) come from the scope rule. The bank must present its prior-year GAR on the new basis or explain the break.
A bank’s covered assets under the 2026 rule are EUR 80bn: mortgages EUR 30bn (6% aligned), general-purpose corporate loans in scope EUR 35bn (weighted turnover KPI 5%, CapEx KPI 9%), use-of-proceeds loans EUR 5bn (40% aligned), other covered assets EUR 10bn (none aligned). New in-scope lending in the year is EUR 12bn, of which EUR 1.5bn aligned; the book runs off at 20% a year and is replaced. Compute both GARs, the flow GAR and the stock GAR (turnover) after three years.
Solution. Aligned on turnover: 30 × 6% + 35 × 5% + 5 × 40% = 1.80 + 1.75 + 2.00 = EUR 5.55bn; GAR = 5.55 / 80 = 6.94%. On CapEx: 1.80 + 35 × 9% + 2.00 = 1.80 + 3.15 + 2.00 = EUR 6.95bn; GAR = 8.69%. Flow GAR = 1.5 / 12 = 12.5%. After three years: 12.5 + (6.94 − 12.5) × 0.8³ = 12.5 − 5.56 × 0.512 = 12.5 − 2.85 = 9.65%. The stock ratio closes more than half the gap in three years because the book is short.
A EUR 300m 5-year loan to an A-rated company (PD 0.07%, LGD 40%, M 2.5) finances a Taxonomy-aligned building portfolio. Net margin over FTP 70 bp, annualised fee 8 bp, no ancillary business, green FTP rebate 2 bp, assessment cost EUR 40,000 a year. The F-IRB risk weight at PD 0.07% is 21.36%. Compute the RAROC with and without the green features (cost-income 40%, capital 13% of RWA, tax 25%).
Solution. RWA = 300 × 21.36% = EUR 64.09m; capital = 13% × 64.09 = EUR 8.33m. Lending revenue = 300 × 0.78% = EUR 2.34m; costs = 40% × 2.34 = EUR 0.936m; EL = 300 × 0.07% × 40% = EUR 0.084m. Conventional RAROC = (2.34 − 0.936 − 0.084) × 0.75 / 8.33 = 0.990 / 8.33 = 11.88%, just below the hurdle. Green: revenue + 300 × 0.02% = + EUR 0.06m; costs + EUR 0.04m; profit before tax EUR 1.34m; RAROC = 1.34 × 0.75 / 8.33 = 12.06%. The green features add 0.18 points and happen to tip the loan over the hurdle: a reminder that a transfer price inside the bank can decide marginal deals, which is why its justification (real funding savings) matters.
1. Why are banks’ Green Asset Ratios so low? Mostly by construction. Under the original rules, exposures to companies outside the reporting perimeter, derivatives, interbank and cash sat in the denominator but could never be in the numerator, while a general-purpose loan only counts in proportion to the client’s own aligned turnover, which is low for most companies. Mortgages count only with evidence of top energy performance. The 2026 rules removed the non-assessable items from the denominator, so ratios rise, but they still depend on client data and on the weight of mortgages more than on the bank’s green lending effort.
2. What did Delegated Regulation 2026/73 change for banks? It made the GAR a ratio on assessable assets: exposures to undertakings outside the CSRD scope, derivatives, on-demand interbank loans, cash and goodwill now leave the denominator as well as the numerator. It cut the number of datapoints, introduced materiality thresholds, deferred the trading book and fee KPIs to 2028, and let financial undertakings skip the detailed KPIs until the end of 2027 if they claim no alignment. It applies to FY2026 reports.
3. Would you advise a bank to use the opt-out? Only if it genuinely makes no Taxonomy claims anywhere: no EU Green Bonds, no “aligned” product marketing, no alignment figure for investors. For a bank active in green funding the opt-out is inconsistent with its other communication and creates greenwashing risk. It can make sense for a smaller bank without green issuance that wants to avoid the cost for two years.
4. What is the BTAR and why does it matter less now? The BTAR extends the GAR numerator to exposures outside the reporting perimeter, mainly SMEs, using estimates. It was created in the Pillar 3 templates to correct the GAR’s asymmetry. With the new GAR denominator the asymmetry is gone, the BTAR typically comes out below the GAR, and the June 2026 Pillar 3 final draft stops Taxonomy disclosures, so it becomes voluntary.
5. What will the bank’s Pillar 3 ESG disclosure look like at end-2026? If the Commission adopts the EBA’s June 2026 final draft in time, a large bank will publish qualitative ESG risk information, exposures to non-financial corporations by sector with financed emissions (scopes shown separately), energy performance of real-estate collateral, alignment metrics with baselines and targets, physical risk by country and other mitigating actions, but no Taxonomy templates. If not adopted, the existing templates apply, read with the EBA’s no-action letter. A careful bank documents which version it used.
6. How do you make a sustainability KPI auditable? By treating it like a financial number: a single reconciled exposure file, golden-source reference data with dates and sources, a documented methodology note, a calculation engine with logged parameters, a register of manual adjustments with approvals, and lineage that lets the auditor go from the published percentage to the individual contract and the evidence behind its flag.
7. How does the GAR relate to the bank’s RAROC? It does not enter it. An aligned loan carries the same risk weight and expected loss as any other loan to the same borrower. Some banks add a small green FTP rebate or a shadow value, but these are internal transfers; the economic value of green lending comes from the client franchise and from cheaper green funding where it exists, which is small.
8. Your CEO wants to announce that the GAR rose by two points. What do you say? That two points came from the change of definition, not from business, and that announcing it as progress would be misleading and contradicted by the restated comparative in the statement. I would propose communicating the flow GAR of new business and its trend, which reflects decisions taken this year, and explaining the definitional change once, with the bridge.
EU legislation (EUR-Lex identifiers).
EBA.
Commentary used to cross-check.
Standards.
Books.
Related modules. A02 (regulatory stack), A03 (carbon data and PCAF), C01 and C15 (green bonds and the eligible pool), E01 (credit risk), E02 (capital), E07 (financed emissions and targets), E10 (greenwashing).